Social network analysis of intergovernmental relations and policy tools in China’s coastal reclamation management

Hongbo Gong, Xiangmei He, Jialin Li, Peng Tian, Shunyi Ai, Yongchao LiuFrontiers in Marine Science 2024 · DOI

This research paper, published in Frontiers in Marine Science, applies social network analysis (SNA) to map the 44-year evolution of China’s coastal reclamation policies. By analyzing 226 policy documents, the authors reveal how the governance of "creating land from the sea" shifted from a simple, development-first approach to a complex, environment-centric network of 23 government departments, while highlighting critical imbalances in the policy "tool kit" used today.

The Challenge of Coastal Reclamation

Coastal reclamation—turning sea into land—is a double-edged sword. It provides vital space for urban and industrial growth but often devastates marine ecosystems. China has experienced four major surges in reclamation since 1949, and managing this process requires a delicate balance between economic needs and environmental protection.

The authors identify a gap in existing research: while many studies look at the spatial impact of reclamation, few have rigorously analyzed the bureaucratic machinery behind it. Specifically, they tackle the "black box" of intergovernmental relations: Which departments hold the most power? Which policy tools (like financial incentives vs. strict regulations) are being ignored? And how have these relationships evolved as China moved toward its "Ecological Civilization" mandate?

Methodology: Mapping the Bureaucratic Network

The study employs a hybrid approach to decode nearly half a century of management:

  • Content Analysis: The authors encoded 226 policy documents (1978–2022) sourced from Peking University’s Law Database and the State Council Policy Document Library.
  • Policy Tool Framework: They categorized policies using the Rothwell and Zegveld framework, which divides tools into Supply-side (tech support, info), Demand-side (market incentives, pilot projects), and Environment-side (regulations, goal planning).
  • Social Network Analysis (SNA): Using UCINET6 and NETDRAW, they constructed "2-mode networks" to visualize the links between specific government departments and the policy tools they employ, measuring centrality and cohesive subgroups.

The Evolution of Policy Stages

The analysis reveals a distinct shift in policy focus over four decades. Early policies (1978–1998) were development-centric, focusing on salt drying and agriculture. In contrast, the current era (2018–2022) is protection-centric, characterized by a near-total ban on reclamation except for major national projects.

Each stage of coastal reclamation management and control policies (1978–2022).

Key Insights: Core-Periphery Structures and Tool Imbalances

  • The "Core-Periphery" Evolution: The network started as a simple, flat structure. Since 1999, it has evolved into a "core-periphery" model. A few "powerhouse" departments—the Ministry of Natural Resources (MNR) and the Ministry of Ecology and Environment (MEE)—now act as central hubs, while others (like Energy or Cultural Relics) have been pushed to the periphery.
  • The Tool Imbalance: There is a striking "over-reliance" on environment-side tools (regulations and planning). Environment-side tools were used 361 times, compared to 323 for Supply-side and only 155 for Demand-side tools—those that use market mechanisms or incentives to change behavior.
  • Bureaucratic "Factions": The study identified specific working cliques, such as "Environmental Protection Factions" and "Audit Factions," showing that different departments cluster together depending on whether the goal is restoration, approval, or propaganda.

Key Results

  • Network Complexity: The governance network expanded to include 23 administrative departments.
  • Centrality Scores: In the most recent phase (2018–2022), the Ministry of Natural Resources and the Ministry of Ecology and Environment achieved the highest degree centrality (0.824), marking them as the undisputed leaders of the policy network.
  • Policy Conflict: As the network became more complex, "vertical" management (top-down) began to clash with "horizontal" provincial differences, leading to noticeable contradictions in policy texts regarding sea-use approval thresholds.

Limitations and Future Directions

The authors acknowledge that policy sustainability is currently inadequate, with a lack of robust post-event supervision and accountability mechanisms. There is also significant variation between coastal provinces in how they interpret sea-use rights, leading to legal friction.

The paper suggests that future research should focus on policy visualization to help administrators balance their toolkits and resolve the internal contradictions between higher-level and lower-level laws. They also call for a more market-oriented approach to resource allocation to fix the current tool imbalance.

Summary updated

Abstract

As an effective means of sea development and utilization, high-intensity coastal reclamation activities lead to increasingly prominent ecological problems. The accurate implementation of policies is paramount in managing and controlling coastal reclamation. We reviewed China’s coastal reclamation management and control policies from 1978 to 2022. Utilizing content analysis and social network analysis, we constructed a policy network to explore the evolution of intergovernmental relations and the habitual combination of policy tools in coastal reclamation management and control. The study shows that (1) The intergovernmental relations of reclamation management and control agencies have evolved from simple to complex, with key departments becoming increasingly prominent; (2) Environmental considerations form the mainstay of policy tools for reclamation control, highlighting an imbalance between supply-side and demand-side approaches; (3) Since 1999, the interactive network between intergovernmental relations and policy tools has begun to exhibit a distinct core-periphery structure, and the social circle has gradually expanded to form a social circle consisting of 23 administrative departments and most departmental policy tools, while there are also some independent working factions at different stages; (4) Policy sustainability is currently inadequate, and in the later stages of management and control, there is a noticeable conflict within the policy texts. The study shows that, China’s coastal reclamation management and controlstill faces challenges, It is necessary to continue to explore the policy visualization methods used in coastal reclamation to help balance policy tools and build efficient intergovernmental relations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2024social,
  author = {Hongbo Gong and Xiangmei He and Jialin Li and Peng Tian and Shunyi Ai and Yongchao Liu},
  title = {{Social network analysis of intergovernmental relations and policy tools in China’s coastal reclamation management}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2024.1417616},
}
Figure