Analysis on the Influence of Geographical Indication Protection on International Competitiveness of Shaanxi Apple

Xiaowei Zhou, Xinyin Zhang, Junnan DongProceedings of the 2018 2nd International Conference on Management, Education and Social Science (ICMESS 2018) 2018 · DOI

Abstract

As a significant agricultural province in western China, Shaanxi's Weibei loess plateau offers a unique ecological environment that is the only region meeting all seven climate indicators required for optimal apple growth. Following the acquisition of Geographical Indication (GI) protection in 2003, the Shaanxi apple industry experienced unprecedented growth, with cultivation area and yield becoming the highest in China. Today, Shaanxi accounts for approximately one-third of national production and 11% of global output. This paper analyzes the international competitiveness of the Shaanxi apple industry before and after obtaining GI protection, utilizing International Market Share (MS) and Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA) indices as primary metrics.

Introduction

Shaanxi province is a global leader in apple production, yet the industry faced intense pressure following China’s entry into the WTO in 2001. To maintain steady development in a globalized market, the province leveraged Geographical Indication (GI) protection—a legal framework similar to "Protected Designation of Origin"—to transform regional agricultural products into specialized global brands. This study evaluates how this legal status catalyzed a surge in international competitiveness from 1998 to 2014.

Methodology

The research employs two quantitative metrics to assess competitiveness:

  1. International Market Share (MS): Measures the proportion of the global fresh apple market held by the region.
  2. Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA): Compares a region’s export share of a product to the world’s export share. An RCA > 1 indicates a comparative advantage, while an RCA > 2.5 signifies very strong international competitiveness.

The "GI Effect" and Industrialization

GI protection acted as more than a marketing label; it triggered a government-led standardization of production. This included rigorous controls on soil quality, irrigation, and pesticide use. By adopting an industrialization model—integrating GI branding with leading enterprises and local farmers—Shaanxi transformed a fragmented sector into a unified, high-quality export engine.

Figure 1: International Market Share (MS) trends for fresh apples (1998-2014).

Key Results and Analysis

Explosive Growth in Comparative Advantage

Prior to GI protection in 1998, Shaanxi’s RCA was 0.79, indicating no comparative advantage. Following the 2003 certification, the index skyrocketed, peaking at 16.38 in 2012. This astronomical growth suggests that Shaanxi is the primary driver of China's international strength in the apple trade. While the national average RCA remains around 1.25, Shaanxi's specialized focus has yielded significantly higher results.

Market Share Expansion and Resilience

Shaanxi’s share of the global fresh apple market grew from 0.11% in 2003 to 0.57% in 2014. Notably, the industry demonstrated resilience during the 2008 global financial crisis. Although the RCA index dipped, it remained above 6.0, indicating that the established GI brand provided a critical buffer against global economic volatility.

Figure 2: Revealed Comparative Advantage (RCA) index trends (1998-2014).

Conclusion and Future Directions

Geographical Indication protection has fundamentally bolstered Shaanxi's international market position. However, to sustain this growth, the industry must address current limitations. Future efforts should focus on increasing global brand awareness beyond quality control and exploring the value-add potential of GI protection for processed products like concentrated apple juice. As trade policies and global markets evolve, maintaining the high standards established by the GI framework will be vital for Shaanxi's continued dominance.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a big agricultural province in western China, Shaanxi loess plateau area of Weibei has a unique ecological environment and natural climate, and the climate here is the only one that meets the requirements of seven indicators for apple growth. In 2003, after Shaanxi's apple got the geographical indication protection products, it got an unprecedented development, that is, the Shaanxi apple cultivation area and yield became the first in the nation, and its production accounts for about a third of the country, 11% of the world. Shaanxi apple industry is the pillar industry of the whole province's national economy development, which occupies the important position in the national apple industry. With Shaanxi apple approved geographical indication products and the development of economic globalization, for Shaanxi's apple industry, how to make use of the geographical indication brands to sell apple outside the province and to improve international competitiveness of these brands in the fierce international competition to maintain the steady development is of a subject worthy of our study. Based on the international market share, revealed comparative advantage indexes of theoretical basis, the author analyzes the international competitiveness of Shaanxi apple industry before and after it got the geographical indication protection.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2018analysis,
  author = {Xiaowei Zhou and Xinyin Zhang and Junnan Dong},
  title = {{Analysis on the Influence of Geographical Indication Protection on International Competitiveness of Shaanxi Apple}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2018 2nd International Conference on Management, Education and Social Science (ICMESS 2018)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2991/icmess-18.2018.402},
}
Figure