Quantum Magnetism in Wannier-Obstructed Mott Insulators

Xiaoyang Huang, Taige Wang, Shang Liu, Hong-Ye Hu, Yi‐Zhuang You

Abstract

We develop a strong coupling approach towards quantum magnetism in Mott insulators for Wannier obstructed bands. Despite the lack of Wannier orbitals, electrons can still singly occupy a set of exponentially-localized but nonorthogonal orbitals to minimize the repulsive interaction energy. We develop a systematic method to establish an effective spin model from the electron Hamiltonian using a diagrammatic approach. The nonorthogonality of the Mott basis gives rise to multiple new channels of spin-exchange (or permutation) interactions beyond Hartree-Fock and superexchange terms. We apply this approach to a Kagome lattice model of interacting electrons in Wannier obstructed bands (including both Chern bands and fragile topological bands). Due to the orbital nonorthogonality, as parameterized by the nearest neighbor orbital overlap $g$, this model exhibits stable ferromagnetism up to a finite bandwidth $W\sim U g$, where $U$ is the interaction strength. This provides an explanation for the experimentally observed robust ferromagnetism in Wannier obstructed bands. The effective spin model constructed through our approach also opens up the possibility for frustrated quantum magnetism around the ferromagnet-antiferromagnet crossover in Wannier obstructed bands.

Introduction: The Challenge of Wannier Obstruction

In conventional Mott insulators, electrons are localized on lattice sites due to strong repulsive interactions. To model the resulting magnetism, physicists typically employ Wannier orbitals—wavefunctions that are both exponentially localized and mutually orthogonal. However, in "topologically non-trivial" systems, such as Chern insulators or the fragile topological bands found in twisted bilayer graphene, a Wannier obstruction occurs. In these cases, it is mathematically impossible to construct orbitals that are simultaneously localized, symmetry-respecting, and orthogonal. This obstruction complicates the derivation of standard spin models (e.g., the Heisenberg model) used to predict magnetic ground states.

Methodology: Embracing Nonorthogonality

To overcome this hurdle, the researchers developed a framework that sacrifices orthogonality in favor of localization. By allowing orbitals to overlap slightly while remaining exponentially localized, they can accurately represent the low-energy physics of obstructed bands.

Mapping between the nonorthogonal low-energy space and the orthogonal spin space.

The core of this approach involves projecting the many-body electron Hamiltonian onto a nonorthogonal basis. This process maps the low-energy Hilbert space $\mathcal{H}$ (spanned by nonorthogonal states $|\Psi_\sigma\rangle$) to an effective spin space $\tilde{\mathcal{H}}$ (spanned by orthogonal states $|\sigma\rangle$). The mapping is mediated by operators $A$ and $A^\dagger$, and the nonorthogonality is tracked via a "Gram matrix" $G$. A systematic diagrammatic expansion then allows for the derivation of magnetic interactions based on the orbital overlap parameter $g$.

Application to the Kagome Lattice

The framework was tested on a Kagome lattice model designed to replicate the topological features of moiré materials. This model features three bands, including a flat middle band with a Wannier obstruction and two outer Chern bands.

Kagome lattice model and its topological band structure with Chern numbers.

As shown in Figure 2, the band structure exhibits non-zero Chern numbers ($C = \pm 1$), a hallmark of topological obstruction. By applying their nonorthogonal projection method to this system, the authors could analytically explore the magnetic phase diagram.

Key Insights and Results

The introduction of nonorthogonality reveals new interaction channels that are absent in standard orthogonal models. While magnetism is typically viewed as a competition between ferromagnetic "Fock" terms and antiferromagnetic "superexchange," the overlap $g$ introduces terms proportional to $tg$ (hopping times overlap).

Major findings include:

  • Robust Ferromagnetism: The study provides a rigorous explanation for the stability of ferromagnetism in obstructed bands. Ferromagnetism remains the ground state even with a finite bandwidth $W$, provided $W < Ug$. This aligns with experimental observations in moiré superlattices.
  • FM-AFM Crossover: The transition from ferromagnetism (FM) to antiferromagnetism (AFM) occurs when $t/U \sim g$. Because $g$ is generally small, ferromagnetism dominates a significant portion of the parameter space.
  • Exotic Magnetic Phases: Near the FM-AFM transition, the model predicts a "canted" 120° antiferromagnetic state. This non-coplanar state carries chiral spin properties, potentially serving as a precursor to quantum spin liquids.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This theoretical framework provides a powerful tool for understanding magnetism in topologically non-trivial materials. By moving beyond the requirement of orthogonal Wannier orbitals, the authors have opened a path to modeling complex moiré systems like twisted bilayer graphene more accurately. Future work will focus on applying these methods to specific experimental parameters to predict the precise magnetic orders and explore the potential for stabilizing Chiral Spin Liquids, which are of significant interest for topological quantum computing.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a strong coupling approach towards quantum magnetism in Mott insulators for Wannier obstructed bands. Despite the lack of Wannier orbitals, electrons can still singly occupy a set of exponentially-localized but nonorthogonal orbitals to minimize the repulsive interaction energy. We develop a systematic method to establish an effective spin model from the electron Hamiltonian using a diagrammatic approach. The nonorthogonality of the Mott basis gives rise to multiple new channels of spin-exchange (or permutation) interactions beyond Hartree-Fock and superexchange terms. We apply this approach to a Kagome lattice model of interacting electrons in Wannier obstructed bands (including both Chern bands and fragile topological bands). Due to the orbital nonorthogonality, as parameterized by the nearest neighbor orbital overlap $g$, this model exhibits stable ferromagnetism up to a finite bandwidth $W\sim U g$, where $U$ is the interaction strength. This provides an explanation for the experimentally observed robust ferromagnetism in Wannier obstructed bands. The effective spin model constructed through our approach also opens up the possibility for frustrated quantum magnetism around the ferromagnet-antiferromagnet crossover in Wannier obstructed bands.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2024quantum,
  author = {Xiaoyang Huang and Taige Wang and Shang Liu and Hong-Ye Hu and Yi‐Zhuang You},
  title = {{Quantum Magnetism in Wannier-Obstructed Mott Insulators}},
  booktitle = {Crystals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/cryst14020176},
}

Loading related content...

Figure