Abstract
Social media has become a key mechanism for the organization of grassroots movements. In the 2015 Barcelona City Council election, Barcelona en Comú, an emerging grassroots party, was the most voted one. This candidacy was devised by activists involved in the Spanish 15M movement in order to turn citizen outrage into political change. On the one hand, the 15M movement is based on a decentralized structure. On the other hand, political science literature postulates that parties historically develop oligarchical leadership structures. This tension motivates us to examine whether Barcelona en Comú preserved a decentralized structure or adopted a conventional centralized organization. In this article we propose a computational framework to analyze the Twitter networks of the parties that ran for this election by measuring their hierarchical structure, small-world phenomenon and coreness. The results of our assessment show that in Barcelona en Comú two well-defined groups co-exist: a cluster dominated by the party leader and the collective accounts, and another cluster formed by the movement activists. While the former group is highly centralized like traditional parties, the latter one stands out for its decentralized, cohesive and resilient structure.
Introduction
Political science has long debated the "Iron Law of Oligarchy," which suggests that any complex organization—including political parties—will eventually develop a centralized, elite leadership. However, modern "networked social movements" (like the Spanish 15M or Occupy Wall Street) are built on decentralized, horizontal structures. This study investigates whether grassroots digital movements lose their decentralized nature when they transition into formal political parties. Using the 2015 Barcelona City Council election as a case study, the authors focus on Barcelona en Comú (BeC), a party born directly from the 15M movement that managed to win the election.
Methodology
The researchers developed a computational framework to characterize the topology of political parties on Twitter using a dataset of 373,818 retweets collected during the May 2015 campaign. The final analyzed network comprised 6,492 nodes and 16,775 edges.
Key analytical steps included:
- Community Detection: Identifying clusters within the retweet network using the Louvain method, with a robustness check across 100 runs.
- Hierarchy Measurement: Applying the Gini coefficient to in-degree distributions to measure communication flow equality.
- Small-World Analysis: Measuring clustering coefficients and average path lengths to determine information spread efficiency.
- Coreness (Resilience): Using k-core decomposition to assess the resilience of groups against the removal of peripheral nodes.
Results and Analysis
The Hybrid "Movement-Party" Structure
Unlike traditional parties, which typically appeared as single, centralized clusters, BeC was composed of two distinct sub-communities: BeC-p (the formal party structure) and BeC-m (the movement activists).
Hierarchy and Decentralization
The BeC-p cluster was highly centralized around the candidate (Ada Colau), mirroring the "Iron Law of Oligarchy." In contrast, the BeC-m cluster was the most decentralized and egalitarian of all groups studied. BeC-p had a Gini coefficient of 0.995 (near-perfect inequality), while BeC-m had a Gini of 0.811, the lowest in the study.
Resilience and Connectivity
The movement cluster (BeC-m) showed the highest "coreness" ($k_{max} = 17$), suggesting a dense, interconnected core resilient to the loss of individual members. Traditional parties like the PSC and PP exhibited "star" topologies with short average path lengths (~2.3 to 2.7), whereas BeC-m had a longer path length (3.35), reflecting a more complex, multi-hop social structure. Additionally, traditional media outlets were found to serve as critical "weak ties" bridging polarized political silos.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that Barcelona en Comú successfully maintained a unique "hybrid" structure: a centralized leadership core co-existing with a highly resilient, decentralized activist base. While Twitter data provides only a partial view of political organization, this study offers a model for analyzing 21st-century grassroots parties. Future research should include longitudinal analysis to determine if movement clusters are eventually absorbed by formal party structures or if this hybrid model represents a sustainable new form of political organization.
Summary updated