Research on the Design of Digital Village Construction Indicator System from the Perspective of Policy Tools

Min Li, Xiaohui Li, Gang Li, Yiming LiuAtlantis 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The construction of digital countryside requires a proper understanding of its concept and scientific evaluation. The policies on digital countryside released in China are fragmented and have not been systematically sorted out. Taking Shandong Province as an example, a two-dimensional analysis framework based on the policy tool—the concept of digital countryside—was used to quantitatively analyze 14 policy samples using content analysis to study the government's policy system for digital countryside construction. From the conceptual layer of digital village, most of the current policies focus on the three aspects of digital life, digital governance and digital economy; and under the perspective of policy tools, the policy texts are more evenly distributed in the supply side, environment side and demand side. Four primary indicators and 15 secondary indicators were extracted from the research results to form the digital village construction assessment index system, which can identify the key tasks and shortcomings of digital village development, provide ideas for the next development of digital village, accelerate the pace of digital village development, and better realize rural revitalization.

Introduction

Digital countryside development is a cornerstone of rural modernization and a strategic priority for "Digital China." However, the current policy landscape is often fragmented, leaving local governments without a standardized methodology to measure progress or evaluate the effectiveness of various policy tools. Without a scientific evaluation index, identifying specific shortcomings in rural digitalization remains a challenge. This research aims to bridge the gap between high-level policy goals and ground-level implementation by creating a structured system that quantifies performance across infrastructure, governance, and the economy.

Methodology: A Two-Dimensional Analysis

The researchers employed a two-dimensional content analysis framework to evaluate 14 key policy documents (7 national and 7 from Shandong Province) released between 2018 and 2020.

  1. Policy Tool Dimension: Based on the Rothwell and Zegveld classification, policies were categorized into Supply-side (e.g., infrastructure, financial investment), Demand-side (e.g., government procurement, public services), and Environmental-side (e.g., tax incentives, legal controls).
  2. Conceptual Dimension: Policies were mapped against the four core pillars of the digital village: Digital Environment, Digital Life, Digital Economy, and Digital Governance.
The conceptual framework of the digital village environment and its impact on rural development pillars.

Key Insights: Infrastructure and the Innovation Gap

Analysis of the policy corpus reveals that China is currently in the "primary stage" of digital village construction. Within supply-side tools, infrastructure development (36.36%) and technical support (39.39%) dominate, reflecting a focus on laying the physical foundation—such as 4G/5G stations and broadband—before higher-level applications can flourish.

However, the data also reveals a significant "innovation gap." Very little policy weight is currently given to environmental tools like tax incentives (2.70%) or encouraging private-sector innovation (5.41%). This suggests a potential lack of long-term technical sustainability if market-driven motivation is not strengthened.

Analysis of demand-side and environmental policy tools, highlighting the distribution of keywords and percentages.

The Proposed Indicator System

The study culminated in a Digital Village Assessment Index System consisting of 4 primary indicators and 22 secondary indicators:

  • Infrastructure Development: Measures mobile broadband coverage, 4G base stations, and IoT penetration.
  • Digital Government: Tracks business training frequency, online legal systems, and transparency in village affairs.
  • Digital Agriculture: Quantifies production digitalization and the share of online retail for agricultural products.
  • Internet Technology Applications: Focuses on social security card coverage, broadband in rural schools, and medical device availability.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The authors emphasize that this system should be applied flexibly. Less developed areas should prioritize the "Digital Environment" (basic infrastructure), while economically advanced regions should focus on "Digital Services" and new business models like "Taobao Villages." As technology evolves, these indicators must be updated to reflect advancements in 5G, AI, and agricultural robotics to ensure continued relevance in the rural revitalization process.

Summary updated

Abstract

The construction of digital countryside requires a proper understanding of its concept and scientific evaluation.The policies on digital countryside released in China are fragmented and have not been systematically sorted out.Taking Shandong Province as an example, a two-dimensional analysis framework based on the policy tool -the concept of digital countryside -was used to quantitatively analyze 14 policy samples using content analysis to study the government's policy system for digital countryside construction.From the conceptual layer of digital village, most of the current policies focus on the three aspects of digital life, digital governance and digital economy; and under the perspective of policy tools, the policy texts are more evenly distributed in the supply side, environment side and demand side.Four primary indicators and 15 secondary indicators were extracted from the research results to form the digital village construction assessment index system, which can identify the key tasks and shortcomings of digital village development, provide ideas for the next development of digital village, accelerate the pace of digital village development, and better realize rural revitalization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022research,
  author = {Min Li and Xiaohui Li and Gang Li and Yiming Liu},
  title = {{Research on the Design of Digital Village Construction Indicator System from the Perspective of Policy Tools}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-016-9\_85},
}
Figure