Abstract
Barcelona en Comú, an emerging grassroots movement-party, won the 2015 Barcelona City Council election. This candidacy was devised by activists involved in the 15M movement in order to turn citizen outrage into political change. On the one hand, the 15M movement is based on a decentralized structure. On the other hand, political science literature postulates that parties historically develop oligarchical leadership structures. This tension motivates us to examine whether Barcelona en Comú preserved a decentralizated structure or adopted a conventional centralized organization. In this article we analyse the Twitter networks of the parties that ran for this election by measuring their hierarchical structure, information efficiency and social resilience. Our results show that in Barcelona en Comú two well-defined groups co-exist: a cluster dominated by the leader and the collective accounts, and another cluster formed by the movement activists. While the former group is highly centralized like the other major parties, the latter one stands out for its decentralized, cohesive and resilient structure.
Introduction
In political science, the "Iron Law of Oligarchy" suggests that all complex organizations eventually develop a ruling elite, sacrificing internal democracy for efficiency. This creates a fundamental tension for modern "networked social movements"—such as the 15M movement in Spain—that prize decentralization and horizontal leadership. When these movements transition into formal political parties to seek office, do they inevitably centralize?
This study uses the 2015 Barcelona City Council election as a laboratory to investigate Barcelona en Comú (BeC). By analyzing Twitter retweet networks, the authors examine whether BeC preserved its grassroots structure or adopted the centralized hierarchy typical of traditional Spanish parties like the PP or PSC.
Methodology
The researchers constructed a directed, weighted graph of Twitter interactions (retweets) to map the digital ecosystem of the election. The dataset comprised 373,818 retweets collected between May 1 and May 26, 2015. After filtering for significant interactions, the final network consisted of 6,492 nodes and 16,775 edges.
To ensure robust community detection, the authors employed a modified Louvain algorithm, running it 100 times and only assigning nodes to a cluster if they appeared there in at least 95% of the runs. This process identified stable partisan clusters across the political spectrum.
The Hybrid "Movement-Party"
A key finding of the study is that Barcelona en Comú did not form a single cohesive cluster. Instead, it manifested as a unique hybrid of two distinct groups:
- BeC-p (The Party Core): Dominated by the leader, Ada Colau, and official party accounts.
- BeC-m (The Movement Periphery): Composed of grassroots activists.
As shown in the table above, the BeC-p cluster is characterized by high-PageRank official accounts and the candidate, while the BeC-m cluster consists of members and media that support the movement's broader goals.
Key Results
The structural analysis revealed stark differences between these two clusters and traditional parties:
- Hierarchy: BeC-p exhibited the highest in-degree inequality (Gini = 0.995), surpassing even traditional conservative parties. In contrast, the movement cluster (BeC-m) had the lowest inequality (Gini = 0.811), reflecting its decentralized nature.
- Cohesion: BeC-m showed the highest clustering coefficient (0.208), indicating a tight-knit community. BeC-p, conversely, resembled a "star" network with a coefficient of only 0.002.
- Resilience: Using k-core decomposition, BeC-m reached a maximum shell index of 17, the highest in the study. This suggests the activist base is significantly more robust against the removal of central nodes than traditional party structures.
- Polarization: The overall network modularity was high ($Q = 0.727$), confirming that Twitter users were largely segregated into partisan "echo chambers," bridged only by media accounts acting as "weak ties."
Conclusion
The results support a "front-end/back-end" model for successful movement-parties: a centralized front-end for media visibility and electoral efficiency, paired with a decentralized, resilient back-end for organizational strength. While the study is a snapshot of a single election, it provides a blueprint for how grassroots movements can navigate the transition to formal politics without entirely losing their horizontal DNA.
Summary updated