Abstract
A new phase for the measurements of radiative decay modes in $b \to s$ transitions has started with new measurements of exclusive modes by LHCb and with Belle-II showing distinctive promises in both inclusive and exclusive channels. After critically reviewing the hadronic uncertainties in exclusive radiative decays, we analyze the impact of recent measurements of the branching ratio and mass-eigenstate rate asymmetry in $B_s \to \phi\gamma$ and of the angular distribution of $B \to K^* e^+ e^-$ at low $q^2$ on new physics in the $b \to s\gamma$ transition.
Introduction
In the Standard Model (SM), the decay of a $b$-quark into an $s$-quark and a photon ($b \to s \gamma$) is a flavor-changing neutral current (FCNC). These decays are forbidden at the tree level and must occur via complex quantum loops, making them highly sensitive to heavy, undiscovered particles. A key feature of the SM is that the emitted photon is almost entirely left-handed. Many theories of New Physics (NP), such as Supersymmetry or models with heavy vector-like quarks, predict a much larger fraction of right-handed photons.
The primary challenge in detecting NP lies in "hadronic uncertainties." While quark behavior is calculable, their binding into mesons like $B$ and $K^*$ involves complex strong-force dynamics. This paper critically reviews these uncertainties and utilizes new experimental data to constrain potential NP contributions.
Methodology
The analysis employs an Effective Hamiltonian approach, using Wilson coefficients ($C_7$ and $C_7'$) to parameterize the strength and chirality of the decay. $C_7$ represents the SM-like (left-handed) contribution, while $C_7'$ represents the "wrong-helicity" (right-handed) contribution.
The study uses a Bayesian statistical framework implemented in the flavio package. The global fit accounts for:
- Form Factors: Utilizing Light-Cone Sum Rules (LCSR) for meson transitions.
- Non-factorizable contributions: Accounting for interactions like spectator scattering and weak annihilation.
- New Observables: Including mass-eigenstate rate asymmetry ($A_{\Delta\Gamma}$) and angular observables ($P_1, A_T^{(Im)}$) sensitive to photon polarization.
The analysis draws from inclusive decays ($B \to X_s \gamma$ from CLEO, Belle, BaBar) and exclusive decays ($B \to K^* \gamma$, $B_s \to \phi \gamma$). It specifically incorporates recent LHCb measurements of the angular distribution of $B \to K^* e^+ e^-$ at low dielectron mass and the first measurement of $A_{\Delta\Gamma}$ in $B_s \to \phi \gamma$.
Results and Analysis
A notable finding is the "Form Factor" tension: SM predictions for $B \to K^* \gamma$ are slightly lower than experimental data, while those for $B_s \to \phi \gamma$ are slightly higher. This divergence suggests the discrepancy stems from hadronic form factors rather than new particles, as NP would typically shift both in the same direction.
The study highlights the complementarity of observables: $A_{\Delta\Gamma}$ probes the real part of $C_7'$, while angular observables in $B \to K^* e^+ e^-$ probe its imaginary part. Additionally, the direct CP asymmetry in $B \to K^* \gamma$ remains a powerful constraint on the imaginary part of $C_7$.
Key results include:
- Tightened Constraints: The real part of the NP contribution to $C_7$ is constrained to $Re(C_7^{NP}) \in [-0.018, 0.012]$ at $1\sigma$.
- Right-Handed Limits: $C_7'$ remains consistent with zero, though LHCb data for $B_s \to \phi \gamma$ shows a slight preference for a non-zero value.
- Form Factor Extraction: Assuming the SM, updated tensor form factors were derived: $T_1(0) = 0.316$ for $B \to K^*$ and $0.280$ for $B_s \to \phi$.
Conclusion and Future Outlook
The primary limitation remains hadronic uncertainty, particularly "soft gluon" corrections involving charm-quark loops. Future progress depends on:
- Belle-II: More precise measurements of inclusive decays and CP asymmetries.
- LHCb Upgrades: Reduction of statistical errors in $A_{\Delta\Gamma}$ and angular observables.
- Baryonic Decays: Radiative decays of the $\Lambda_b$ baryon could provide an independent check on photon chirality.
Summary updated