Abstract
This article presents a comprehensive review of China’s policy system for the management of natural hazard-induced disasters from 1949 to 2016 through a quantitative bibliometric analysis of 5,472 policy documents. It identifies four phases of China’s evolving disaster management system, which focused on agriculture, economic development, government and professional capacity building, and disaster governance, respectively. Characteristics of policies and contributing factors of policy change in each of the four phases are discussed in depth. This article provides a quantitative foundation for understanding the dynamic policy change of the disaster management system in China with a particular emphasis on the governance capacity and may serve as a basis for exploring the potential pathways of transformation according to the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 and the Sustainable Development Goals.
Introduction
China is among the most disaster-prone nations globally, facing frequent and severe natural hazards that challenge its social and economic stability. Historically, the study of China's disaster management has relied on qualitative assessments or narrow case studies. This paper addresses this gap by providing a quantitative map of the country's disaster management evolution over nearly seven decades. By analyzing a massive corpus of state-level policy documents, the research uncovers how the system transformed from a passive, reactive response mechanism into a complex, integrated governance structure.
Methodology
The study utilized the PKULaw Database, the most comprehensive archive of Chinese legal and regulatory documents, to identify 5,472 validated policy documents related to natural hazard-induced disasters issued between 1949 and 2016. The researchers employed bibliometric analysis and Social Network Analysis (SNA) to process this data. Key techniques included:
- Co-word Analysis: Mapping policy priorities by identifying keywords that frequently appear together.
- Cluster Analysis: Grouping keywords into thematic subgroups to visualize the focus of different eras.
- Network Centrality Measures: Using degree and betweenness centrality to identify the most influential government departments and concepts within the policy network.
The Four Phases of Evolution
The analysis reveals that China's disaster policy history is divided into four distinct phases, marked by shifting priorities and a dramatic increase in policy output over time.
Phase I (1949–1978): The Agricultural Anchor
In the early decades of the People's Republic, disaster policy was almost entirely focused on protecting food production and "spring-time production." Disaster relief was often viewed through a political lens—summarized by the sentiment that "man can conquer nature"—and the management system was relatively simple and isolated. Keywords from this era emphasize agricultural cooperatives, flood prevention, and drought control.
Phase II (1979–2003): Economic Priority
Following the "Reform and Opening-up," disaster management began to serve the broader goal of economic stability. New keywords such as "industry," "national economic plan," and "transportation" emerged, reflecting a strategic shift toward protecting infrastructure and national assets to ensure uninterrupted economic growth.
Phase III (2004–2008): The Emergency Surge
Triggered by the 2003 SARS outbreak, China began building a systematic "Emergency Management System." This era saw a massive spike in policy volume, peaking in 2008—the year of the devastating Wenchuan Earthquake. During this peak, 660 disaster-related policies were issued in a single year, focusing on rapid response and professional capacity building.
Phase IV (2009–2016): Transition to Governance
In the final phase studied, the focus shifted toward "risk assessment," "prevention and mitigation," and "social participation." The interdepartmental network became highly dense, involving a wide array of specialized agencies beyond the traditional Ministry of Civil Affairs, including health, finance, and military sectors. This represents a transition toward a modern "disaster governance" model.
Drivers of Policy Change: The "Focusing Event" Theory
A key finding of the research is that policy change in China is rarely incremental. Instead, it is often driven by "focusing events"—major shocks like the SARS epidemic or the Wenchuan Earthquake. these events open a "window of opportunity" for structural reform, allowing the government to consolidate lessons learned into comprehensive new regulatory frameworks.
Conclusion
The evolution of China's disaster management reflects a broader shift from reactive relief to proactive risk management. While the system has become significantly more robust and integrated, the authors note that concepts like "disaster risk reduction" and "risk governance" are still emerging as central policy pillars. Future research should examine the impact of the 2018 government restructuring and bridge the gap between policy issuance and local-level implementation effectiveness.
Summary updated