The Role of Organizations in Networked Mobilization: Examining the 2011 Chilean Student Movement Through The Logic of Connective Action

Diego Gómez-Zará, Carolina Perez-Arredondo, Denis Parra

Introduction

In the last decade, the landscape of social activism has undergone a fundamental shift. The traditional "Logic of Collective Action," characterized by centralized, formal organizations and rigid manifestos, has largely been supplemented—or, some argue, replaced—by the "Logic of Connective Action." This new paradigm emphasizes decentralized networks where individuals share "personal action frames," such as memes and personal stories, to mobilize peers through social media.

However, this shift raises a critical question: Are formal organizations becoming obsolete in the age of digital activism? This paper investigates the 2011 Chilean student movement to determine whether organizations still play a unique and essential role in the formation and propagation of mobilization networks.

Methodology

To analyze the structural dynamics of these movements, the researchers employed Exponential Random Graph Models (ERGMs). Unlike standard descriptive statistics, ERGMs allow for the identification of specific structural signatures—patterns of interaction that occur more frequently than would be expected by random chance.

The study focused on the "formation phase" of two distinct retweet networks extracted via the Twitter Academic API, analyzing the first 1,000 retweets of two specific hashtags:

  1. #FuerzaEstudiantes (Crowd-enabled): A decentralized, grassroots-led network.
  2. #YoMarchoEl28 (Organizationally-enabled): A network initiated by the CONFECH student union.

Accounts were manually coded into four categories: ordinary users, student organizations, student leaders, and influential users (celebrities/politicians). This allowed the researchers to test for two primary diffusion mechanisms: "Hierarchical Cascades" (top-down broadcasting) and "Triadic Closure" (peer-to-peer sharing within a web of trust).

Key Findings

1. Distinct Structural Signatures

The research confirmed that the "DNA" of a network depends heavily on its origin. Organizationally-enabled networks propagate primarily through hierarchical cascades ($\beta = 0.056$). These networks are highly centralized (0.193 centralization score) and rely on a broadcast style of communication.

In contrast, crowd-enabled networks are driven by triadic closure ($\beta = 2.722$). In these networks, information spreads because users trust the person they follow, who in turn follows the source. These networks were found to be 15 times more likely to form through this peer-to-peer mechanism, likely because personal stories are more adaptable and easier for individuals to adopt than organizational mandates.

2. Organizations as Informational Hubs

Perhaps the most significant finding is that organizations remain relevant even in decentralized, crowd-led movements. In the #FuerzaEstudiantes network, organizations acted as critical "informational hubs," bridging unconnected users and preventing the movement from fragmenting into isolated "islands."

Quantitatively, organizations were four times more likely than individuals to retweet in crowd-enabled networks. Furthermore, messages originating from organizations were 2 to 2.3 times more likely to be retweeted than those from ordinary users across both network types. This suggests that organizations provide a level of reach and legitimacy that individuals alone cannot match.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study suggests that the most effective modern movements are not purely decentralized or purely hierarchical; rather, they are hybrid ecosystems. While individuals provide the personal resonance and "web of trust" necessary for grassroots growth, organizations provide the infrastructure and bridging capacity required for large-scale mobilization.

Limitations and Future Directions

It is important to note that this data stems from 2011-2012, a period when Twitter utilized a chronological feed. The impact of modern algorithmic curation on these diffusion patterns remains a subject for future study. Additionally, while the structural analysis is robust, combining these models with Natural Language Processing (NLP) could provide deeper insights into how the sentiment and content of a tweet influence its path through the network.

In conclusion, organizations are not obsolete in the digital age. Instead, their role has evolved from being the sole directors of action to becoming essential catalysts and bridges within a broader, networked mobilization strategy.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{gomezzara2025role,
  author = {Diego Gómez-Zará and Carolina Perez-Arredondo and Denis Parra},
  title = {{The Role of Organizations in Networked Mobilization: Examining the 2011 Chilean Student Movement Through The Logic of Connective Action}},
  booktitle = {WebSci},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1145/3717867.3717917},
}
Figure