Thinking, Fast and Slow? Some Field Experiments to Reduce Crime and Dropout in Chicago*

Sara Heller, Anuj Shah, Jonathan Guryan, Jens Ludwig, Sendhil Mullainathan, Harold A. Pollack

TL;DR

Three large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in Chicago demonstrate that low-cost Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) interventions can significantly reduce violent crime arrests and school dropout rates. The core mechanism isn't teaching "grit" or social skills, but rather helping youth "slow down" and bypass maladaptive automatic responses in high-stakes situations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the U.S., disparities in youth outcomes are staggering; for instance, the homicide rate for Black males aged 15–24 is 18 times higher than for their white peers. Traditional social policies often focus on long-term incentives—like vocational training or cash transfers—to change behavior. However, these often yield disappointing results.

The authors argue that many "anti-social" behaviors are not the result of a lack of skills or character, but rather a failure of real-time decision-making. Youth in high-stress, violent environments often develop "automatic" aggressive responses that are adaptive for survival on the street but disastrous in a school or legal setting. This paper investigates whether interventions designed to reduce this "automaticity" can improve life outcomes.

Methods

The researchers conducted three large-scale RCTs:

  1. BAM Study 1 (2009–10): 2,740 male students (grades 7–10) in Chicago Public Schools (CPS).
  2. BAM Study 2 (2013–15): 2,064 male students (grades 9–10) in CPS.
  3. JTDC Study (2009–11): 2,693 male admissions to the Cook County Juvenile Temporary Detention Center.

The primary intervention was Becoming a Man (BAM), a program using CBT techniques to encourage "meta-cognition" (thinking about thinking). Activities included role-playing, "check-ins," and experiential exercises like the "Fist" exercise (where youth realize they can get an object by asking rather than using force).

To test the underlying mechanism, the authors used a modified iterated dictator game. In this experiment, youth were provoked by a "partner" (actually a computer script) who took money from them. The researchers measured the decision-making time and the amount of retaliation to see if the program actually helped youth "slow down" and think before acting.

Datasets

The study relied on a robust combination of administrative and experimental data:

  • Schooling Data: Longitudinal student-level records from Chicago Public Schools (GPA, attendance, enrollment, and graduation).
  • Criminal Justice Data: Electronic "rap sheets" from the Illinois State Police (ISP) and arrest data from the Chicago Police Department (CPD).
  • Detention Data: Admissions logs and housing rosters from the Cook County Juvenile Temporary Detention Center (JTDC).
  • Survey Data: Bi-annual online surveys from the Consortium on Chicago School Research (CCSR) to measure traits like "grit" and social skills.
  • Experimental Data: Response times and "take amounts" from the custom-designed dictator game.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Automaticity Hypothesis: The authors move beyond "System 1 vs. System 2" as a purely cognitive theory, applying it to social survival. They suggest that youth aren't "bad"; they are simply applying a "street code" (where aggression is adaptive) to "school life" (where it is not).
  • "Sense of Occasion": The goal of the intervention isn't to make youth "pro-social" in all contexts—which could be dangerous in their neighborhoods—but to help them recognize which "code" is appropriate for the current situation.
  • Failure of Traditional Mediators: Surprisingly, the researchers found no evidence that the program worked by increasing "grit," emotional intelligence, or social capital. This suggests that "character-building" might be less important than "decision-tuning."
  • High ROI: The interventions are remarkably cheap (~$1,100 to $1,850 per participant). Given the massive social costs of crime and the benefits of graduation, the benefit-cost ratios range from 5-to-1 to over 30-to-1.

Key Results

  • Crime Reduction: Participation in BAM reduced total arrests by 28–35% and violent-crime arrests by 45–50% during the intervention period.
  • Schooling Improvements: In the first BAM study, graduation rates increased by 12–19% (a gain of 6 to 9 percentage points).
  • Recidivism: The JTDC intervention reduced readmission rates to the facility by 21%.
  • Mechanism Verification: In the dictator game, BAM participants took 80% longer to decide how to respond to a provocation compared to the control group. Crucially, they didn't necessarily retaliate less; they just took more time to consider their options.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Persistence: While schooling effects persisted, the impact on arrest rates faded after the program ended. This suggests that youth might need "booster shots" of the intervention as they age.
  • Scalability and Staffing: The programs are manualized, but their success may depend on the specific qualities of the counselors (often college-educated men from similar neighborhoods). It is unclear if the effect holds with different staffing models.
  • Generalizability: The studies were all conducted in Chicago. Future research is needed to see if these results replicate in different urban contexts or with different demographic groups (e.g., female youth).
  • Measurement Gaps: The survey data used to measure "grit" and social skills had a relatively low response rate (~40%), which may have limited the authors' ability to detect changes in those specific traits.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the results of three large-scale randomized controlled trials (RCTs) carried out in Chicago, testing interventions to reduce crime and dropout by changing the decision making of economically disadvantaged youth. We study a program called Becoming a Man (BAM), developed by the nonprofit Youth Guidance, in two RCTs implemented in 2009-2010 and 2013-2015. In the two studies participation in the program reduced total arrests during the intervention period by 28-35%, reduced violent-crime arrests by 45-50%, improved school engagement, and in the first study where we have follow-up data, increased graduation rates by 12-19%. The third RCT tested a program with partially overlapping components carried out in the Cook County Juvenile Temporary Detention Center (JTDC), which reduced readmission rates to the facility by 21%. These large behavioral responses combined with modest program costs imply benefit-cost ratios for these interventions from 5-to-1 up to 30-to-1 or more. Our data on mechanisms are not ideal, but we find no positive evidence that these effects are due to changes in emotional intelligence or social skills, self-control or "grit," or a generic mentoring effect. We find suggestive support for the hypothesis that the programs work by helping youth slow down and reflect on whether their automatic thoughts and behaviors are well suited to the situation they are in, or whether the situation could be construed differently. <i>JEL</i> Codes: C91, C93, D03, D1, I24, I3, I32, K42.
BibTeX
@article{heller2016thinking,
  author = {Sara Heller and Anuj Shah and Jonathan Guryan and Jens Ludwig and Sendhil Mullainathan and Harold A. Pollack},
  title = {{Thinking, Fast and Slow? Some Field Experiments to Reduce Crime and Dropout in Chicago*}},
  journal = {The Quarterly Journal of Economics},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1093/qje/qjw033},
}

Loading related content...

Figure