Measuring dynamic competitive relationship and intensity among the global coal importing trade

Wenya Wang, Zhenfu Li, Peng Zhou2021 · DOI

Abstract: The International Energy Agency has provided the data that coal consumption is a major source of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. Up to now, the evolution of the global coal trade volume still tends towards increasing. However, whether there is a possibility of downward trend in global coal trade competition? This paper offers a comprehensive exploration and discussion of dynamic competitive intensity among the global coal importing trade from a continuous time series perspective. First, the results indicate that global coal trade competitive intensity has continued to rise. Next, we find that the role played by the Asian-Pacific region, led by Japan and China in sequence, in the evolution of this competitive pattern is becoming increasingly prominent. The competitive intensity of European importers has declined since 2007. Finally, based on the results, it is recommended that the policy makers in Asian countries should make out strategies such as adopting environmentally friendly technologies to decrease the CO2 emissions.

Introduction

While the global community strives for decarbonization, the competitive landscape of the coal trade remains robust. Coal is a primary driver of global CO2 emissions, and despite a shift toward renewables in many Western nations, global trade volumes continue to climb. This research addresses a critical question: is global coal trade competition actually slowing down? A decrease in competition might signal a decoupling from coal; conversely, intensifying competition suggests a persistent dependence on coal for energy security, complicating climate mitigation efforts. By mapping these "competitive battlegrounds," this study identifies where intervention and green technology transfers are most urgently needed.

Methodology and Data

The study utilizes Complex Network Theory to model the Coal Import Competition Network (CICN). In this framework, nodes represent importing countries, and an edge is established between two countries if they share a common coal supplier.

Construction of the Coal Import Competition Network (CICN) from bipartite trade relationships.

To quantify these relationships, the authors developed a symmetrical weighted model. A "competition intensity" index ($S_{ij}$) was calculated, accounting for the volume of coal shared from a common supplier, normalized against the importers' total volumes and the global trade total. The analysis relies on the UN Comtrade database (Commodity Code: HS 2701), covering annual export and import flows among 226 countries and territories from 1998 to 2017.

Analysis of Competitive Dynamics

The research reveals an "80/20 rule" within the coal market: approximately 80% of global competitive intensity is generated by just 20% of the relationships. This concentration means a small group of major importers dictates the market's overall dynamics.

A significant "Great Shift East" is evident. While the Asia-Pacific and European regions have historically been the primary competitive hubs, their internal trajectories have diverged. Intra-Asian competition has skyrocketed, doubling its 1998 value by 2017. Interestingly, a temporary dip in global intensity occurred around 2007, which the authors attribute to strategic supply diversification by major importers seeking to enhance energy security. Throughout this period, Japan has remained a central, stabilizing pillar in the Asia-Pacific network, participating in nearly all of the region's highest-intensity competitive links.

Key Findings

The longitudinal analysis confirms that global coal trade competition has not only risen but also grown more complex over the last two decades.

Evolution of global coal import competition intensity and key regional relationships (1998, 2007, 2017).

Regional trends highlight the shifting epicenter of coal demand:

  • Asia-Pacific: This region now faces the highest competitive pressure globally, driven by the massive energy needs of emerging and established economies.
  • Europe: Reflecting a genuine transition away from coal, European competition has seen a steady decline since 2007.
  • Africa: The region's ranking in regional competition dropped, indicating a weakening of intra-regional coal trade ties.

These results suggest that because the fiercest competition is concentrated among a few Asian nations (China, Japan, South Korea, and India), these countries are pivotal to global emission reduction. Policy makers in these regions must prioritize the adoption of environmentally friendly coal technologies and accelerate renewable transitions.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this study provides a robust historical view of volume-based competition, it acknowledges certain limitations. The current model does not differentiate between coal qualities (e.g., thermal vs. coking coal) or integrate price dynamics, which could further segment competitive links. Future research could utilize this network data for predictive modeling to forecast trade shifts under various carbon tax scenarios. Ultimately, a systematic global framework for coal trade is necessary to ensure that energy security competition does not undermine collective climate goals.

Summary updated

Abstract

The International Energy Agency has provided the data that coal consumption is a major source of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions. Up to now, the evolution of the global coal trade volume still tends towards increasing. However, whether there is a possibility of downward trend in global coal trade competition? This paper offers a comprehensive exploration and discussion of dynamic competitive intensity among the global coal importing trade from a continuous time series perspective. First, the results indicate that global coal trade competitive intensity has continued to rise. Next, we find that the role played by the Asian-Pacific region, led by Japan and China in sequence, in the evolution of this competitive pattern is becoming increasingly prominent. The competitive intensity of European importers has declined since 2007. Finally, based on the results, it is recommended that the policy makers in Asian countries should make out strategies such as adopting environmentally friendly technologies to decrease the CO2 emissions.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2021measuring,
  author = {Wenya Wang and Zhenfu Li and Peng Zhou},
  title = {{Measuring dynamic competitive relationship and intensity among the global coal importing trade}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.46855/energy-proceedings-7513},
}
Figure