TL;DR
In this landmark 1887 paper, Michelson and Morley attempted to detect the "ether wind"—the relative motion of the Earth through the medium supposedly required for light to travel. Using a high-precision interferometer floating on mercury, they found essentially no motion, a "null result" that fundamentally challenged classical physics and set the stage for Einstein’s theory of Special Relativity.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In the late 19th century, physicists believed light was a wave that required a medium to propagate, much like sound requires air. This hypothetical medium was called the "luminiferous ether." If the ether filled all of space and remained stationary, the Earth’s orbital motion (at ~30 km/s) should create an "ether wind."
The challenge was that the expected effect on the speed of light was incredibly small—a second-order effect proportional to $(v/V)^2$, where $v$ is the Earth's velocity and $V$ is the speed of light. Previous attempts to measure this were plagued by experimental noise and insufficient sensitivity. Michelson and Morley sought to build an apparatus stable and sensitive enough to finally confirm or refute the ether's existence.
Methods
The authors employed a technique now known as Michelson Interferometry. A single beam of light is split into two perpendicular paths (arms), reflected back by mirrors, and recombined. If one path takes slightly longer than the other (due to the ether wind), the light waves will be out of phase, creating a visible pattern of interference fringes.
Key innovations in this setup included:
- Path Length Extension: By using multiple reflections between mirrors at each corner of the apparatus, they increased the effective path length to about 11 meters, roughly ten times longer than Michelson's earlier 1881 attempt.
- Vibration Isolation: To solve the "extreme sensitiveness to vibration" that ruined previous experiments, they mounted the entire optical system on a massive square stone block ($1.5$ meters wide, $0.3$ meters thick).
- Mercury Flotation: The stone block was floated in an annular trough of mercury (see Figure 3). This allowed the researchers to rotate the entire apparatus smoothly and continuously, looking for fringe shifts as the orientation relative to the Earth's orbital motion changed.
Datasets
While not a "dataset" in the modern computational sense, the authors meticulously recorded fringe positions at 16 equidistant points during the rotation of the stone. They conducted two main sets of observations in July 1887:
- Noon Observations: Conducted when the Earth's orbital motion was oriented a certain way relative to the lab.
- P.M. Observations: Conducted near 6:00 PM to provide a different orientation.
The raw data, consisting of micrometer readings of the interference fringes, is summarized in their results table (see Figure 6).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Theoretical Correction: The authors acknowledge a crucial correction by H.A. Lorentz. Earlier calculations had overlooked that the Earth's motion also affects the light path perpendicular to the motion. This oversight meant the expected fringe shift was actually only half of what was originally calculated.
- The Null Result: This is the most famous "failed" experiment in history. Despite having an apparatus sensitive enough to detect a shift of $0.4$ fringes, the observed displacement was almost non-existent.
- Refuting Fresnel: The results were "quite small enough entirely to refute Fresnel’s explanation of aberration," which relied on a stationary ether.
Key Results
The quantitative findings were stark. Based on the Earth's orbital velocity, the theory predicted a fringe displacement of 0.4. However, the actual observed displacement was less than 0.01.
As shown in Figure 5, the solid lines (actual data) are nearly flat compared to the dotted lines, which represent only one-eighth of the theoretically predicted displacement. The authors concluded that if there is any relative motion between the Earth and the ether, it must be less than one-fourth (and likely less than one-sixth) of the Earth's orbital velocity.
Limitations and Future Work
- Solar System Motion: The authors noted that the Earth's orbital motion might coincidentally be canceled out by the motion of the entire solar system through space. They proposed repeating the experiment every three months to account for the Earth's changing direction in its orbit.
- Ether Drag at Altitude: They speculated that the ether might be "dragged" along by the Earth's surface, masking the wind. They suggested that repeating the experiment at high altitudes, such as a mountain peak, might yield different results.
- Alternative Methods: The supplement discusses a new potential method for measuring the "first power" of relative velocity using revolving mirrors and selenium cells, though they admitted the mechanical difficulties were significant.
Summary updated