Use of neutrino scattering events with low hadronic recoil to inform neutrino flux and detector energy scale

A. Bashyal, D. Rimal, B. Messerly, Z. Ahmad Dar, F. Akbar, M. V. Ascencio, A. Bercellie, M. Betancourt, A. Bodek, J. L. Bonilla, A. Bravar, H. S. Budd, G. Cáceres, T. Cai, M. F. Carneiro, H. da Motta, S. Dytman, G. A. Díaz, J. Félix, L. Fields, A. Filkins, R. Fine, A. M. Gago, H. Gallagher, A. Ghosh, S. Gilligan, R. Gran, Deborah A. Harris, S. Henry, S. Jena, C. Jena, J. Kleykamp, M. Kordosky, A. Lozano, X.-g. Lu, E. Maher, S. Manly, W. A. Mann, C. Mauger, K. S. McFarland, J. Miller, J. G. Morfín, D. Naples, J. K. Nelson, C. Nguyen, A. Olivier, V. Paolone, Gabriel Perdue, M. A. Ramírez, H. Ray, D. Ruterbories, H. Schellman, C. J. Solano Salinas, Hang Su, M. Sultana, V. S. Syrotenko, E. Valencia, N. Vaughan, A. V. Waldron, C. Wret B. Yaeggy, K. Yang, L. ZazuetaJournal of Instrumentation 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Charged-current neutrino interactions with low hadronic recoil ("low-nu") have a cross-section that is approximately constant versus neutrino energy. These interactions have been used to measure the shape of neutrino fluxes as a function of neutrino energy at accelerator-based neutrino experiments such as CCFR, NuTeV, MINOS and MINERvA. In this paper, we demonstrate that low-nu events can be used to measure parameters of neutrino flux and detector models and that utilization of event distributions over the upstream detector face can discriminate among parameters that affect the neutrino flux model. From fitting a large sample of low-nu events obtained by exposing MINERvA to the NuMI medium-energy beam, we find that the best-fit flux parameters are within their a priori uncertainties, but the energy scale of muons reconstructed in the MINOS detector is shifted by 3.6% (or 1.8 times the a priori uncertainty on that parameter). These fit results are now used in all MINERvA cross-section measurements, and this technique can be applied by other experiments operating at MINERvA energies, such as DUNE.

Introduction

Measuring neutrino cross-sections requires a precise understanding of the neutrino flux—the number of neutrinos passing through the detector per unit area and time, as a function of energy. In accelerator-based experiments like MINERvA, neutrino beams are produced by colliding high-energy protons with a target, creating a hadronic shower that decays into neutrinos. Uncertainties in beamline components, such as target positioning and magnetic horn currents, introduce significant systematic errors into the predicted flux. Furthermore, detector miscalibrations can mimic flux variations, creating a degeneracy between beam models and detector response.

The Low-$\nu$ Method

To address these challenges, the MINERvA collaboration utilized the "low-$\nu$" method, where $\nu$ represents the hadronic recoil energy. For charged-current neutrino interactions with low hadronic recoil (defined here as $\nu < 800$ MeV), the interaction cross-section is approximately independent of the incident neutrino energy. This property allows these events to serve as a "standard candle" to measure the shape of the neutrino energy spectrum.

Reconstructed neutrino energy spectra for data and simulation, showing POT-normalized and area-normalized distributions.

Spatial Analysis and Self-Calibration

A key innovation in this work is the use of spatial information across the detector face. The MINERvA detector was divided into seven transverse regions. This spatial binning allows for the disentanglement of flux and detector uncertainties: beam alignment issues typically produce asymmetric patterns across the detector, whereas a global detector energy scale shift affects all regions uniformly.

The analysis involved a joint $\chi^2$ fit of beam parameters and the muon energy scale. The data was collected using the NuMI beam in its "Medium Energy" configuration, with simulations performed using g4numi for the beamline and GENIE (version 2.12.6) for neutrino interactions.

Results and Impact

The most significant result of the fit was identifying a 3.6% shift in the muon energy scale for the MINOS Near Detector, which serves as the spectrometer for MINERvA. This shift is 1.8 times the a priori estimated uncertainty. Adjusting for this shift significantly improved the agreement between data and simulation across all energy bins and spatial regions.

Fractional uncertainty components for the neutrino energy spectrum.

The fit also confirmed that beam alignment parameters were within their expected tolerances. These results have been integrated into all subsequent MINERvA cross-section measurements, providing a more robust foundation for high-precision neutrino physics.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the low-$\nu$ method is highly effective at medium energies, its precision is limited at low neutrino energies ($E_\nu < 1.5$ GeV) due to detector acceptance thresholds. Additionally, the method assumes the theoretical cross-section is flat at low recoil, a prediction that remains a subject of ongoing study. This "self-calibration" approach serves as a precursor to future strategies, such as the DUNE-PRISM concept, which will utilize movable detectors to further constrain neutrino flux and interaction models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Charged-current neutrino interactions with low hadronic recoil ("low-nu") have a cross-section that is approximately constant versus neutrino energy. These interactions have been used to measure the shape of neutrino fluxes as a function of neutrino energy at accelerator-based neutrino experiments such as CCFR, NuTeV, MINOS and MINERvA. In this paper, we demonstrate that low-nu events can be used to measure parameters of neutrino flux and detector models and that utilization of event distributions over the upstream detector face can discriminate among parameters that affect the neutrino flux model. From fitting a large sample of low-nu events obtained by exposing MINERvA to the NuMI medium-energy beam, we find that the best-fit flux parameters are within their a priori uncertainties, but the energy scale of muons reconstructed in the MINOS detector is shifted by 3.6% (or 1.8 times the a priori uncertainty on that parameter). These fit results are now used in all MINERvA cross-section measurements, and this technique can be applied by other experiments operating at MINERvA energies, such as DUNE.
BibTeX
@article{bashyal2021use,
  author = {A. Bashyal and D. Rimal and B. Messerly and Z. Ahmad Dar and F. Akbar and M. V. Ascencio and A. Bercellie and M. Betancourt and A. Bodek and J. L. Bonilla and A. Bravar and H. S. Budd and G. Cáceres and T. Cai and M. F. Carneiro and H. da Motta and S. Dytman and G. A. Díaz and J. Félix and L. Fields and A. Filkins and R. Fine and A. M. Gago and H. Gallagher and A. Ghosh and S. Gilligan and R. Gran and Deborah A. Harris and S. Henry and S. Jena and C. Jena and J. Kleykamp and M. Kordosky and A. Lozano and X.-G. Lu and E. Maher and S. Manly and W. A. Mann and C. Mauger and K. S. McFarland and J. Miller and J. G. Morfín and D. Naples and J. K. Nelson and C. Nguyen and A. Olivier and V. Paolone and Gabriel Perdue and M. A. Ramírez and H. Ray and D. Ruterbories and H. Schellman and C. J. Solano Salinas and Hang Su and M. Sultana and V. S. Syrotenko and E. Valencia and N. Vaughan and A. V. Waldron and C. Wret B. Yaeggy and K. Yang and L. Zazueta and K. Yang and L. Zazueta},
  title = {{Use of neutrino scattering events with low hadronic recoil to inform neutrino flux and detector energy scale}},
  journal = {Journal of Instrumentation},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1088/1748-0221/16/08/p08068},
}
Measurement of the $^8$B Solar Neutrino Flux Using the Full SNO+ Water Phase DatasetarXiv · 2024
Measurement of the antineutrino to neutrino charged-current interaction cross section ratio in MINERvAPhysical · 2017
Measurement of <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msub><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi><mml:mi>μ</mml:mi></mml:msub></mml:math> charged-current single <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:msup><mml:mi>π</mml:mi><mml:mn>0</mml:mn></mml:msup></mml:math> production on hydrocarbon in the few-GeV region using MINERvAPhysical · 2017
Calibration of muon reconstruction algorithms using an external muon tracking system at the Sudbury Neutrino ObservatoryNuclear · 2011
SOLVING THE SOLAR NEUTRINO PROBLEM 2 km UNDERGROUND — THE SUDBURY NEUTRINO OBSERVATORYAstroparticle, · 2004
Measurement of inclusive charged-current <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi>μ</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:math> scattering on hydrocarbon at <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:mo stretchy="false">⟨</mml:mo><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mi>E</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi>ν</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:msub><mml:mo stretchy="false">⟩</mml:mo><mml:mo>∼</mml:mo><mml:mn>6</mml:mn><mml:mtext> </mml:mtext><mml:mtext> </mml:mtext><mml:mi>GeV</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:math> with low three-momentum transferarXiv · 2021
Figure