Thinking, Fast and Slow? Some Field Experiments to Reduce Crime and Dropout in Chicago

Sara Heller, Anuj Shah, Jonathan Guryan, Jens Ludwig, Sendhil Mullainathan, Harold A. Pollack

Abstract

This paper presents results from three large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in Chicago evaluating interventions designed to reduce crime and school dropout among economically disadvantaged youth. The interventions, primarily the "Becoming a Man" (BAM) program, focus on Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) techniques to improve real-time decision-making. Results indicate that participation reduced violent-crime arrests by 45–50% and increased graduation rates by 12–19%. The findings suggest that these effects are driven by reducing "automaticity" in social responses—helping youth "slow down" in high-stakes situations—rather than by changing long-term character traits like "grit."

Introduction

Disparities in youth outcomes in the United States are a persistent challenge for social policy. In many urban environments, the risk of involvement in violent crime is exceptionally high; for example, the homicide rate for Black males aged 15–24 is 18 times higher than for their white counterparts. Traditional interventions often emphasize long-term human capital development, such as vocational training, or economic incentives. However, these approaches frequently fail to address the immediate, high-stakes decisions that lead to criminal justice involvement or school exit.

This study explores an alternative hypothesis: that many problematic behaviors among disadvantaged youth stem from "automatic" responses that are adaptive in dangerous neighborhood contexts but maladaptive in institutional settings like schools. By testing interventions that teach youth to recognize and bypass these automatic responses, the researchers aim to identify a scalable path toward reducing violence and improving educational attainment.

The Interventions: Becoming a Man (BAM) and JTDC

The primary intervention studied is Becoming a Man (BAM), developed by the Chicago-based non-profit Youth Guidance. BAM utilizes Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) principles to help youth develop meta-cognitive skills. Through weekly group sessions, participants engage in role-playing and experiential exercises designed to help them "slow down" and reflect on their thoughts and actions. A key example is the "Fist" exercise, where youth learn that they can obtain an object through negotiation rather than force.

A second intervention was implemented within the Cook County Juvenile Temporary Detention Center (JTDC). This program shared core CBT components with BAM, focusing on helping detained youth manage their responses to provocation and stress to reduce recidivism.

Methodology and Data

The researchers conducted three large-scale RCTs:

  1. BAM Study 1 (2009–10): 2,740 male students in grades 7–10 within Chicago Public Schools (CPS).
  2. BAM Study 2 (2013–15): 2,064 male students in grades 9–10 within CPS.
  3. JTDC Study (2009–11): 2,693 male admissions to the Cook County JTDC.

The study integrated multiple data sources, including longitudinal administrative records from CPS (GPA, attendance, graduation), electronic "rap sheets" from the Illinois State Police, and detention records from the JTDC. To evaluate the psychological mechanisms at play, the authors used survey data and a custom-designed laboratory experiment—a modified iterated dictator game—to measure decision-making speed and retaliatory behavior under provocation.

Key Findings

Impact on Crime and Recidivism

The results across all three trials were substantial. Participation in BAM reduced total arrests by 28–35% and violent-crime arrests by 45–50% during the intervention period. In the JTDC study, the intervention led to a 21% reduction in readmission rates to the facility. These findings suggest that CBT-based interventions can effectively mitigate the most severe forms of anti-social behavior.

Educational Gains

Beyond crime reduction, the BAM program significantly improved school engagement. In the first study, for which long-term follow-up data was available, the program increased high school graduation rates by 12–19% (a 6 to 9 percentage point increase). This indicates that the benefits of improved decision-making extend into academic persistence.

Economic Viability

The programs are highly cost-effective, with costs ranging from $1,100 to $1,850 per participant. Given the enormous social and economic costs associated with violent crime and the lifetime earnings benefits of high school graduation, the estimated benefit-cost ratios range from 5-to-1 to over 30-to-1.

The Mechanism: Addressing Automaticity

A surprising finding of the study was the lack of evidence for traditional psychological mediators. Survey data did not show significant improvements in "grit," emotional intelligence, or social capital. Instead, the laboratory experiment provided strong support for the automaticity hypothesis.

In the modified dictator game, youth who participated in BAM took 80% longer to decide how to respond to a provocation than those in the control group. Crucially, they did not necessarily retaliate less; they simply took more time to process the situation. This suggests that the program works not by making youth "nicer" or more "pro-social" in a general sense, but by giving them the cognitive tools to recognize which "code" of behavior—the street code or the school code—is appropriate for the current "occasion."

Conclusion and Policy Implications

The success of BAM and the JTDC program demonstrates that addressing real-time decision-making is a powerful lever for improving outcomes for at-risk youth. These interventions are relatively inexpensive, manualized, and scalable. However, the study also noted that the effects on crime tended to fade after the program ended, suggesting that "booster shots" or continued support may be necessary as youth navigate the transition to adulthood. By focusing on "decision-tuning" rather than fundamental character change, policymakers can implement effective, respectful, and high-impact strategies to reduce urban violence and promote educational equity.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the results of three large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) carried out in Chicago, testing interventions to reduce crime and dropout by changing the decision-making of economically disadvantaged youth. We study a program called Becoming a Man (BAM), developed by the non-profit Youth Guidance, in two RCTs implemented in 2009–10 and 2013– 15. In the two studies participation in the program reduced total arrests during the intervention period by 28–35%, reduced violent-crime arrests by 45–50%, improved school engagement, and in the first study where we have follow-up data, increased graduation rates by 12–19%. The third RCT tested a program with partially overlapping components carried out in the Cook County Juvenile Temporary Detention Center (JTDC), which reduced readmission rates to the facility by 21%. These large behavioral responses combined with modest program costs imply benefit-cost ratios for these interventions from 5-to-1 up to 30-to-1 or more. Our data on mechanisms are not ideal, but we find no positive evidence that these effects are due to changes in emotional intelligence or social skills, self-control or “grit, ” or a generic mentoring effect. We find suggestive support for the hypothesis that the programs work by helping youth slow down and reflect on whether their automatic thoughts and behaviors are well suited to the situation they are in, or whether the situation could be construed differently.
BibTeX
@article{heller2016thinking,
  author = {Sara Heller and Anuj Shah and Jonathan Guryan and Jens Ludwig and Sendhil Mullainathan and Harold A. Pollack},
  title = {{Thinking, Fast and Slow? Some Field Experiments to Reduce Crime and Dropout in Chicago}},
  journal = {The Quarterly Journal of Economics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1093/qje/qjw033},
}

Loading related content...

Figure