The Research of an Evaluation Indicator System Design for the Core Competitiveness of Aerospace Enterprises from a Dual Capacity Perspective

Dong Li, Chu-gui Zheng, Yun-tang Zhang2017 · DOI

Abstract

Through comprehensive analysis of Chinese and foreign literature on the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises, the factors influencing the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises in China are summarized, followed by the analysis made based on such elements as the resource capacity, technical capacity, product capacity and environment capacity of aerospace enterprises. From a dual-capacity perspective, a model for identification of the factors influencing the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises is constructed, with thirteen influencing factors selected by means of expert questionnaire survey, with evaluation of each indicator conducted respectively, followed by screening based on the importance of each influencing factor, with four capacities and eight indicator factors relating to the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises from a dual-capacity perspective finally selected.

Introduction

China’s aerospace industry has achieved significant milestones, yet it remains positioned within the "second echelon" of global aerospace powers, trailing the technological leaders in the United States and Russia. Historically, Chinese aerospace enterprises relied on the imitation and absorption of foreign technologies. However, as Western nations implement increasingly stringent "technological lock-in" strategies, the path of imitation has reached its limits. The industry now faces a critical mandate: shifting toward independent innovation and self-reliance.

This transition is complicated by the unique structural challenges of the Chinese aerospace sector, specifically the "military-to-civil" transition. In times of peace, a decrease in military orders necessitates that these high-tech giants adapt their specialized capabilities—such as satellite relay, advanced materials, and precision engineering—for commercial markets. Despite the importance of this shift, there has been a lack of a standardized, quantitative framework to evaluate how these "dual capacity" enterprises can build and sustain a competitive edge in both military and civil spheres.

The Dual-Capacity Framework

To address this gap, the researchers developed a conceptual model that categorizes the drivers of competitiveness into four primary dimensions: Resource Capacity, Technical Capacity, Product Capacity, and Environment Capacity. This framework acknowledges that competitiveness is not merely a result of internal assets but is a dynamic outcome of how an enterprise interacts with its external environment and leverages its technical output in the marketplace.

Conceptual model of factors influencing the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises.

As illustrated in the model above, these four capacities interact to create basic, unique, and sustainable competitive advantages. For instance, technical and product factors often provide the immediate "unique" advantage, while resource and environmental factors provide the foundation for "sustainable" long-term competitiveness.

Methodological Approach

The study employed a multi-stage, expert-driven methodology to refine the evaluation system:

  1. Literature Synthesis: An initial pool of 13 influencing factors was identified through a review of global academic research.
  2. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP): This mathematical tool was used to quantify subjective expert judgments. The researchers engaged 10 prominent scholars and industry experts specialized in the Chinese aerospace landscape to rank the relative importance of the 13 factors.
  3. Weighting and Screening: AHP allowed for the calculation of specific weights for each factor. To ensure the model remained focused and actionable, any factor with a calculated weight of less than 0.1 was eliminated. This process reduced the initial 13 factors to a final set of eight critical indicators.

Key Insights and Results

The final evaluation system highlights the specific priorities required for success in the dual-capacity environment.

Technical and Product Capacities

In the technical realm, the paper emphasizes the "Two Overalls" strategy: "Two overalls inside, middle outside, key parts in hand." This philosophy dictates that enterprises should maintain internal control over overall design and core "key" technologies while outsourcing non-essential subsystems to maximize efficiency. Consequently, Technical Innovation Capacity (Weight: 0.5000) and Cooperative Research Capacity (0.4375) emerged as the dominant indicators.

Regarding product capacity, Product Features (0.5000) and Market Share (0.4375) were identified as the primary metrics. In the civil market, the ability to establish a recognizable brand is vital for attracting consumer groups outside the traditional military-industrial complex.

Resource and Environment Capacities

For resource capacity, the model prioritizes Human Resources (0.45) and Market Resources (0.45). Interestingly, factors such as "Fund Management Capacity" were filtered out, suggesting that while capital is necessary, it is the quality of talent and market access that defines core competitiveness.

Finally, the Macro External Environment (0.5000) and Enterprise Internal Environment (0.4445) represent the environmental dimension. The study underscores that national policies, particularly those protecting intellectual property rights, are essential external catalysts for technical output and competitive survival.

Conclusion

This research provides a theoretical foundation for quantifying the competitiveness of Chinese aerospace enterprises navigating the transition between military and commercial sectors. By focusing on eight high-weight indicators, firms can better prioritize their strategic investments in innovation and market expansion.

However, the study is limited by its small expert sample size (10) and its specific focus on state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Future research should aim to validate this indicator system using empirical data from a broader range of firms, including private aerospace startups, to test its predictive power regarding long-term business success.

Summary updated

Abstract

Through comprehensive analysis of Chinese and foreign literature on the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises, the factors influencing the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises in China are summarized, followed by the analysis made based on such elements as the resource capacity, technical capacity, product capacity and environment capacity of aerospace enterprises. From a dual-capacity perspective, a model for identification of the factors influencing the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises is constructed, with thirteen influencing factors selected by means of expert questionnaire survey, with evaluation of each indicator conducted respectively, followed by screening based on the importance of each influencing factor, with four capacities and eight indicator factors relating to the core competitiveness of aerospace enterprises from a dual-capacity perspective finally selected.
BibTeX
@misc{li2017research,
  author = {Dong Li and Chu-gui Zheng and Yun-tang Zhang},
  title = {{The Research of an Evaluation Indicator System Design for the Core Competitiveness of Aerospace Enterprises from a Dual Capacity Perspective}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.2991/icemct-17.2017.288},
}
Figure