On the illumination of lines of molecular pressure, and the trajectory of molecules

W. CrookesAmerican Journal of Science 1879 · DOI

This classic 1879 paper by William Crookes represents a foundational moment in the history of physics. It documents the transition from studying bulk gases to discovering the behavior of individual particles in a vacuum—work that eventually led to the discovery of the electron and the development of television tubes and X-rays.

TL;DR

William Crookes demonstrates that in high-vacuum tubes, the "dark space" around a negative electrode is actually a region where molecules travel long distances without colliding. By showing these "molecular rays" travel in straight lines, exert mechanical force, and deflect in magnetic fields, he proposes a "fourth state of matter" where the kinetic theory of gases reaches its extreme limit.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the late 19th century, physicists were fascinated by the glow produced when electricity passed through rarefied gases in glass tubes. A persistent mystery was the "dark space" that appeared around the negative pole (cathode) as the vacuum improved.

Crookes sought to understand the physical nature of this dark space. Was it a void, or was it a region of intense activity? He aimed to bridge the gap between the Kinetic Theory of Gases (which describes how molecules bounce off each other) and the observed phenomena of electrical discharge, eventually arguing that the dark space is a "molecular graveyard" where the usual rules of gaseous collisions no longer apply.

Methods

Crookes employed a series of ingenious experimental vacuum tubes, pushing the limits of 19th-century exhaustion technology (reaching pressures as low as 0.06 millionths of an atmosphere). Key techniques included:

  • The Electrical Radiometer: A modification of his famous light-mill, where the vanes acted as the negative pole. This allowed him to measure the mechanical "kick" or pressure exerted by the discharge.
  • Shadow Casting: Placing obstacles (like mica or aluminium plates) in the path of the discharge to see if the resulting phosphorescence on the glass tube showed sharp shadows.
  • Magnetic Deflection: Using electromagnets and permanent magnets to observe how the trajectory of the "molecular stream" bent in response to magnetic force.
  • Thermal Focusing: Using concave (cup-shaped) aluminium poles to focus the rays onto a single point, testing if the concentrated impact could generate enough heat to melt metal.
  • Phosphorescent Indicators: Using different types of glass (like uranium glass) to visualize where the invisible rays struck the vessel walls.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. As a 19th-century experimental physics paper, it relies on qualitative observations and specific point-measurements of pressure (in millims or millionths of an atmosphere) rather than large-scale datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Dark Space as Mean Free Path: Crookes realized the thickness of the dark space is a physical manifestation of the "mean free path"—the average distance a molecule travels before hitting another. As the gas becomes thinner, this distance grows until it hits the glass walls.
  • Normal Projection: Unlike light from a candle, which radiates in all directions, these "molecular rays" are projected in a direction normal (perpendicular) to the surface of the electrode. This allowed him to focus them using curved electrodes, much like a lens focuses light.
  • The Fourth State of Matter: Crookes proposed that at extreme vacuums, matter enters an "ultra-gaseous state." In this state, the "hits" (collisions) are so few compared to the "misses" that molecules obey their own individual laws of motion rather than the statistical laws of a bulk gas.
  • Mechanical Momentum: He proved these rays aren't just light; they have mass and velocity. He demonstrated this by making a small "fly" (a paddle wheel) rotate rapidly when hit by the rays.
  • Magnetic Sensitivity: He discovered that these rays follow a spiral path when influenced by a magnet, behaving like a flexible conductor carrying a current.

Key Results

  • Straight-Line Propagation: Crookes proved the rays do not "turn corners." He showed that an object in the path of the rays casts a perfectly sharp "molecular shadow" on the glass.
  • Thermal Energy: By focusing the rays from a hemispherical cathode onto a strip of platinum foil, he was able to heat the metal to its melting point, proving the immense kinetic energy of the particles.
  • Phosphorescence: He observed that the rays cause the glass of the tube to glow with a color characteristic of the glass itself (e.g., greenish-yellow for German glass), independent of the gas inside the tube.
  • Pressure Thresholds: He quantified the limits of conductivity, noting that at 0.06 M (millionths of an atmosphere), the vacuum becomes almost non-conductive, as there are too few molecules left to carry the discharge.

Limitations and Future Work

  • The Nature of the "Molecule": Crookes believed he was seeing actual molecules of gas being electrified and repelled. We now know he was actually observing electrons (cathode rays). His "fourth state of matter" was a precursor to what we now call plasma.
  • Observational Limits: Crookes noted that he could only observe the rays when they struck a phosphor or a mechanical indicator; the "invisible lines of force" in the vacuum remained a subject of theoretical speculation.
  • Glass Composition: He acknowledged that the specific colors observed were a property of the "soft German glass" used in his tubes, suggesting that further research into different materials was needed to understand the phosphorescence fully.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{crookes1879illumination,
  author = {W. Crookes},
  title = {{On the illumination of lines of molecular pressure, and the trajectory of molecules}},
  journal = {American Journal of Science},
  year = {1879},
  doi = {10.2475/ajs.s3-17.99.218},
}
Figure