Quantum Magnetism in Wannier-Obstructed Mott Insulators

Xiaoyang Huang, Taige Wang, Shang Liu, Hong-Ye Hu, Yi‐Zhuang You

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel theoretical framework to understand quantum magnetism in "Wannier-obstructed" Mott insulators, materials where standard localized electron orbitals cannot be constructed due to symmetry constraints. By developing a method that accounts for nonorthogonal localized orbitals, the authors reveal new mechanisms for magnetic interactions, explaining observed ferromagnetism and opening doors to understanding complex magnetic phases.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In condensed matter physics, Mott insulators are materials where strong electron-electron repulsion prevents electrons from moving freely, leading to insulating behavior. Typically, these materials exhibit magnetic ordering due to "superexchange" interactions between localized electron spins. However, recent experiments on materials like twisted bilayer graphene have revealed ferromagnetic behavior in Mott insulating states, which is challenging to explain with conventional theories. A key obstacle is the concept of "Wannier obstruction," which arises when the relevant electronic bands in a material cannot be described by standard, symmetric, and orthogonal localized orbitals (Wannier orbitals). This obstruction makes it difficult to derive effective models for magnetism, especially when the interaction strength is comparable to or larger than the bandwidth (strong coupling regime). This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a method to model magnetism in these "Wannier-obstructed" systems.

Methods

The authors propose a "strong coupling approach" that tackles the Wannier obstruction by sacrificing the orthogonality of localized orbitals. Instead, they consider a set of nonorthogonal exponentially localized orbitals that minimize the system's energy. This is achieved by numerically optimizing these orbitals using a Gross-Pitaevskii equation derived from the Hartree energy.

Once these nonorthogonal orbitals are established, the many-body Hamiltonian is projected onto a low-energy subspace spanned by these orbitals. This projection, combined with a diagrammatic approach, allows them to derive an effective spin model. A key finding is that the nonorthogonality of the orbitals introduces new "spin-exchange" or "permutation" interaction channels beyond the standard Hartree-Fock and superexchange terms. These new channels are crucial for understanding the observed magnetic phenomena. The paper also employs a generalized perturbation theory to account for effects beyond the strict flat-band limit.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical modeling and applies the framework to a toy model of interacting electrons on a Kagome lattice.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Orthogonality: The core insight is that sacrificing orbital orthogonality, while maintaining localization, is key to understanding magnetism in Wannier-obstructed systems.
  • New Magnetic Channels: Nonorthogonal orbitals give rise to novel spin interaction terms (beyond superexchange) that can favor ferromagnetism or lead to complex magnetic phases.
  • Explaining Ferromagnetism: The framework provides a mechanism for stable ferromagnetism up to a finite bandwidth, explaining experimental observations in materials like twisted bilayer graphene.
  • Orbital Symmetry Breaking: The choice of localized orbitals can spontaneously break lattice symmetries, leading to phenomena like nematic phases.
  • Kagome Lattice as a Testbed: The Kagome lattice model serves as a valuable platform to demonstrate the theory, revealing rich phase diagrams with competing magnetic interactions.

Key Results

  • The developed approach successfully derives an effective spin model for Wannier-obstructed Mott insulators.
  • The model predicts stable ferromagnetism up to a bandwidth $W \sim Ug$, where $U$ is the interaction strength and $g$ is the orbital overlap parameter. This explains the robustness of ferromagnetism observed in experiments.
  • The study of a Kagome lattice model reveals a complex phase diagram with ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and canted phases, influenced by the interplay of different interaction channels arising from orbital nonorthogonality.
  • The theory highlights the importance of orbital symmetry and its breaking in determining the magnetic properties of these materials.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximations: The theory relies on approximations, particularly in the diagrammatic expansion and perturbation theory. The convergence of the series for the effective Hamiltonian is discussed, with numerical evidence suggesting the dominance of leading terms.
  • Specific Models: While the framework is general, the detailed phase diagrams are derived for specific models (Kagome lattice with different interaction types). Extending this to more complex material structures is a future direction.
  • Weak Coupling Regime: The current work focuses on the strong coupling regime ($W \ll U$). Understanding the transition to the weak coupling regime and the Fermi liquid phase requires further investigation.
  • Experimental Verification: While the theory explains experimental observations, direct experimental verification of the predicted new interaction channels would be valuable.
  • Richer Magnetic Phases: The authors suggest that their framework can be extended to explore more exotic magnetic phases, such as chiral spin liquids and Dirac spin liquids, which might arise from the complex interplay of interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a strong coupling approach towards quantum magnetism in Mott insulators for Wannier-obstructed bands. Despite the lack of Wannier orbitals, electrons can still singly occupy a set of exponentially localized but nonorthogonal orbitals to minimize the repulsive interaction energy. We develop a systematic method to establish an effective spin model from the electron Hamiltonian using a diagrammatic approach. The nonorthogonality of the Mott basis gives rise to multiple new channels of spin-exchange (or permutation) interactions beyond Hartree–Fock and superexchange terms. We apply this approach to a Kagome lattice model of interacting electrons in Wannier-obstructed bands (including both Chern bands and fragile topological bands). Due to the orbital nonorthogonality, as parameterized by the nearest-neighbor orbital overlap g, this model exhibits stable ferromagnetism up to a finite bandwidth W∼Ug, where U is the interaction strength. This provides an explanation for the experimentally observed robust ferromagnetism in Wannier-obstructed bands. The effective spin model constructed through our approach also opens up the possibility for frustrated quantum magnetism around the ferromagnet-antiferromagnet crossover in Wannier-obstructed bands.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2024quantum,
  author = {Xiaoyang Huang and Taige Wang and Shang Liu and Hong-Ye Hu and Yi‐Zhuang You},
  title = {{Quantum Magnetism in Wannier-Obstructed Mott Insulators}},
  booktitle = {Crystals},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/cryst14020176},
}

Loading related content...

Figure