The influence of KN potential on the production of kaon mesons in heavy-ion collisions at intermediate energies

Miao Li, Chenchen Guo, LiYan Zou, Yongjia Wang, Qingfeng Li, Ling LiuZhongguo 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Kaon mesons produced in heavy-ion collisions serve as vital probes for investigating the properties of dense nuclear matter, specifically the Equation of State (EOS). By employing an updated version of the Ultra-relativistic Quantum Molecular Dynamics (UrQMD) model, this research demonstrates that the inclusion of the Kaon-Nucleon (KN) potential is essential for accurately modeling particle flow. Furthermore, the study identifies the $K^0/K^+$ yield ratio as a highly sensitive indicator of the density dependence of nuclear symmetry energy, particularly at intermediate collision energies.

Introduction: The Equation of State Mystery

One of the fundamental challenges in nuclear physics is determining the Equation of State (EOS) of dense nuclear matter—the set of rules governing how pressure, temperature, and density interact within nucleons. A critical yet uncertain component of this EOS is symmetry energy, which describes how a system's energy changes as the ratio of neutrons to protons is altered.

To probe these conditions, scientists collide heavy ions, such as gold nuclei, at relativistic speeds to create a short-lived "fireball" of high-density matter. Because this state exists only for a fraction of a second, researchers rely on "probes"—particles like kaons (K mesons) that are produced early in the collision and can escape the dense medium with information about its properties. However, standard transport models have historically struggled to match experimental data regarding kaon movement, or "flow."

Methodology: Modeling the KN Potential

To address these discrepancies, researchers utilized an updated UrQMD transport model. The primary innovation was the explicit integration of the Kaon-Nucleon (KN) potential, derived from chiral Lagrangian theory. This potential characterizes the repulsive force that kaons experience when surrounded by nucleons in a dense environment.

Extracted figure from page 4 of The influence of KN potential on the production of kaon mesons in heavy-ion collisions at intermediate energies

As shown in the figure above, the potential $U_k$ is fundamentally repulsive, increasing significantly as the baryon density rises. To test the model's sensitivity, the team also incorporated various Skyrme energy density functionals to simulate different levels of "stiffness" in the nuclear symmetry energy.

Results: Correcting the Flow and Squeeze-Out

The inclusion of the repulsive KN potential proved to be the "missing ingredient" for modeling collective flow. Without this potential, simulations predicted that kaons would flow in the same direction as the bulk nuclear matter. With the potential, the kaons are "pushed" away, aligning the model with experimental observations of negative directed flow ($v_1$) and enhanced elliptic flow ($v_2$), also known as "squeeze-out."

Elliptic flow $v_2$ of $K^+$ mesons as a function of normalized rapidity $y_0$, comparing simulations with and without the KN potential.

In the figure above, the simulation including the KN potential (dashed red line) shows a more pronounced negative elliptic flow compared to the version without it (solid blue line). This shift indicates a stronger squeeze-out effect, which more accurately reflects the experimental data from collaborations like FOPI and KaoS.

Probing Symmetry Energy with the $K^0/K^+$ Ratio

Beyond flow, the study highlights the $K^0/K^+$ production ratio as a powerful "thermometer" for isospin effects. Because $K^0$ and $K^+$ mesons have different isospin, their relative production is sensitive to the neutron-richness of the high-density fireball.

The research found that a "soft" symmetry energy (where neutrons are more easily packed) results in a higher $K^0/K^+$ ratio than a "stiff" one. Notably, this sensitivity increases at lower collision energies near the production threshold. At 0.8 GeV/nucleon, the $K^0/K^+$ ratio proved to be a more sensitive probe for the stiffness of nuclear matter than the traditionally used pion ($\pi^-/\pi^+$) ratio, providing a clear linear relationship that experimentalists can use to measure the symmetry energy slope parameter ($L$).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The inclusion of the KN potential significantly improves the theoretical description of kaon dynamics in heavy-ion collisions. While it primarily affects flow rather than total yield, it provides a robust framework for extracting the nuclear EOS. Future work will focus on incorporating "in-medium" effects on production thresholds and refining theoretical support for upcoming experiments at the High Intensity heavy ion Accelerator Facility (HIAF) in China.

Summary updated

Abstract

The kaon meson produced in heavy ion collisions can be taken as a useful probe for investigating the properties of dense nuclear matter. With the help of transport model simulations, it can be used to extract the information of the equation of state of nuclear matter. Within the newly updated version of the ultrarelativistic quantum molecular dynamics (UrQMD) model, the kaon-nucleon (KN) potential is further taken into account and its influence on both the yield and the directed and elliptic flows of kaon mesons produced in Au+Au collisions at intermediate energies ($E_{\rm lab}$=0.6-2.0 GeV$/$nucleon) is investigated. It is found that the experimental data of flows can be better described with the consideration of the KN potential, and it is further found that the K$^0$/K$^+$ yield ratio is affected by the density dependence of the nuclear symmetry energy. The K$^0$/K$^+$ ratio calculated with a soft symmetry energy is larger than that with a stiff one, and the sensitivity to the density dependence of the nuclear symmetry energy at lower beam energy becomes larger. At the low energy such as 0.8 GeV$/$nucleon, the K$^0$/K$^+$ ratio is more sensitive to the stiffness of nuclear symmetry energy than the $\uppi^-$/$\uppi^+$ ratio is.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2017influence,
  author = {Miao Li and Chenchen Guo and LiYan Zou and Yongjia Wang and Qingfeng Li and Ling Liu},
  title = {{The influence of KN potential on the production of kaon mesons in heavy-ion collisions at intermediate energies}},
  booktitle = {Zhongguo},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1360/sspma2016-00433},
}
Figure