Optical design of spherical zone projection lens for small and medium-sized flight simulator

Xiaochan Liu, Chen Chen, Tao Song, Weishan Li, Xin Zhang, Song Gao, Bo Yang, Yang BoJournal of Applied Optics 2023 · DOI

Abstract

To address the need for miniaturization and cost reduction in immersive flight simulators, this paper presents the design of a specialized spherical zone projection lens. The system utilizes an off-axis projection scheme where a single projector, equipped with a 172° wide-angle lens and a 6:1 retrofocus ratio, is positioned at the screen's edge to fill the entire spherical zone. The design employs an 8-lens configuration using cost-effective materials, achieving 4K resolution with an MTF exceeding 0.4 at 185 lp/mm. Key innovations include the optimization of illumination uniformity and the utilization of screen curvature to compensate for field curvature, resulting in high pixel efficiency and superior image quality.

Introduction

Immersive flight simulators are critical for pilot training, traditionally relying on large-scale spherical dome screens. However, these systems are often prohibitively expensive and require significant space. Smaller systems typically place a projector at the center of the dome, which interferes with the pilot's position and causes shadowing. Furthermore, central projection often wastes over 50% of available pixels because the circular image does not align efficiently with the rectangular sensor. This paper describes an off-axis projection system that overcomes these limitations by placing the projector at the periphery of the screen.

Design Methodology and Geometry

The core of the system is a high-performance inverted-telephoto (retrofocus) lens. To cover the entire 180° horizontal and 85° vertical spherical zone from an edge position, the lens was designed with an ultra-wide 172° field of view (FOV).

Horizontal projection scheme illustrating the 172° field of view required to cover the 180° spherical screen from an off-axis position.

Key technical features of the lens include:

  • High Retrofocus Ratio: A 6:1 ratio (back focal length to effective focal length) was implemented to accommodate the internal prisms of a 4K DLP projector.
  • Lens Configuration: The assembly uses 8 elements, prioritizing low-cost glass types (e.g., H-LAF1 and H-FK61) while correcting for the extreme aberrations inherent in fisheye designs.
  • Illumination Engineering: To prevent the significant brightness drop-off (vignetting) common in wide-angle lenses, the incident angle at the first lens surface was optimized to maintain a relative illumination of 68% at the edges.

Imaging Performance and Optimization

A significant finding in this design is the role of the spherical screen in image correction. The screen's curvature naturally compensates for the lens's field curvature, allowing for sharper focus at the edges than would be possible on a flat surface.

Vertical optical path demonstrating how the 172° FOV lens covers the 85° vertical span of the simulator screen.

By optimizing the imaging area on the DLP chip for this off-axis geometry, the researchers increased pixel utilization from the standard ~40% to between 75% and 90%. This ensures that the 4K resolution of the projector is used effectively across the entire field of view.

Key Results

The final lens design provides high-quality 4K projection in a compact form factor (maximum diameter of 78 mm).

  • Resolution: The Modulation Transfer Function (MTF) remains above 0.4 at the Nyquist frequency of 185 lp/mm across all fields, ensuring high contrast and sharpness.
  • Distortion: Relative distortion is controlled within 13.2% relative to the ideal equidistant projection model ($y = f\theta$).
  • Manufacturability: The use of only 8 lenses and standard glass types makes the system highly cost-effective and suitable for mass production.

Conclusion

The designed spherical zone projection lens successfully meets the requirements for compact, low-cost, and high-resolution flight simulators. By moving the projector to the screen edge and utilizing an ultra-wide-angle lens, the system avoids pilot occlusion and maximizes pixel efficiency. Future research will involve physical prototyping and thermal stability testing to ensure performance during extended training sessions.

Summary updated

Abstract

针对现有沉浸式飞行模拟器进一步小型化和低成本化的需求,设计了一款应用于中小型飞行模拟器的球带幕投影镜头。论文确定了投影方案中各部件(球带幕、投影机、投影物镜)的关键参数,设计的球带幕投影镜头具有172°的视场角和6∶1的反远比,将一台装有该镜头的投影机置于银幕上沿就可以将画面投满整个球带幕。文中给出了大视场、大反远比光学系统的构造方法,对大视场非相似成像系统中的畸变、场曲和相对照度进行了分析和讨论,并给出了改善照度均匀性的有效途径。该镜头以8片透镜的低成本结构满足了4 k分辨率的高质量投影需求,在奈奎斯特频率185 lp/mm处全部视场的MTF值均达到了0.4以上,且具有良好的工艺性。
BibTeX
@article{liu2023optical,
  author = {Xiaochan Liu and Chen Chen and Tao Song and Weishan Li and Xin Zhang and Song Gao and Bo Yang and YANG Bo},
  title = {{Optical design of spherical zone projection lens for small and medium-sized flight simulator}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Optics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.5768/jao202344.0101005},
}
Figure