Studies of directed flow with event plane method in the HIRFL-CSR external-target experiment

Wei Wu, Xiong-Hong He, Yan-Yu Ren, Di-Yu Shen, Shu-Su Shi, X. SunarXiv 2025 · arXiv

Abstract

The Cooling-Storage-Ring External-target Experiment (CEE) at Heavy Ion Research Facility in Lanzhou (HIRFL) is designed to study the properties of nuclear matter created in heavy-ion collisions at a few hundred MeV/$u$ to 1 GeV/$u$ beam energies, facilitating the research of quantum chromodynamics phase structure in the high-baryon-density region. Collective flow is one of the most important observables in heavy-ion collision experiments to study the bulk behavior of the created matter. Even though the standard event plane method has been widely used for collective flow measurements, it remains crucial to validate and optimize this method for the CEE spectrometer. In this paper, we study the experimental procedures of measuring directed flow in $^{238}$U+$^{238}$U collisions at 500 MeV/$u$ using event planes reconstructed by Multi Wire Drift Chamber and Zero Degree Calorimeter, respectively. Jet AA Microscopic (JAM) transport generator is used to generate events, and the detector response is simulated by the CEE Fast Simulation (CFS) package. Finally, the optimal kinetic region for proton directed flow measurements is discussed for the future CEE experiment.

Introduction

Understanding the "Equation of State" of nuclear matter—how it behaves under extreme pressure and density—is a central goal of high-energy nuclear physics. This research provides insights into conditions similar to those found in the cores of neutron stars. A key experimental probe for these properties is collective flow, the anisotropic expansion of particles following a heavy-ion collision.

Schematic layout of the CEE spectrometer showing the various detector components including the TPC, MWDC, and ZDC.

Measuring collective flow requires determining the "reaction plane" of the collision. Since this cannot be observed directly, physicists estimate an "event plane" based on detected particle distributions. However, experimental setups like the CEE introduce biases; for instance, the 0.5-Tesla dipole magnet bends charged particles, creating asymmetric data distributions. This paper details the development and validation of correction algorithms to extract accurate physics signals from the CEE spectrometer.

Methods

The study utilized a comprehensive simulation framework to validate the event plane method:

  1. Event Generation: The JAM (Jet AA Microscopic) transport model simulated $^{238}$U + $^{238}$U collisions at a center-of-mass energy ($\sqrt{s_{NN}}$) of 2.1 GeV (500 MeV per nucleon).
  2. Detector Simulation: The CFS (CEE Fast Simulation) package modeled the response of the CEE hardware, including the Time Projection Chamber (TPC), Multi-Wire Drift Chambers (MWDC), and Zero Degree Calorimeter (ZDC).
  3. Correction Algorithms: To counteract detector bias and magnetic field interference, the authors applied "re-centering" and "shifting" techniques to the MWDC data. For the ZDC, a "position weight correction" was developed to account for the magnet's tendency to push charged particles toward one side of the calorimeter.
  4. Validation: The flow signal extracted via these corrected event planes was compared against the "true" flow values provided by the JAM model.

Results and Discussion

The simulation results confirm the robustness of the CEE's design. The MWDC achieved an event plane resolution of approximately 90%, while the ZDC reached 70% for mid-central collisions (impact parameter $b$ between 5 and 7 fm).

Comparison of directed flow ($v_1$) as a function of rapidity ($y$) extracted using different event plane methods compared to the true simulation values.

As shown in the figure above, the directed flow ($v_1$) extracted using the event plane method is highly consistent with the "true" simulation values within a $1\sigma$ margin of error. The researchers measured a directed flow slope ($dv_1/dy$) of approximately 0.63, establishing a clear benchmark for future experiments. Furthermore, the study found that the extracted flow signal remains stable even if detector efficiency fluctuates by up to 10%, indicating high operational resilience. To avoid "self-correlation" biases, the study recommends utilizing the ZDC specifically for measuring "backward" protons within the TPC.

Conclusion

This technical roadmap demonstrates that the CEE spectrometer, equipped with its proposed correction algorithms, can reliably measure directed flow to probe high-density nuclear matter. Future research will focus on mitigating "non-flow" effects in highly central collisions ($b < 1$ fm) and extending these validation methods to other particle species, such as pions and light nuclei, to provide a more comprehensive view of collision dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Cooling-Storage-Ring External-target Experiment (CEE) at Heavy Ion Research Facility in Lanzhou (HIRFL) is designed to study the properties of nuclear matter created in heavy-ion collisions at a few hundred MeV/$u$ to 1 GeV/$u$ beam energies, facilitating the research of quantum chromodynamics phase structure in the high-baryon-density region. Collective flow is one of the most important observables in heavy-ion collision experiments to study the bulk behavior of the created matter. Even though the standard event plane method has been widely used for collective flow measurements, it remains crucial to validate and optimize this method for the CEE spectrometer. In this paper, we study the experimental procedures of measuring directed flow in $^{238}$U+$^{238}$U collisions at 500 MeV/$u$ using event planes reconstructed by Multi Wire Drift Chamber and Zero Degree Calorimeter, respectively. Jet AA Microscopic (JAM) transport generator is used to generate events, and the detector response is simulated by the CEE Fast Simulation (CFS) package. Finally, the optimal kinetic region for proton directed flow measurements is discussed for the future CEE experiment.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2025studies,
  author = {Wei Wu and Xiong-Hong He and Yan-Yu Ren and Di-Yu Shen and Shu-Su Shi and X. Sun},
  title = {{Studies of directed flow with event plane method in the HIRFL-CSR external-target experiment}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.22774},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.22774},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure