A Finite Element Analysis-based Study on the Reliability of Heightened Quayside Container Cranes

Dazhi Huang, Xiaoqiang Guo, Haichao Wang, Hao Wang, Peng YangJournal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 2021 · DOI

Abstract

With the ever-increasing size of container ships, the lifting height of most in-service quayside container cranes (quay cranes) can no longer adapt to the new demands. In order to enable quay cranes to lift containers from 18,000 twenty-foot equivalent unit (TEU) ships, the world's ports are now developing crane heightening technology. This study employs finite element analysis (FEA) to analyze the structural reliability of heightened quay cranes. Using the 61t-55m Quay Crane Heightening Project at Lianyungang Port as a case study, eight operating conditions were identified. The static and dynamic characteristics were simulated using ANSYS, and stresses and deformations were compared across critical trolley positions. Results indicate that the maximum stresses remain below allowable limits and the structural vibration is stable, confirming the reliability of hydraulically heightened quay cranes.

Introduction

The global shipping industry is currently engaged in a "TEU arms race," with modern ultra-large container ships stacking containers higher than ever before. Older quayside cranes often lack the necessary reach for these vessels. Ports face a dilemma: replace functional cranes at a massive cost or find a way to "stretch" their existing fleet. Heightening a crane costs approximately 15% of the price of a new unit, saving roughly $1 million USD per unit. However, raising the upper structure by several meters alters the center of gravity and structural dynamics, necessitating rigorous safety verification through advanced simulation.

Methodology

The study focused on a 61t-55m quay crane at Lianyungang Port. The physical modification involved a fully automatic hydraulic jacking technique to raise the upper structure by 6 meters and insert new leg sections.

Structural layout of the heightened quay crane used in the FEA model.

To evaluate the structural integrity, a high-fidelity Finite Element Analysis (FEA) model was constructed in ANSYS using Beam188 elements for the main structure and linkage elements for the tie rods. The model comprised 9,580 elements. Researchers simulated eight critical operating conditions by varying the position of the trolley—the moving part that carries the container—from maximum outreach to maximum backreach.

Diagram of the trolley positions and operating conditions analyzed, including the back and raised positions.

Modal analysis was also performed using the Block Lanczos solver to determine the first 30 natural frequencies and mode shapes, ensuring the structure's dynamic stability and resistance to dangerous resonance during high-speed operations.

Results and Discussion

The analysis identified the seaside column and the outer front tie rods as the most critical stress points. Under full load conditions at maximum outreach, the maximum calculated stress was 224.76 MPa on the seaside column. This value is within the 230 MPa allowable stress limit for the Q345B steel used, maintaining a safety factor of 1.5.

The maximum structural displacement recorded was 362.74 mm at the front girder end during full outreach. While significant, this flex is considered acceptable for a structure of this scale. Modal frequencies ranged from 0.261 Hz to 3.555 Hz. The lowest frequency corresponds to a stable overall forward tilt, indicating that the door frame structure remains stable and the vibration characteristics are suitable for daily operation.

Conclusion

This study confirms that hydraulically heightening quayside cranes is a structurally sound and cost-effective solution for modernizing port infrastructure. The FEA results demonstrate that the 61t-55m crane at Lianyungang Port maintains its structural reliability after a 6-meter height increase, directly enabling it to handle two additional layers of containers. This approach provides a viable roadmap for port operators to meet the demands of 18,000+ TEU vessels. Future work will focus on incorporating environmental factors like wind loads and long-term fatigue analysis into the simulation models to further refine structural stability determinations.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the ever-increasing size of container ships, the lifting height of most in-service quayside container cranes (hereinafter referred to as quay cranes) can no longer adapt to the new demands. In order to enable quay cranes to lift containers from 18,000 twenty-foot equivalent unit (TEU) ships, the world's ports are now developing crane heightening technology. However, the structure of heightened quay cranes undergoes changes that affect their reliability. In this study, finite element analysis (FEA) was employed to analyze the structural reliability of heightened quay cranes. In the case of the 61t-55m Quay Crane Heightening Project at Lianyungang Port, eight operating conditions were identified using the FEA software ANSYS. The static and dynamic characteristics of the metal structure for the heightened quay crane were simulated and experimentally analyzed. The stresses and deformations at various observation points were compared when the trolley was in different critical positions. The stress and displacement nephograms of the quay crane metal structure under different operating conditions were derived, and the structural reliability of the hydraulically heightened quay cranes was verified. Results showed that the maximum stress of the sea side column is 224.76MPa, and the maximum stress of the road side column is 195.19MPa, both of which are less than the allowable stress, when the modal frequency is from 0.261Hz to 3.555Hz, the structural vibration is stable, the overall stiffness and stress of the quay crane metal structure meet the safety requirements. This study provides an important reference for the heightening modification and metal structure reliability assessment of quay cranes.
BibTeX
@article{huang2021finite,
  author = {Dazhi Huang and Xiaoqiang Guo and Haichao Wang and Hao Wang and Peng Yang},
  title = {{A Finite Element Analysis-based Study on the Reliability of Heightened Quayside Container Cranes}},
  journal = {Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.25103/jestr.146.08},
}
Figure