Abstract
In the post-pandemic era, the street vendor economy has emerged as a vital means of alleviating employment pressure and stimulating market vitality, necessitating a scientific evaluation and optimization of its public governance policies. This study employs the PMC (Policy Modeling Consistency) Index Model to conduct a quantitative analysis of nine street vendor-related policies issued by national and local governments between 2020 and 2022. By integrating text mining and social network mapping methods, the paper constructs an evaluation system comprising ten primary variables and forty-two secondary variables. Based on the distribution of high-frequency terms, socio-semantic network diagrams, PMC index scores, and PMC surface plots, the study finds that the overall design of the street vendor policies is generally sound (with an average PMC index score of 7.28, and six policies rated as excellent). However, structural shortcomings persist, including short policy durations (78% are short-term), insufficient cross-departmental coordination (78% were issued by a single department), and incomplete coverage of target beneficiaries. Local policies outperform national ones in areas such as incentive mechanisms and content innovation, reflecting greater governance flexibility. Accordingly, the study recommends policy optimization from three perspectives: top-level design, implementation mechanisms, and collaborative governance.
Introduction
The "street vendor economy" has undergone a significant transformation in post-pandemic China, evolving from a perceived urban nuisance into a critical economic lifeline. Historically, urban management oscillated between total suppression and sudden liberalization, often employing "one-size-fits-all" approaches. As the economy seeks to recover, there is an urgent need for scientific, quantitative evaluation of governance policies to transition from reactive emergency measures to a standardized, sustainable model that balances urban order with economic survival.
Methodology
This study utilizes a multi-stage quantitative framework to evaluate nine representative policies issued between 2020 and 2022, sourced from national bodies like the State Council and local governments such as Qinghai and Hunan.
Text Mining and Semantic Analysis
Using ROSTCM6.0 software, the researchers performed word frequency analysis and social network mapping to identify core themes within the policy corpus. Key terms such as "employment," "protection," and "subsidies" emerged as central nodes, reflecting the primary focus of governance during this period.
The PMC Index Model
The core analytical tool is the Policy Modeling Consistency (PMC) Index Model. This model evaluates policy quality across 10 primary variables (X1: Policy Nature to X10: Policy Disclosure) and 42 secondary variables. Policies are scored based on a binary system across these parameters to calculate a final PMC Index, which categorizes policies as "Perfect," "Excellent," "Good," or "Poor."
Results and Discussion
The quantitative analysis revealed that the overall design of street vendor policies is generally sound, with an average PMC index score of 7.28.
Key Findings
- The "Local Advantage": Provincial-level policies (P5–P9) consistently outperformed national ones (P1–P4). Local governments demonstrated 14% to 49% higher scores in incentive mechanisms and content innovation, suggesting a greater ability to adapt to grassroots economic realities. Policy P8 (Qinghai Province) achieved the highest score of 8.41 due to its systematic design and strong operability.
- Institutional Silos: A significant 78% of policies were issued by a single department, leading to "policy fragmentation." Effective street vendor governance requires coordination across urban management, health, commerce, and social security.
- The Sustainability Gap: Most policies are short-term (1–3 years), focusing on immediate relief rather than long-term integration. The term "long-term mechanism" appeared only nine times across the entire corpus, highlighting a lack of structural planning.
- Transparency: All policies scored a perfect 1.0 in Policy Disclosure (X10), indicating high accessibility of regulations to the public.
Policy Optimization and Future Directions
To promote the normalization and sustainable development of the street vendor economy, the study proposes a "three-step" strategy:
- Short-term (1–3 years): Focus on relief and hardship alleviation for vulnerable groups.
- Mid-term (3–5 years): Promote standardized operations and categorized support.
- Long-term (5+ years): Deep integration with urban public services and digital governance.
Future governance should prioritize inter-departmental coordination, the establishment of "Smart Management Systems" for digital oversight, and the inclusion of social stakeholders—including industry associations and community volunteers—in the governance process.
Summary updated