Study on Aerodynamic Characteristics of H. A. W. T. by Combination Analysis of Momentum, Energy and Blade Element theory, and Experiment : Effects of Angular Rotation of Air Flow on Performance

Masayuki Norita, Kenichi Oyama, Koki Kishinami, Jun Suzuki, Hiroshi Ibano, Isamu KonnoThe Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering 2001 · DOI

Abstract Aerodynamic performance characteristics of the Horizontal Axis Wind Turbine (HAWT) were investigated theoretically and experimentally by a combination analysis of momentum, energy, and blade element theory, considering the angular rotation of the working flow. Four types of wing sections and blade arrangements were examined via small-scale experiments in an open-type wind tunnel (0.88m diameter) with wind speeds from 0.8 to 4.5 m/s. The study discusses the relationship between power ($C_P$), thrust ($C_T$), and torque ($C_q$) coefficients and the tip speed ratio ($\lambda$). Analytical results for large-scale units clarify how optimized design parameters play a significant role in performance.

Introduction

Predicting the aerodynamic performance of wind turbines is notoriously complex. Traditional Blade Element Momentum (BEM) theory often relies on simplifying assumptions that can lead to inaccuracies, particularly by neglecting the "swirl" or angular momentum imparted to the air as it passes through the rotor. This rotation represents a kinetic energy loss that reduces the actual power coefficient ($C_P$). This paper seeks to bridge the gap between theoretical models and experimental reality by integrating momentum, energy, and blade element theories while specifically accounting for these energy losses caused by wake rotation.

Methodology

The study employs a dual-track approach:

  1. Theoretical Modeling: A hybrid analytical method combining Momentum-Energy theory with Blade Element theory was developed. A modified Bernoulli equation accounts for the angular velocity of the wake, allowing for accurate calculation of "swirl" loss and prediction of $C_P$, $C_T$, and $C_q$.
  2. Experimental Validation: Small-scale experiments were conducted in an open-type wind tunnel. Four blade types were tested: tapered blades using LS04 airfoils (Type I), tapered blades using NACA44 airfoils (Type II), NACA44 blades with oval tips (Type III), and a "two-stage pitch" tapered NACA44 blade (Type IV) designed to maintain a constant effective angle of attack.
Geometry and airfoil sections (NACA 44 series) for the experimental tapered blades, showing the two-stage pitch design.

Theoretical Framework: The "Swirl" Penalty

The research quantifies how the reaction to the torque generated by the blades creates a rotating wake. This rotation is a direct drain on the energy available for conversion. Accounting for this angular momentum is essential for accurate performance prediction, especially at high tip-speed ratios where traditional models often diverge from experimental data.

Schematic of flow through a HAWT rotor accounting for wake rotation (swirl) and velocity components.

Key Results and Discussion

Experimental models showed that the power coefficient ($C_P$) generally peaked at a tip-speed ratio ($\lambda$) of approximately 6. The LS04 airfoil (Type I) outperformed the NACA44 (Type II) in terms of pitch control response.

A significant finding was the "blockage" phenomenon: at high rotation speeds, blade tips can effectively "choke" the flow, causing a sharp drop in performance. The authors found that "extreme tapering" (significantly reducing the tip chord length) can mitigate this effect. The "two-stage pitch" blade (Type IV) provided the best correlation between theory and experiment, suggesting that discrete twist distributions are a viable design strategy.

Simulations of a 60m diameter turbine revealed that while an oval tip slightly improves peak $C_P$, an "extreme tapered" tip dramatically increases the stable operating range. Furthermore, narrowing the tips reduces centrifugal loads and bending moments, leading to lighter and more durable blade designs.

Limitations and Conclusion

Discrepancies between small-scale experimental values and theoretical predictions were noted, likely due to low Reynolds numbers in the wind tunnel. Future work will refine lift and drag coefficient settings and address 3D flow effects at the extreme blade tips. In conclusion, this study demonstrates that optimizing blade-tip taper and pitch distribution can significantly broaden a turbine's efficient operating range and prevent aerodynamic blockage while providing structural benefits.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aerodynamic performance characteristics of the HAWT were investigated theoretically and experimentally by the combination analysis of momentum, energy, and blade element theory superimposed by the strip element theory, and by a small-scale model, considering the angular rotation of working flow, hi this study, four types of wing section and arrangement of blade were examined by a small scale experiments under the condition of open typed wind tunnels with free stream 0.8〜4.5 m/s and outlet ducts dia. of 0.88m φ. i.e., tapered rectangular blade with NACA44, LS04 and two-stage pitch angle tapered blade and tip oval tapered blade with NACA44. The aeronautical characteristics of the H. A. W. T. employing the different blades were discussed to the relation of C_P, C_T, C_q and tip speed ratio λ, based on the experimental and analytical results. Prediction results of aeronautical characteristics for large scale unit are cleared how to be optimized design parameters acting as significant role.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{norita2001study,
  author = {Masayuki Norita and Kenichi Oyama and Koki Kishinami and Jun Suzuki and Hiroshi Ibano and Isamu Konno},
  title = {{Study on Aerodynamic Characteristics of H. A. W. T. by Combination Analysis of Momentum, Energy and Blade Element theory, and Experiment : Effects of Angular Rotation of Air Flow on Performance}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmeenv.2001.11.460},
}
Figure