Abstract: In 2022, under the dual influence of the COVID-19 and the international situation, China's economic development pressure will continue to rise. China has always regarded "innovation" as the core of its national development strategy. With the implementation of Wenzhou's strategy of creating "two healthy" pilot areas in the new era, Wenzhou has put forward many innovative policies. This research intends to collect the innovation policy texts issued by Wenzhou in the past, analyze the characteristics and direction of innovation policy formulation in Wenzhou through word frequency statistical analysis and word cloud map construction, and draw conclusions. The research found that the main direction of innovation policy formulation in Wenzhou is to use innovation to promote Wenzhou's industrial transformation and upgrading and high-quality economic development, including Zhejiang manufacturing, digitization, intelligence, independent innovation and other keywords. Furthermore, Wenzhou Municipal Government can improve the design concept and method of innovation policy from four aspects.
Introduction
Wenzhou is historically recognized in China as a pioneer of the private economy. However, as global economic pressures mount—exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic and shifting international trade dynamics—traditional manufacturing hubs face a critical "transform or perish" dilemma. While the Wenzhou Municipal Government has released numerous policies to spur innovation, these documents are often scattered across different departments. This study addresses the lack of a systematic, data-driven overview by quantifying the "language of governance" to determine if legislative efforts align with modern goals like digitization and high-quality industrial upgrading.
Methodology
The researchers employed a multi-step Natural Language Processing (NLP) and statistical pipeline to analyze the policy landscape:
- Text Segmentation: The Jieba library in Python was used to break down policy documents into individual keywords.
- Data Cleaning: Meaningless stop words were removed to isolate 194 core "theme words."
- Frequency Analysis: Donohue’s high-low frequency formula was applied to filter noise and identify the 41 most significant subject words (those appearing more than five times across the corpus).
- Network Visualization: A co-occurrence network map was constructed to visualize the relationships between different policy goals, where node size represents frequency and connecting lines represent how often terms appear together in the same document.
Policy Landscape and Keyword Frequency
The study utilized a custom-curated dataset of 69 valid policy documents issued by the Wenzhou People's Government between 2012 and April 2022. These policies generally fall into two pillars: Innovation System Construction (e.g., incubators, IP protection) and Industrial Development (e.g., digital economy, logistics).
As shown in the frequency data, Intellectual Property (IP) is the foundational priority, appearing 557 times—nearly double the next most frequent term. This suggests that Wenzhou views legal protection as the essential prerequisite for innovation. Furthermore, the high frequency of "Small and micro enterprise" (281) reflects Wenzhou’s unique economic structure, which relies on a vast network of small private businesses rather than massive state-owned conglomerates.
Strategic Interconnectivity and Network Analysis
The data reveals a clear shift from simple volume-based manufacturing to high-tech, data-driven production, evidenced by terms like "digitization," "intelligence," and "intelligent manufacturing."
The network map demonstrates that innovation is rarely discussed in isolation. It is tightly linked to "financial policy" and "industrial agglomeration," indicating that the government views innovation as a holistic ecosystem requiring both capital and physical infrastructure, such as "incubators" and "maker spaces."
Conclusion and Policy Recommendations
While Wenzhou has established a robust framework for innovation, the authors identify several areas for improvement:
- Tool Diversity: Current policies rely heavily on voluntary guidance. A better mix of incentives ("carrots") and mandatory standards ("sticks") is recommended to ensure enterprise compliance.
- Audience Expansion: Policies are currently very government-to-business (G2B) focused; broadening the audience to involve more sectors of society could improve the innovation climate.
- Implementation Gap: Future research should correlate these textual trends with actual economic outcomes—such as GDP growth or patent filing rates—to measure the real-world efficiency of these policies.
Summary updated