517 Study on Aerodynamic Characteristics of H.A.W.T. by Combination Analysis of Momentum, Energy and Blade Element theory, and Experiment

Masayuki Norita, Kenichi Oyama, Koki Kishinami, Jun Suzuki, Hiroshi Ibano, Syuhei TakazakuraThe Proceedings of Conference of Hokkaido Branch 2001 · DOI

Abstract

Aerodynamic characteristics of the Horizontal Axis Wind Turbine (HAWT) were investigated theoretically by the combination analysis of momentum, energy, and blade element theory, and experimentally by a small-scale model. In this study, two types of blade were examined: a tapered rectangular blade with NACA LS04 and a two-stage pitch angle tapered blade with NACA44. The performance results of the HAWT by experiment and analysis were discussed in relation to the power coefficient ($C_p$) and tip speed ratio ($\lambda$), focusing on variable pitch control and fixed pitch stall control methods for turbine blade output.

Introduction

As wind energy becomes a cornerstone of renewable power, engineers face a persistent challenge: maximizing efficiency while ensuring structural integrity during high-wind events. Most large-scale turbines utilize variable pitch control, where blades rotate to adjust their angle to the wind. While effective, these systems are mechanically complex and expensive. An alternative is fixed pitch stall control, where the blade's aerodynamic profile is designed to naturally lose lift (stall) when wind speeds exceed a threshold. This study aims to bridge the gap between theoretical modeling and real-world performance for these control methods.

Methodology

The researchers employed a dual-track approach to analyze HAWT performance:

  1. Theoretical Modeling: The study integrated Momentum, Energy, and Blade Element theories. This combined approach accounts for rotational energy losses and axial/tangential induction factors more comprehensively than standard Blade Element Momentum (BEM) theory alone. Airflow was modeled using a streamtube approach to calculate velocity and pressure changes across the rotor.
  2. Experimental Validation: A small-scale test rig was developed, featuring a 1.2m diameter blower and a model turbine equipped with torque and revolution sensors to capture real-time performance data.
Schematic of the experimental setup, including the wind tunnel, turbine model, and data acquisition system.

Two distinct blade geometries were tested:

  • Type I (NACA LS04): A tapered rectangular blade.
  • Type IV (NACA44): A "two-stage" design where the twist angle is constant for the first 60% of the blade and then changes for the tip section.

Key Results and Discussion

Experimental results highlighted several critical performance characteristics:

  • Peak Efficiency: Both blade types achieved a maximum power coefficient ($C_p$) of approximately 0.40 at a tip speed ratio ($\lambda$) of about 6.
  • Performance Sensitivity: The Type I blade (NACA LS04) showed significant variation in $C_p$ with changes in the tip pitch angle ($\theta_{tip}$), as shown in the experimental data below.
Power coefficient (Cp) vs. Tip speed ratio (λ) for the Type I blade across different tip pitch angles.
  • Passive Safety via Aerodynamics: The "two-stage" Type IV design proved to be highly robust. Its power coefficient remained stable across different pitch angles, making it less sensitive to installation errors. Crucially, the study verified that if wind speed increases significantly, the drop in tip speed ratio moves the turbine into a stall region where $C_p$ plummets, providing a passive "aerodynamic braking" effect.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that while the LS04 blade is well-suited for large-scale turbines with active pitch control, the NACA44 two-stage blade is ideal for robust, low-maintenance small-to-medium turbines due to its inherent stall-control characteristics. Discrepancies between theoretical models and experimental data for certain airfoils suggest that future work should focus on refining aerodynamic coefficients at low Reynolds numbers to improve predictive accuracy across all scales.

Summary updated

Abstract

Aerodynamic characteristics of the HAWT were investigated theoretically by the combination analysis of momentum, energy, and blade element theory, and experimentally by a small-scale model. In this study, two types of blade were examined; i.e. tapered rectangular blade with NACA LS04 and two-stage pitch angle tapered blade with NACA44. The performance characteristics result of the HAWT by experiment and analysis were discussed to the relation of C_p and tip speed ratio λ, from the point of view to the variable pitch control and fixed pitch stall control methods for turbine blade output.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{norita2001study,
  author = {Masayuki Norita and Kenichi Oyama and Koki Kishinami and Jun Suzuki and Hiroshi Ibano and Syuhei Takazakura},
  title = {{517 Study on Aerodynamic Characteristics of H.A.W.T. by Combination Analysis of Momentum, Energy and Blade Element theory, and Experiment}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of Conference of Hokkaido Branch},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmehokkaido.2001.41.180},
}
Figure