On Flavourful Easter eggs for New Physics hunger and Lepton Flavour Universality violation

M. Ciuchini, Antônio Coutinho, Marco Fedele, E. Franco, Ayan Paul, L. Silvestrini, Mauro Valli

Abstract

Within the standard approach of effective field theory of weak interactions for $ΔB = 1$ transitions, we look for possibly unexpected subtle New Physics effects, here dubbed "flavourful Easter eggs". We perform a Bayesian global fit using the publicly available HEPfit package, taking into account state-of-the-art experimental information concerning these processes, including the suggestive measurements from LHCb of $R_{K}$ and $R_{K^{*}}$. We parametrize New Physics contributions to $b \to s$ transitions in terms of shifts of Wilson coefficients of the electromagnetic dipole and semi-leptonic operators, assuming CP-conserving effects, but allowing in general for violation of lepton flavour universality. We show how optimistic/conservative hadronic estimates can impact quantitatively the size of New Physics extracted from the fit. With a conservative approach to hadronic uncertainties we find nonzero New Physics contributions to Wilson coefficients at the level of $\sim 3σ$, depending on the model chosen.

Introduction

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics dictates Lepton Flavour Universality (LFU), implying that electrons and muons should behave identically in electroweak interactions. However, persistent anomalies in rare $B$ meson decays ($b \to s \ell \ell$ transitions) observed at LHCb, Belle, and other experiments have challenged this principle. Specifically, ratios such as $R_K$ and $R_{K^*}$ suggest a deficit in muon production relative to electrons, hinting at potential New Physics (NP). The challenge lies in disentangling these potential signals from complex "hadronic uncertainties"—non-factorizable QCD power corrections that can mimic NP effects.

Methodology: EFT and Global Fits

The study employs an Effective Field Theory (EFT) framework, where NP effects are modeled as shifts in Wilson coefficients ($C_7, C_9, C_{10}$). These coefficients represent the strength of magnetic dipole, vector, and axial-vector interactions, respectively. Using the HEPfit package, the authors perform a Bayesian global fit to a comprehensive dataset including LHCb angular observables ($P_5'$), radiative decays ($B \to X_s \gamma$), and rare leptonic decays ($B_s \to \mu \mu$).

A critical aspect of this analysis is the comparison of two paradigms for treating hadronic uncertainties:

  1. Phenomenological Model Driven (PMD): An optimistic approach relying on specific theoretical models for QCD corrections.
  2. Phenomenological and Data Driven (PDD): A conservative approach where hadronic parameters are constrained by experimental data itself, making fewer theoretical assumptions.

The Impact of Hadronic Uncertainties

The choice of hadronic model significantly alters the perceived significance of NP. In the optimistic PMD model, the evidence for NP can exceed $5\sigma$, reaching discovery-level significance. However, under the more rigorous PDD approach, this significance drops to approximately $3\sigma$.

Comparison of PMD (green) and PDD (red) approaches for muonic New Physics coefficients in Scenario (II). The PDD approach shows broader distributions and a shift in the preferred parameter space, reflecting more conservative hadronic assumptions.

As shown in Figure 1, the PDD approach (red) leads to larger uncertainties and a different correlation between $C_{9,\mu}^{NP}$ and $C_{10,\mu}^{NP}$ compared to the PMD approach (green). This underscores that the "hunger" for NP must be balanced against a careful treatment of QCD effects, as the hadronic "elephant in the room" can significantly shift the interpretation of experimental data.

Exploring Electronic New Physics

While most research focuses on muonic NP, this study also investigates the possibility of NP in electronic channels. Scenario (I) explores independent shifts in $C_{9,\mu}$ and $C_{9,e}$.

Bayesian posterior distributions for Scenario (I), comparing muonic ($C_{9,\mu}^{NP}$) and electronic ($C_{9,e}^{NP}$) contributions under PMD (green) and PDD (red) frameworks.

The results indicate that the data does not strictly rule out NP in the electronic sector. In fact, the fit allows for a scenario where the observed LFU violation stems from non-standard electronic interactions, a hypothesis that is less commonly explored but remains statistically viable under current experimental constraints.

Key Results and Future Outlook

The global fit identifies scenarios involving both $C_9$ and $C_{10}$ (Scenario VI) or specific correlations (Scenario V) as providing the best fit to current data, as measured by the Information Criterion (IC). Notably, if one adopts a conservative stance on hadronic effects, NP in the axial-vector current ($C_{10}$) becomes as viable as the more commonly discussed vector current ($C_9$) modifications. This shift in perspective is crucial, as it opens up different theoretical interpretations for the underlying physics beyond the Standard Model.

To distinguish between these "Easter eggs," the authors propose measuring "transverse ratios" ($R_K^{T}$, $R_\phi^{T}$) in future experiments. These observables are designed to be cleaner and more sensitive to specific NP structures. Definitive confirmation of these anomalies will require more data from LHCb Run 2 and Belle II, alongside improved first-principles calculations of hadronic power corrections to reduce reliance on data-driven estimates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Within the standard approach of effective field theory of weak interactions for $ΔB = 1$ transitions, we look for possibly unexpected subtle New Physics effects, here dubbed "flavourful Easter eggs". We perform a Bayesian global fit using the publicly available HEPfit package, taking into account state-of-the-art experimental information concerning these processes, including the suggestive measurements from LHCb of $R_{K}$ and $R_{K^{*}}$, the latter available only very recently. We parametrize New Physics contributions to $b \to s$ transitions in terms of shifts of Wilson coefficients of the electromagnetic dipole and semi-leptonic operators, assuming CP-conserving effects, but allowing in general for violation of lepton flavour universality. We show how optimistic/conservative hadronic estimates can impact quantitatively the size of New Physics extracted from the fit. With a conservative approach to hadronic uncertainties we find nonzero New Physics contributions to Wilson coefficients at the level of $\sim 3σ$, depending on the model chosen. Furthermore, given the interplay between hadronic contributions and New Physics effects in the leptonic vector current, a scenario with nonstandard leptonic axial currents is comparable to the more widely advocated one with New Physics in the leptonic vector current.
BibTeX
@article{ciuchini2017flavourful,
  author = {M. Ciuchini and Antônio Coutinho and Marco Fedele and E. Franco and Ayan Paul and L. Silvestrini and Mauro Valli},
  title = {{On Flavourful Easter eggs for New Physics hunger and Lepton Flavour Universality violation}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-017-5270-2},
}
Figure