Bakerian Lecture: Nuclear constitution of atoms

Ernest RutherfordProceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character 1920 · DOI

TL;DR

In this landmark 1920 Bakerian Lecture, Sir Ernest Rutherford provides the first definitive evidence for the artificial disintegration of an atom. By bombarding nitrogen with alpha particles, he demonstrates the release of hydrogen nuclei and a new mass-3 isotope of helium, laying the conceptual foundation for nuclear physics and famously predicting the existence of the neutron.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

By 1920, the "Rutherford model" of the atom—a tiny, massive, positively charged nucleus surrounded by electrons—was well-established. However, the internal structure of the nucleus itself remained a "black box."

Rutherford sought to move beyond simply measuring nuclear charge to understanding nuclear constitution. The central challenge was how to probe a structure held together by immense forces. Rutherford’s solution was to use high-velocity alpha particles (helium nuclei) as subatomic projectiles to strike light atoms (like nitrogen and oxygen) with enough force to potentially disrupt their internal equilibrium and see what "building blocks" might be knocked loose.

Methods

Rutherford employed a combination of classic scattering experiments and sophisticated magnetic deflection analysis:

  • Alpha Bombardment: Using Radium C as a source, he fired swift alpha particles through various gases (nitrogen, oxygen, and hydrogen-carbon dioxide mixtures) and solid nitrogen compounds (like boron nitride).
  • Scintillation Counting: Particles resulting from these collisions were detected by the tiny flashes of light (scintillations) they produced on a zinc sulphide screen.
  • Magnetic Deflection: To identify the unknown particles, Rutherford built a specialized apparatus (see Figure 1) that used a powerful electromagnet to bend the path of the particles. By comparing the deflection of unknown particles from nitrogen to the deflection of known hydrogen atoms, he could calculate their mass-to-charge ($m/e$) ratio.
The experimental setup for measuring magnetic deflection of particles.
  • Comparative Gas Mixtures: To ensure accuracy, he created a mixture of hydrogen and carbon dioxide with the same "stopping power" for alpha rays as air, allowing for a direct "apples-to-apples" comparison of hydrogen recoil atoms versus nitrogen disintegration products.

Datasets

As a foundational physics paper, it does not use modern digital datasets. Instead, the "data" consists of:

  • Calculated Ranges: Theoretical ranges for particles of different masses (1 through 4) set in motion by alpha collisions (see Figure 2/3).
  • Scintillation Ratios: The ratio of counts observed when the magnetic field was reversed (+ vs -), which served as a proxy for the degree of deflection.
  • Experimental Benchmarks: Measurements of alpha particles from Thorium C (range 8.6 cm) used to calibrate the magnetic field.
Calculated ranges for particles of different masses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Artificial Transmutation: Rutherford proved that the nitrogen nucleus could be disintegrated. When struck by an alpha particle, it expels a hydrogen nucleus. This was the first time one element was shown to be changed into another by human intervention.
  • The Mass-3 Building Block: Rutherford identified a second type of particle ejected from both nitrogen and oxygen. Through magnetic analysis, he determined it had a mass of 3 and a charge of 2—what we now know as the isotope Helium-3.
  • The "Neutral Doublet" (The Neutron): In a brilliant theoretical leap (page 396), Rutherford speculated that an electron could combine very closely with a hydrogen nucleus to form a neutral particle. He predicted this particle would have "novel properties," such as the ability to move freely through matter, and would be essential for building up heavy nuclei. This is the first formal prediction of the neutron, discovered 12 years later by his colleague James Chadwick.
  • Isotopes Explained: He argued that the properties of an atom are defined by its nuclear charge (atomic number) rather than its mass, providing a rational explanation for why isotopes of the same element exist.

Key Results

  • Identity of Nitrogen Products: The long-range particles from nitrogen were confirmed to be hydrogen nuclei (protons) with a range of approximately 28 cm in air.
  • Discovery of $X_3$: A shorter-range particle (9 cm) was found in both oxygen and nitrogen, identified as an atom of mass 3 with two positive charges.
  • Nuclear Dimensions: By observing where the inverse square law of electric force begins to fail, Rutherford estimated the radius of the nucleus to be on the order of $3 \times 10^{-13}$ cm.
  • Precision of Atomic Number: Citing Chadwick’s recent work, he noted that the nuclear charge is identical to the atomic number within an experimental accuracy of 1%.

Limitations and Future Work

Rutherford acknowledged several hurdles:

  • Observational Strain: Counting scintillations by eye is exhausting and prone to subjective error, especially for weak flashes.
  • Contamination: Ensuring solid samples were free of hydrogen (which would produce "natural" recoil atoms and mask the disintegration results) was extremely difficult.
  • Projectile Energy: He noted that "swifter" alpha particles than those currently available would be needed to probe the even more stable nuclei of heavier elements.
  • Visualizing the Event: He expressed hope that C.T.R. Wilson’s cloud chamber method could eventually be used to photograph these rare nuclear collisions to better understand the energy exchange involved.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction.—The conception of the nuclear constitution of atoms arose initially from attempts to account for the scattering of α-particles through large angles in traversing thin sheets of matter. Taking into account the large mass and velocity of the α-particles, these large deflexions were very remarkable, and indicated that very intense electric or magnetic fields exist within the atom. To account for these results, it was found necessary to assume that the atom consists of a charged massive nucleus of dimensions very small compared with the ordinarily accepted magnitude of the diameter of the atom. This positively charged nucleus contains most of the mass of the atom, and is surrounded at a distance by a distribution of negative electrons equal in number to the resultant positive charge on the nucleus. Under these conditions, a very intense electric field exists close to the nucleus, and the large deflexion of the α-particle in an encounter with a single atom happens when the particle passes close to the nucleus. Assuming that the electric forces between the α-particle and the nucleus varied according to an inverse square law in the region close to the nucleus, the writer worked out the relations connecting the number of α-particles scattered through any angle with the charge on the nucleus and the energy of the α-particle. Under the central field of force, the α-particle describes a hyperbolic orbit round the nucleus, and the magnitude of the deflection depends on the closeness of approach to the nucleus. From the data of scattering of α-particles then available, it was deduced that the resultant charge on the nucleus was about ½ Ae, where A is the atomic weight and e the fundamental unit of charge. Geiger and Marsden made an elaborate series of experiments to test the correctness of the theory, and confirmed the main conclusions. They found the nucleus charge was about ½ Ae, but, from the nature of the experiments, it was difficult to fix the actual value within about 20 per cent. C. G. Darwin worked out completely the deflexion of the α-particle and of the nucleus, taking into account the mass of the latter, and showed that the scattering experiments of Geiger and Marsden could not be reconciled with any law of central force, except the inverse square. The nuclear constitution of the atom was thus very strongly supported by the experiments on scattering of α-rays. Since the atom is electrically neutral, the number of external electrons surrounding the nucleus must be equal to the number of units of resultant charge on the nucleus. It should be noted that, from the consideration of the scattering of X-rays by light elements, Barkla had shown, in 1911, that the number of electrons was equal to about half the atomic weight. This was deduced from the theory of scattering of Sir J. J. Thomson, in which it was assumed that each of the external electrons in an atom acted as an independent scattering unit.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rutherford1920bakerian,
  author = {Ernest Rutherford},
  title = {{Bakerian Lecture: Nuclear constitution of atoms}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character},
  year = {1920},
  doi = {10.1098/rspa.1920.0040},
}
Figure