Design and analysis of thickness dimension for large aperture plane optical window of aerial electro-optics

Gang Cheng, Huilin Wang, Bo Zhang, Tao Wang, 吕恒 Lü Heng, Cao Yinqi, Fan Zhou, Zhou FanJournal of Applied Optics 2025 · DOI

Abstract

For aerial electro-optical equipment, the thickness of the optical window is a critical factor influencing imaging performance once the configuration and combination forms are established. This study analyzes the design problem from three perspectives: design variables, combination forms, and applied loads. A design target for plane window thickness was determined based on structural rigidity and Root Mean Square (RMS) wavefront error. By quantitatively solving for the first-order structural resonance frequency and RMS wavefront error under temperature and pressure loads, a thickness range of 11.9 mm to 18.4 mm was identified. An integrated analysis workflow was proposed to calculate performance under combined flight conditions (flow field, gravity, and vibration). Results for a 16 mm design showed a first-order resonance frequency of 151 Hz and an RMS wavefront error of less than 1/10λ. Experimental tests validated these findings, with measured RMS errors below 0.07λ and clear imaging during flight, confirming the effectiveness of the design methodology.

The Challenge of Large-Aperture Windows

Aerial electro-optical sensors, essential for surveillance and reconnaissance, require protective windows that maintain optical integrity under extreme conditions. As sensor apertures increase, these windows become structural elements subjected to aerodynamic pressure, thermal gradients, and mechanical vibrations at high altitudes (e.g., 18,000 m) and speeds (e.g., 1,050 km/h). These factors cause surface deformation, leading to wavefront errors that degrade image quality. Finding the optimal thickness—balancing structural stiffness against thermal distortion—is a complex engineering challenge often referred to as finding the "Goldilocks" thickness: too thin, and the window deforms under pressure; too thick, and thermal gradients create internal distortions.

Integrated Analysis Workflow

The research employs an integrated analysis workflow to bridge mechanical stress and optical performance:

  1. Analytical Modeling: Establishing baseline thickness requirements using plate theory to ensure resonance frequencies stay above 150 Hz.
  2. Multi-Physics Simulation: Using CFD (ANSYS Fluent) for aerodynamic loads and FEA (ANSYS Workbench) for structural and modal analysis.
  3. Optical Mapping: Surface deformations are converted into Zernike polynomials via Matlab to quantify wavefront errors.
  4. Optical Evaluation: CodeV is used to simulate the final image quality across various field angles.

The study specifically evaluates multi-spectral Zinc Sulfide (m-ZnS) for its superior mechanical and optical properties in harsh environments.

Key Insights: The "Thickness Window" and Mounting Strategy

A pivotal finding is the quantification of the viable "thickness window." For the system studied, the thickness must fall between 11.9 mm (to resist pressure-induced deformation) and 18.4 mm (to minimize thermal gradient distortion). A thickness of 16 mm was selected as the optimal design point.

Furthermore, the mounting method is critical for performance. Rather than rigid clamping, the study utilizes a "peripheral adhesive" approach.

Cross-sectional diagram of the optical window assembly, showing the peripheral adhesive mounting strategy.

As shown in the assembly diagram, the window is secured using structural and sealing glues. This flexible mounting allows for slight thermal expansion and contraction, significantly reducing stress concentrations that could otherwise lead to material failure or severe optical distortion.

Results and Validation

The 16 mm design achieved a first-order resonance frequency of 151.17 Hz, successfully avoiding low-frequency aircraft jitter. Structural analysis showed a maximum stress of 6.15 MPa, providing a safety factor of 11.2, well above the aerospace requirement of 1.5.

Optically, the design maintained an RMS wavefront error below 0.07λ (λ = 632.8 nm) under combined load conditions, exceeding the standard diffraction-limited requirement of 0.1λ. Flight tests confirmed these results, with both visible (TV) and infrared (IR) sensors producing stable, high-resolution imagery during high-speed maneuvers.

Conclusion and Future Work

The proposed integrated analysis workflow provides a robust framework for designing large-aperture aerial windows. By accurately predicting the interplay between mechanical loads and optical wavefront errors, engineers can optimize window thickness to ensure mission success. Future research will focus on weight optimization for aerial platforms and applying this workflow to complex curved "conformal" windows, which present even greater aerodynamic and optical challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

航空光电装备平面光学窗口在确定构型尺寸和组合形式后,窗口厚度对装备成像性能影响至为关键。从设计变量、组合形式、作用载荷3个方面对窗口设计问题进行分析,确定了基于结构刚性和RMS(root mean square)波前误差的平面窗口厚度设计目标;从光学窗口一阶结构谐振频率及其在温度和压力载荷作用下的RMS波前误差量化求解出窗口厚度尺寸范围11.9 mm ~18.4 mm;提出针对光学窗口组合工况性能计算的集成分析流程,计算得到光学窗口一阶谐振频率为 151 Hz,在飞行工作时各向组合工况−流场/重力/振动作用下光学窗口RMS波前误差不大于1/10参考波长。实验测试结果表明:光学窗口RMS波前误差小于0.07参考波长,实物样机振动和飞行条件下成像清晰、稳定,证明窗口厚度尺寸设计分析方法正确有效。
BibTeX
@article{cheng2025design,
  author = {Gang Cheng and Huilin Wang and Bo Zhang and Tao Wang and 吕恒 Lü Heng and CAO Yinqi and Fan Zhou and ZHOU Fan},
  title = {{Design and analysis of thickness dimension for large aperture plane optical window of aerial electro-optics}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Optics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.5768/jao202546.0301005},
}
Figure