Multi-scale structural integrity assessment of a series of identical components in cultural-heritage structures: The case of the Clifton suspension bridge

Raffaele De Risi, T. W. Moody, Elia Voyagaki, Sam Gunner, Maria Pregnolato, Nicolò Grilli, Colin Anthony TaylorOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Cultural-heritage structures often feature structural elements that are geometrically identical for cosmetic or functional reasons but are subjected to significantly different stress distributions based on their location. This can lead to asynchronous damage and failure, complicating maintenance for grade-listed systems where interventions are costly and legally constrained. This research proposes a multi-scale approach to minimize maintenance costs while preserving historical value, combining material characterization, empirical mechanical testing, detailed geometric digitization, and numerical modeling. The framework is applied to the 162 cast-iron parapet stanchions of the Clifton Suspension Bridge in Bristol, UK, identifying the causes of cracking and providing essential insights for informed decision-making by the Clifton Suspension Bridge Trust (CSBT).

Introduction: The Repetitive Component Problem

Engineers managing cultural heritage structures frequently encounter the "repetitive component" problem. In the case of the Clifton Suspension Bridge, 162 geometrically identical parapet stanchions serve both functional and aesthetic roles. Despite their identical design, these components experience vastly different stress distributions from wind, pedestrian crowds, and temperature fluctuations depending on their position along the bridge.

Repetitive components in heritage structures (a) and the Clifton Suspension Bridge case study (b, c).

This variance leads to asynchronous failure, where identical parts break at different times. For a Grade-listed structure, maintenance is not only expensive but also legally restricted. To address this, researchers at the University of Bristol developed a multi-scale framework to move beyond generic literature values and understand the specific failure mechanisms of these 19th-century cast-iron components.

Methodology

The assessment framework utilized four primary pillars to reduce uncertainty and optimize maintenance:

  1. Material Characterization: Microscopy of decommissioned stanchions revealed a microstructure of graphite flakes in a pearlite/ferrite matrix. Density and porosity were measured using the "immersion in fluid" method.
  2. Mechanical Testing: A combination of non-destructive Leeb hardness tests and destructive tensile testing of 40 "dog-bone" specimens determined the actual breaking strength and Elastic Modulus of the 150-year-old iron.
  3. Geometric Digitization: High-fidelity point clouds were created using an Artec Eva 3D laser scanner, allowing for precise measurement of "re-entrant corners" where stresses concentrate.
  4. Multi-Fidelity Modeling: Three levels of Finite Element (FE) models were constructed, ranging from simplified beam elements to full 3D tetrahedral continuum elements for high-resolution stress analysis.
Cross-section of the bridge deck showing the structural role of the parapet stanchion.

Key Insights and Results

The multi-scale analysis provided several critical findings that challenge standard assumptions:

  • Material Classification: The bridge material was officially classified as Class 20 grey cast iron according to ASTM standards, correcting previous reliance on generic literature values.
  • The Porosity Culprit: Microscopy revealed that the "web" (middle section) of the stanchions has significantly higher porosity (~3%) compared to the flanges (~0.5%), making it more susceptible to crack initiation.
  • Stiffness Variance: Flanges were found to be 7% stiffer than the web, likely due to uneven cooling rates during the original 1864 casting process.
  • Geometric Stress Traps: 3D models confirmed that a triangular hole near the base—originally intended to save weight—creates stress concentrations that exceed the material's low ductility, leading to unrepairable cracks.
  • Validation: Level 3 tetrahedral models successfully predicted tensile stress concentrations exactly where the CSBT had historically observed field cracking.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study provides a scientific foundation for the Clifton Suspension Bridge Trust to transition from reactive maintenance to informed, predictive conservation. By quantifying the material properties and identifying geometric weaknesses, the trust can better manage the lifecycle of these historic components.

Future work will focus on dynamic loading environments, including fatigue testing to determine cycle limits before crack initiation and shaking table tests to evaluate vibration signatures for remote health monitoring. These steps will further refine the "residual life" estimates for components currently in service.

Summary updated

Abstract

Cultural-heritage structures may be characterised by structural elements that are geometrically identical for cosmetic or functional reasons but can be subjected to a significant variable stress distribution because they are located in different positions on the structural system. This can lead to a variety of damage and failure phenomena that will probably occur asynchronously. Damage occurrence triggers discussions among the stakeholders and decision-makers. For heritage structures, repair and restoration actions are costly and constrained by laws regulating grade-listed systems. Therefore, it becomes imperative to understand if such actions are necessary and to identify the most suitable intervention. The research question is: how can future maintenance costs be minimised while preserving the historical value of legacy structures? The answer lies in the reduction of uncertainties using a multi-scale approach that combines: (a) multi-scale knowledge of the material nature and fabrication, (b) multi-scale empirical evidence on material mechanical properties, (c) detailed geometrical description of the system, and (d) multi-scale numerical models. The challenge is finding the optimal trade-off between maintenance and historical value. Such a multi-scale framework is applied to the parapet stanchions of the Clifton Suspension Bridge in Bristol, UK. Stanchions are vertical cast-iron structural elements providing: (a) lateral support to parapets and anti-climb barriers and (b) partial support to the maintenance under-deck gantry. There are 162 identical parapet stanchions on the bridge. These structural elements may suffer heavy damage due to wear and tear. The damage consists of cracking in zones of stress concentration. This damage is unrepairable, and stanchions must be replaced when cracks appear. Their substitution is operated by the Clifton Suspension Bridge Trust (CSBT), which is particularly interested in science and technology for conservation and awareness. By applying the proposed multi-scale assessment framework, we provided essential insights into the structural integrity of such elements that are fundamental for informed decision-making.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{risi2023multi,
  author = {Raffaele De Risi and T. W. Moody and Elia Voyagaki and Sam Gunner and Maria Pregnolato and Nicolò Grilli and Colin Anthony Taylor},
  title = {{Multi-scale structural integrity assessment of a series of identical components in cultural-heritage structures: The case of the Clifton suspension bridge}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1201/9781003323020-466},
}
Figure