Nuclear flow excitation function

Dietrich Klakow, G. Welke, W. BauerPhysical 1993 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We consider the dependence of collective flow on the nuclear surface thickness in a Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck (BUU) transport model of heavy ion collisions. Well-defined surfaces are introduced by giving test particles a Gaussian density profile of constant width. Zeros of the flow excitation function are as much influenced by the surface thickness as the nuclear equation of state, and the dependence of this effect is understood in terms of a simple potential scattering model. Realistic calculations must also take into account medium effects for the nucleon-nucleon cross section and impact parameter averaging. We find that balance energy scales with the mass number as $A^{-y}$, where $y$ has a numerical value between 0.35 and 0.5, depending on the assumptions about the in-medium nucleon-nucleon cross section.

Introduction

In heavy-ion collisions, the movement of nuclear matter is characterized by "collective flow." This phenomenon is a result of the interplay between two competing forces: the attractive nuclear mean field, which dominates at low energies, and the repulsive effects of nucleon-nucleon collisions and kinetic pressure, which dominate at high energies. The specific beam energy at which these forces cancel out—resulting in zero net flow—is known as the balance energy ($E_{Bal}$).

$E_{Bal}$ is a critical observable because it serves as a probe for the nuclear Equation of State (EOS)—the "stiffness" of nuclear matter—and the behavior of nucleons within a dense medium. However, accurately modeling this energy requires distinguishing between physical effects and numerical artifacts inherent in transport simulations.

Addressing Numerical Artifacts in Transport Models

Standard numerical simulations, such as the Boltzmann–Uehling–Uhlenbeck (BUU) model, often calculate density on a fixed spatial grid. In these models, the grid size ($\Delta x$) can unintentionally dictate the thickness of the nuclear surface. This creates a problem: if the calculated flow changes based on the grid resolution, it becomes difficult to determine whether the results reflect real physics or are merely artifacts of the simulation's setup.

To resolve this, the authors implemented a refined approach by assigning each test particle a Gaussian density profile with a fixed width. This modification allows the nuclear surface thickness to be varied independently of the numerical grid, ensuring that the resulting flow dynamics are physically grounded rather than a byproduct of the numerical discretization.

Methodology

The study employs two primary theoretical frameworks:

  1. BUU Transport Model: A standard tool that tracks the evolution of test particles, accounting for both the mean-field potential and individual collisions.
  2. Vlasov Dynamics: A subset of the BUU model that isolates the effects of the mean-field potential by ignoring hard collisions.

Additionally, the researchers investigated in-medium effects on the nucleon-nucleon (NN) cross-section ($\sigma_{NN}$). They introduced a parameter $\alpha_1$ to model how the cross-section changes in dense nuclear matter using a Taylor expansion: $$\sigma_{NN}(\rho) = (1 + \alpha_1 \frac{\rho}{\rho_0}) \sigma_{NN}(0)$$ where $\rho_0$ is the normal nuclear density.

Key Insights: The Importance of the Surface

The simulations revealed that the thickness of the nuclear surface has a profound impact on collective flow. A thinner nuclear surface produces significantly more flow than a thicker one. Specifically, varying the surface thickness from 1 fm to 2 fm shifted the balance energy by approximately 10 MeV. This shift is comparable in magnitude to the effect of changing the entire Equation of State from "stiff" to "soft," highlighting that surface modeling is just as critical as the EOS itself for interpreting experimental data.

Scaling Laws and Mass Number

The research confirms that the balance energy follows a power-law relationship with the mass number ($A$) of the colliding nuclei: $$E_{Bal} = xA^{-y}$$ The exponent $y$ was found to be highly sensitive to the in-medium NN cross-section. When the cross-section is reduced in dense matter (a negative $\alpha_1$), the value of $y$ increases. Furthermore, the "impact parameter" (how off-center the collision is) shifts $E_{Bal}$; peripheral collisions show a higher balance energy because the mean field dominates more than NN collisions due to reduced volume overlap.

Results and Experimental Comparison

The model's predictions were compared against established experimental data from $^{139}La + ^{139}La$, $^{12}C + ^{12}C$, and $^{40}Ar + V$ reactions.

  • Scaling Exponent: The calculated value for $y$ typically fell between 0.35 and 0.5. This is in reasonable agreement with experimental observations, which suggest $y \approx 0.33 \pm 0.04$.
  • In-Medium Effects: The best fit for the magnitude of $E_{Bal}$ across different systems occurred with $\alpha_1 = -0.2$. This implies a 20% reduction in the nucleon-nucleon cross-section at normal nuclear density.
  • Vlasov vs. BUU: While simplified potential scattering models (Vlasov) can explain the general trend of surface dependence, full BUU calculations including collisions are necessary to identify the exact "zeros" in the flow excitation function.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work demonstrates that the "zeros" of the flow excitation function are deeply influenced by the initial conditions of the nuclei, particularly the surface thickness. For transport models to provide quantitative insights into the nuclear Equation of State, they must accurately account for these surface effects and in-medium cross-sections.

The authors note that while this study provides a strong framework, future work requires "impact parameter averaging"—simulating many different collision angles—to achieve a truly quantitative comparison with experimental data. Additionally, moving beyond a constant $\alpha_1$ to more realistic, energy-dependent models for in-medium cross-sections may further refine the scaling law exponent $y$.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the dependence of collective flow on the nuclear surface thickness in a Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck transport model of heavy ion collisions. Well-defined surfaces are introduced by giving test particles a Gaussian density profile of constant width. Zeros of the flow excitation function are as much influenced by the surface thickness as the nuclear equation of state, and the dependence of this effect is understood in terms of a simple potential scattering model. Realistic calculations must also take into account medium effects for the nucleon-nucleon cross section, and impact parameter averaging. We find that balance energy scales with the mass number as ${\mathit{A}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}\mathit{y}}$, where y has a numerical value between 0.35 and 0.5, depending on the assumptions about the in-medium nucleon-nucleon cross section.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{klakow1993nuclear,
  author = {Dietrich Klakow and G. Welke and W. Bauer},
  title = {{Nuclear flow excitation function}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {1993},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevc.48.1982},
}
Figure