432 Aerodynamic Characteristics of H.A.W.T. by Using Aerofoils of NACA44xx, LSO4xx, and NACA64-415

Yasuhiko Araya, Koki Kishinami, Jun Suzuki, Himsar Ambarita, Takahiro Koikeda, K Turi, Hiroshi IbanoThe Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering 2007 · DOI

Abstract

The aerodynamic performance characteristics of a horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT) using NACA44xx, LS04xx, and NACA64-415 aerofoils were investigated theoretically and experimentally. The analysis combined momentum, energy, and blade element theory (MEBT) via the strip element method. Sectional lift ($C_L$) and drag ($C_D$) data were analyzed using JavaFoil. Experimental validation was conducted using a subscale model. The study clarifies the impact of blade diameter, number, chord length, and twist pitch angle on power ($C_p$), torque ($C_q$), and thrust ($C_T$) coefficients across varying tip speed ratios ($\lambda$), providing insights for optimum design and control.

Introduction

Designing efficient horizontal axis wind turbines (HAWT) requires a precise balance between blade geometry and aerodynamic profiles. While standard NACA profiles are common, their performance varies significantly with turbine scale and wind conditions. This research addresses the need for robust analytical methods to predict performance across scales, specifically comparing the high-lift LS04 series, the standard NACA44 series, and the low-drag NACA64 laminar series.

Comparison of the three aerofoil profiles: NACA4415, LS0417, and NACA64-415.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  1. Theoretical Modeling: A "Strip Element Method" based on Momentum, Energy, and Blade Element Theory (MEBT) was used. Unlike basic models, this approach includes an energy dissipation term ($L_{dis}$) to account for losses due to blade drag.
  2. Aerofoil Analysis: Sectional lift ($C_L$) and drag ($C_D$) coefficients were generated using JavaFoil software for the three aerofoil types across a range of Reynolds numbers ($Re$).
  3. Experimental Validation: A subscale wind turbine model (D ≈ 0.85m) was tested in a wind tunnel at speeds of 4.3–4.5 m/s to validate the theoretical power coefficients ($C_p$).

Aerodynamic Performance and Scaling

A critical finding of this study is the scale-dependency of aerofoil performance, driven by the Reynolds number ($Re$).

Lift coefficient ($C_L$) vs. angle of attack ($\alpha$) for the studied aerofoils at different Reynolds numbers.

As shown in the performance data, at low Reynolds numbers (typical of small models), the laminar NACA64-415 aerofoil struggles to maintain lift. However, as the scale increases to utility-sized turbines with higher Reynolds numbers, its low-drag characteristics provide a significant advantage.

Key Insights

  • Reynolds Number Divide: At high $Re$, the NACA64-415 (Laminar) aerofoil achieved the highest power coefficient in simulations, followed by the LS0417.
  • Drag Dissipation: Increasing the blade count (e.g., from 2 to 5) for a fixed total area leads to higher cumulative drag losses at high tip speed ratios. This explains why 2-blade configurations often reach higher peak efficiency.
  • Pitch Control Synergy: The high-lift LS04 series showed a unique response to pitch adjustments, allowing for improved torque at low speeds and reduced thrust at high speeds, making it a strong candidate for turbines using pitch-controlled regulation.

Conclusion

The theoretical MEBT model showed excellent agreement with experimental data. While aerofoil choice is less critical for small-scale models, laminar flow aerofoils like the NACA64 series offer substantial performance gains for large-scale, high-Reynolds-number turbines. Future work should address 3D tip losses and structural challenges associated with thinner laminar profiles in mega-scale applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Aerodynamic performance characteristics of a horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT) using by NACA44xx, LSO4xx, and NACA64-415 aerofoils were investigated theoretically by an analysis involving a combination of momentum, energy, and blade element theory by means of the strip element method, based on the detail date of C_L, C_D characteristics of the employed blades analyzed by the soft of Java Foil, and experimentally by the use of a subscale model. The characteristics of HAWT employed NACA44xx, LSO4xx and NACA64-415 aerofoil blades for the different types of the blades such as blade dia. D and number N, chord length l, twist pitch angle θ, and for large scale units are discussed and cleared by reference to the power, torque and thrust coefficient, C_p, C_q, C_T, and the tip speed ratio λ from the point of view of the optimum design and controlling.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{araya2007aerodynamic,
  author = {Yasuhiko Araya and Koki Kishinami and Jun Suzuki and Himsar Ambarita and Takahiro Koikeda and K Turi and Hiroshi Ibano},
  title = {{432 Aerodynamic Characteristics of H.A.W.T. by Using Aerofoils of NACA44xx, LSO4xx, and NACA64-415}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmeenv.2007.17.372},
}
Figure