A Study on Competitiveness in the Aircraft Industry

Jaesung Lee2019 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the relative competitiveness of the aerospace industries in the United States and the United Kingdom. Utilizing trade data from the UN Comtrade database spanning 2000 to 2018, the research employs three primary economic indices: the Trade Specialization Index (TSI), Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA), and Market Share Analysis. The results indicate that the USA maintains a significant comparative advantage, functioning as a dominant export specialist with RCA values consistently exceeding 7.0. While the UK remains a robust player with a focus on high-value R&D, the USA's market share and component-level dominance underscore an "overpoweringly superior" competitive position.

Introduction

The aerospace industry represents a pinnacle of high-value manufacturing and technological prestige. For developed nations, it is not merely an "infant industry" but a cornerstone of national wealth and strategic capability. Understanding the nuances of international competitiveness in this sector requires moving beyond simple production volumes to analyze trade dynamics and comparative advantages. This paper examines the bilateral trade relationship between the USA and the UK to quantify strategic dominance in this capital-intensive field.

Methodology

To assess competitiveness, this study utilizes a tripartite analytical framework:

  1. Trade Specialization Index (TSI): Measures a country's status as an export or import specialist relative to a partner. A value of +1 signifies pure export specialization.
  2. Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA): Compares a country's share of specific product exports to its share of total world exports. Values above 1.0 indicate a comparative advantage.
  3. Market Share Analysis: Evaluates the proportion of the global aerospace export market held by each nation.

The US-UK Competitive Landscape

The analysis reveals a stark contrast between the two nations. While the UK aerospace industry is internally resilient—accounting for 4% of manufacturing value-added and maintaining a consistent trade surplus—it operates as an "import specialist" relative to the United States.

Trade and Comparative Advantage

From 2000 to 2018, the USA's TSI against the UK remained consistently positive (ranging from 0.31 to 0.59), reflecting a strong export specialization. The RCA values for the US were exceptionally high, peaking at 8.997 in 2005 and remaining at 7.90 in 2018. These figures suggest that the US aerospace industry is not just a leader but a global outlier in terms of comparative advantage.

Component-Level Dominance

The US's lead is particularly evident in critical components. By 2017, the US provided approximately 65.9% of propellers and 46.8% of airframe supports to the global market, serving as a primary supplier for the UK's own manufacturing needs.

US Market Share for Propellers and Other Components (2015-2017)
US Market Share for Airframe Supports and Other Components (2015-2017)

Strategic Resilience and Future Outlook

The UK has attempted to mitigate its smaller market share through aggressive R&D investment, ranking second only to the pharmaceutical sector in national research spending. Firms like Rolls-Royce and BAE Systems remain global leaders in innovation. However, the "overpowering" statistical lead of the US—with a market share nearly ten times that of the UK in certain years—remains the defining characteristic of the industry.

Future shifts may arise from geopolitical changes, such as the long-term impacts of Brexit on supply chains, or the rise of emerging aerospace powers. For now, the data confirms the USA's position as the world's preeminent aerospace export specialist.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose - This study shows that which country has more competitiveness in aerospace industry. The reason why author choose aerospace industry for research is aerospace industry is one of major business in every country in the world instead of infant industry. Research design and methodology - In order to research this topic, there are 3 tools to analyze competitiveness in aerospace industry. To achieve analysis of competitiveness between USA and England, UN comtrade program which provides huge database including time serial data. Results - All of TSI are over zero (0) which means that from 2000 to 2018, USA aerospace industry is export specialization as USA aerospace industry has comparative advantage against England aerospace industry. All of TSI in USA are approaching to figure +1 as export specialization except 2010. Conclusions - Even though RCA value in 2000 is 6.313, however, when time goes by and they are 8.997 in 2005, 8.007 in 2010 and 8.389 in 2015 respectively and RCA value is slightly going down as figure 7 in 2018. we review above market share analysis data, USA has overpoweringly superior competitive power against British aerospace industry.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2019study,
  author = {Jaesung Lee},
  title = {{A Study on Competitiveness in the Aircraft Industry}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.20498/eajbe.2019.7.3.49},
}
Figure