On radiant matter

William CrookesJournal of the Franklin Institute 1879 · DOI

This 1879 lecture by William Crookes is a foundational text in the history of physics, marking the transition from classical thermodynamics to the dawn of atomic science. In it, Crookes explores the behavior of matter in high-vacuum environments, proposing the existence of a "Fourth State of Matter"—what he calls Radiant Matter.

TL;DR

Crookes demonstrates that when gas is highly rarefied, it ceases to behave like a fluid and instead acts as a stream of individual particles ("Radiant Matter") projected from the negative electrode. He proves these rays travel in straight lines, exert mechanical pressure, generate intense heat, and are deflected by magnets, effectively discovering cathode rays (electrons) decades before they were fully understood.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the late 19th century, the behavior of electricity in vacuum tubes was a mystery. While scientists were familiar with the "cloudy luminosity" of low-vacuum discharges, Crookes wanted to understand what happened when the vacuum was pushed to the extreme—specifically, when the "mean free path" of a molecule (the distance it travels before hitting another) becomes comparable to the size of the tube itself.

At this point, the gas no longer acts as a continuous medium. Crookes sought to prove that this state was fundamentally different from solids, liquids, or gases, representing a "Border Land" where matter and force seem to merge.

Methods

Crookes utilized "Crookes tubes"—glass vessels exhausted to roughly one-millionth of an atmosphere. He used an induction coil to create high-voltage discharges and observed the resulting phenomena.

Key experimental setups included:

  • Dark Space Analysis: Measuring the "dark space" around the negative pole (cathode), which he correctly identified as a visual representation of the molecules' mean free path.
  • Phosphorescence Testing: Placing various minerals (diamonds, rubies) and different types of glass in the path of the discharge to observe their luminous response.
  • Mechanical and Thermal Probes: Using internal paddle wheels to detect momentum and iridio-platinum plates to measure the heat generated by the "molecular bombardment."
  • Magnetic Deflection: Using horseshoe magnets to observe how the trajectory of the radiant stream changed.

Datasets

Not applicable. This is a 19th-century experimental physics paper; results are presented through qualitative observations and specific physical measurements described in the text.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Fourth State of Matter: Crookes argues that Radiant Matter is as different from gas as gas is from liquid. In this state, molecules are allowed to obey their own laws without the constant interference of collisions.
  • Straight-Line Propagation: Unlike the diffuse glow of a standard vacuum tube, Radiant Matter "absolutely refuses to turn a corner." It is projected normally (perpendicularly) from the surface of the cathode.
  • Molecular Bombardment: The luminosity seen on the glass is not the "electricity" itself, but the result of the glass being "hammered" by particles. This is beautifully illustrated in his comparison of low-vacuum vs. high-vacuum bulbs.
Figure 5: Comparing the path of discharge in a moderate vacuum (A) where it follows the shortest path, vs. a high vacuum (B) where it is projected in a straight line regardless of the positive pole's position.
  • Negative Electrification: By showing that two parallel streams of Radiant Matter repel each other, Crookes concluded they are composed of similarly electrified (negative) particles.

Key Results

  • Phosphorescence: Crookes discovered that Radiant Matter causes brilliant luminescence. Rubies glow with a "rich red tone," and diamonds shine "with as much light as a candle."
Figure 2: Three bulbs of different glass (uranium, English, and German) phosphorescing under molecular discharge.
Figure 3: A diamond mounted in a bulb, phosphorescing a bright green when bombarded.
  • Shadow Casting: He demonstrated that Radiant Matter casts sharp shadows of solid objects (like an aluminum cross), proving it travels in straight lines.
  • Mechanical Force: He successfully used the "molecular stream" to drive a small paddle wheel along a glass railway, proving the particles carry significant momentum.
  • Thermal Energy: By focusing the rays with a cup-shaped cathode, he was able to melt iridio-platinum, one of the most heat-resistant metals known at the time.
  • Magnetic Sensitivity: He showed that a magnet could "bend" the stream of matter, much like gravity bends the trajectory of a bullet.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation, viewed through a modern lens, is that Crookes believed Radiant Matter consisted of molecules or "atoms" of the residual gas. We now know these are actually electrons—subatomic particles much smaller than atoms.

Crookes himself acknowledged the "Chemistry of Radiant Matter" was difficult to distinguish, as the physical properties seemed identical regardless of the gas used. He concluded by speculating that this "Border Land" held the key to "Ultimate Realities," a prediction that was vindicated by the subsequent discovery of X-rays and the electron in the decades that followed.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{crookes1879radiant,
  author = {William Crookes},
  title = {{On radiant matter}},
  journal = {Journal of the Franklin Institute},
  year = {1879},
  doi = {10.1016/0016-0032(79)90319-3},
}
On the illumination of lines of molecular pressure, and the trajectory of moleculesAmerican Journal of Science · 1879
Bakerian Lecture: Nuclear constitution of atomsProceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character · 1920
Eine Kern-γ-Strahlung bei leichten ElementenThe Science of Nature · 1930
Ueber eine neue Art elektrischer StrömeAnnalen der Physik · 1860
On the relative motion of the Earth and the luminiferous etherAmerican Journal of Science · 1887
Experiments and observations on electricity
Figure