On Admissible Positions of Transonic Shocks for Steady Isothermal Euler Flows in a Horizontal Flat Nozzle under Vertical Gravity

Beixiang Fang, Xin GaoarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

In this paper, we are concerned with the existence of transonic shocks for 2-D steady isothermal Euler flows in a horizontal flat nozzle under vertical gravity. In particular, we focus on the contribution of the vertical gravity in determining the position of the shock front. For steady horizontal flows, the existence of normal shocks with the position of the shock front being arbitrary in the nozzle can be easily established. This paper tries to determine the position of the shock front as the state of the flow at the entrance of the nozzle and the pressure at the exit are slightly perturbed. To this end, this paper proposes a free boundary problem of the linearized Euler system with vertical gravity, whose solution could be an initial approximation for the shock solution with the free boundary being the approximation for the shock front. Under certain sufficient conditions on the perturbation, the existence of the solution to the proposed free boundary problem is established as the acceleration of gravity $g>0$ and the perturbation are sufficiently small. A nonlinear iteration scheme leads to a transonic shock solution with the position of the shock front being close to the initial approximating position.

Introduction: Where Does the Shock Sit?

In fluid dynamics, predicting the exact location of a shock wave inside a nozzle is a classic challenge. While geometry typically dictates shock position in diverging nozzles, a "flat" nozzle with parallel walls presents a mathematical ambiguity: without external forces, a steady shock could theoretically exist at any longitudinal position.

Recent research by Beixiang Fang and Xin Gao explores a factor often omitted in these models: vertical gravity. Their work demonstrates that even a small gravitational field acts as a mathematical "anchor," helping to uniquely determine the admissible position of a transonic shock in a horizontal flat nozzle.

The Problem: Gravity as a Determinant

In a horizontal flat nozzle, the steady Euler equations without gravity allow for "normal shocks" to exist anywhere. This lack of a unique solution is problematic for modeling real-world flows. The authors investigate whether adding vertical gravity ($g$) and slightly perturbing the flow at the entrance and the pressure at the exit can "fix" the shock's position.

Schematic of the perturbed transonic shock flow in a horizontal nozzle under vertical gravity.

As shown in Figure 1, the gravity introduces variable coefficients into the equations because density changes with height, coupling the mathematical system in complex ways. The challenge lies in solving the boundary value problem in the subsonic domain ($\mathcal{D}_+$) behind the shock front ($E_s$).

Methodology: Free Boundary Problem and Linearization

The problem is tackled as a Free Boundary Problem (FBP), where the shock front itself is an unknown boundary. The approach follows a rigorous mathematical pipeline:

  1. Lagrange Transformation: Coordinate transformation is used to "straighten" the streamlines, simplifying boundary conditions.
  2. Linearization: The Euler system is linearized around an unperturbed background state. Due to gravity, this linearized system is an elliptic-hyperbolic composite. In the subsonic region, pressure and flow angle are governed by elliptic-like equations, while entropy/Bernoulli variables are hyperbolic.
The unperturbed background state with a normal shock front used for linearization.
  1. Solvability Conditions: A specific condition for the subsonic flow is derived, which effectively selects the shock's position.
  2. Nonlinear Iteration: Using Schauder fixed-point theory, the authors prove that a full nonlinear solution exists near the initial approximation.

Key Insights and Results

The most significant insight is that vertical gravity is the "primary ingredient" that determines the shock position in a flat nozzle. It breaks the symmetry between pressure and velocity, forcing the shock to a specific coordinate to satisfy exit pressure requirements.

Key results include:

  • Theorem 2.5 (Initial Approximation): For small gravity $g > 0$ and perturbation $\sigma$, there exists a unique approximate shock position $\dot{\xi}_*$.
  • Theorem 2.6 (Main Existence Result): There exists a unique transonic shock solution to the full nonlinear problem.
  • Stability: The resulting shock position is stable and close to the initial approximation, with error estimates bounded by $C \sigma / g$.

Limitations and Future Work

The results are "local," applying only when gravity and perturbations are very small. Furthermore, the paper assumes isothermal gases ($p = \rho$). For polytropic gases ($p = \rho^\gamma$ with $\gamma > 1$), the current assumptions might not yield a solution. Finally, while the iteration scheme converges, the absolute uniqueness of the nonlinear solution remains an open problem.

Reference: Fang, B., & Gao, X. (2021). On Admissible Positions of Transonic Shocks for Steady Isothermal Euler Flows in a Horizontal Flat Nozzle under Vertical Gravity. arXiv:2112.02558v1 [math.AP].

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we are concerned with the existence of transonic shocks for 2-D steady isothermal Euler flows in a horizontal flat nozzle under vertical gravity. In particular, we focus on the contribution of the vertical gravity in determining the position of the shock front. For steady horizontal flows, the existence of normal shocks with the position of the shock front being arbitrary in the nozzle can be easily established. This paper will try to determine the position of the shock front as the state of the flow at the entrance of the nozzle and the pressure at the exit are slightly perturbed. To this end, this paper proposes a free boundary problem of the linearized Euler system with vertical gravity, whose solution could be an initial approximation for the shock solution with the free boundary being the approximation for the shock front. Due to the existence of the vertical gravity, difficulties arise in solving the boundary value problem in the approximate subsonic domain behind the shock front. The linearized Euler system is elliptic-hyperbolic composite for subsonic flows, and the elliptic part and the hyperbolic part are coupled in the $0$-order terms depending on the acceleration of gravity $g$. Moreover, the coefficients are not constants since the unperturbed shock solution depends on the vertical variable. New ideas and techniques are developed to deal with these difficulties and, under certain sufficient conditions on the perturbation, the existence of the solution to the proposed free boundary problem is established as the acceleration of gravity $g>0$ and the perturbation are sufficiently small. Then, with the obtained initial approximation of the shock solution, a nonlinear iteration scheme can be constructed which leads to a transonic shock solution with the position of the shock front being close to the initial approximating position.
BibTeX
@misc{fang2021admissible,
  author = {Beixiang Fang and Xin Gao},
  title = {{On Admissible Positions of Transonic Shocks for Steady Isothermal Euler Flows in a Horizontal Flat Nozzle under Vertical Gravity}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2112.02558},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2112.02558},
}
Figure