Safety assessment of steel framework of a utility boiler

Bin Xu, Enpin Liu, Jingdong Wang, Liangsheng Chen2015 · DOI

Abstract

The structural integrity of utility boiler frameworks is critical for power plant safety, particularly when retrofitted with additional equipment like denitrification systems. This paper presents a safety evaluation of a 37-meter-tall steel framework using a combination of physical stiffness measurements and 3D finite element analysis (FEA). By incorporating seismic loads—often overlooked in simplified models—the study confirms that the modified structure remains within safe operating limits. Results indicate a maximum equivalent stress of 102.9 MPa and a maximum perpendicularity error of 33 mm, both of which satisfy industry safety standards for Q235 steel structures.

Structural Challenges in Boiler Retrofitting

Utility boilers are massive load-bearing structures. When these systems are modified to include new environmental controls, such as denitrification units, the original structural design must be re-validated. Adding new pillars and beams alters weight distribution and changes how the framework responds to external forces.

A significant limitation in many existing safety assessments is the reliance on simplified 2D models or the exclusion of seismic loads. For a structure of this scale, 3D modeling is essential to capture the complex interactions between components. This study addresses these gaps by performing a comprehensive "health check" that accounts for regional seismic risks and the three-dimensional nature of the framework.

Methodology: Physical and Digital Assessment

The assessment utilized a dual-track approach to evaluate both stiffness and strength:

Stiffness Assessment

The physical "stiffness" of the framework was assessed by measuring the perpendicularity of the six main pillars using total positioning systems. This process involved checking the vertical alignment at 12 specific points across the structure to determine if any significant tilting or leaning had occurred due to the added loads.

Measurement points for pillar perpendicularity assessment at various heights.

Strength Assessment via 3D FEA

A high-fidelity 3D Finite Element Analysis (FEA) model was developed to simulate the framework's response to operational and environmental stresses. The model integrated dead loads (2260t) and live loads (340t), while applying an aseismatic degree of 7 to simulate earthquake conditions. The simulation used the material properties of Q235 carbon structural steel, a standard in industrial construction.

Results and Safety Margins

The evaluation yielded positive results across all safety metrics:

  • Stiffness Results: The maximum measured perpendicularity error was 33 mm. This value falls within the acceptable tolerance range for boiler steel structures, indicating that the framework maintains its required rigidity.
  • Strength Results: The FEA simulation identified a maximum equivalent (Von Mises) stress of 102.9 MPa. Given that Q235 steel has a typical yield strength of 235 MPa, the structure operates with a substantial safety margin.
  • Deflection: The calculated maximum deflection was 9.6 mm, which is considered negligible for a 37-meter-tall structure.
FEA results showing the equivalent stress distribution and structural deformation under load.

Conclusion

The safety re-evaluation confirms that the utility boiler's steel framework is capable of supporting the new denitrification equipment while withstanding potential seismic events. The use of 3D FEA proved vital in capturing the stress distribution accurately. This case study underscores the importance of rigorous structural assessment during the green energy transition, ensuring that environmental retrofits do not compromise industrial safety.

Summary updated

Abstract

The steel framework of a utility boiler was an important structure sustained loads, and its strength and stiffness were primary factors in structural design. Stiffness was assessed by measuring perpendicularity of pillars. For this steel framewok seismic loads was significant to the entire strength. In order to refer to the influence of seismic loads, finite element method was adopted to analyze the strength of the whole steel framework. According to the results of finite element analysis, the maximum equivalent stress was 102.9MPa, which could satisfy the strength requirement. It indicated that this steel framework could satisfy the requirement of practical working conditions.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2015safety,
  author = {Bin Xu and Enpin Liu and Jingdong Wang and Liangsheng Chen},
  title = {{Safety assessment of steel framework of a utility boiler}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2991/icadme-15.2015.126},
}
Figure