Global Instability of the Multi-dimensional Plane Shocks for the isothermal flow

N. Lai, Wei Xiang, Yi ZhouarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

While one-dimensional plane shocks in isothermal fluids are stable over long periods, this paper proves that in two and three dimensions, they are fundamentally unstable. Even small perturbations cause these complex wave structures to "blow up" in finite time, with lifespan estimates that perfectly mirror those found in nonlinear wave equations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In fluid dynamics, the Riemann problem—studying what happens when two different states of a fluid meet at a boundary—is a cornerstone for understanding shocks and flow patterns. For a long time, researchers have known that in a one-dimensional world, these solutions (like shocks and contact discontinuities) are globally stable.

However, our world is multi-dimensional. When we move to 2D or 3D, the mathematical "well-posedness" of these problems becomes much more fragile. The authors tackle the generalized Riemann problem for compressible isothermal Euler equations. Specifically, they ask: if we start with a stable 1D plane shock and introduce a tiny, smooth perturbation in a higher-dimensional space, does the solution stay smooth forever?

The challenge lies in the "fan-shaped" wave structure, which involves two shocks and a contact discontinuity. Proving whether these structures can exist globally is a major hurdle in the mathematical theory of conservation laws.

Methods

The authors employ rigorous mathematical analysis rather than numerical simulations. Their approach involves several key steps:

  1. Subdomain Decomposition: They rewrite the isothermal Euler equations across four subdomains separated by the moving shocks and the contact discontinuity.
  2. Multiplier Technique: To analyze the growth of perturbations, they introduce specific "multipliers." In 2D, they use exponential functions ($e^y \pm e^{-y}$); in 3D, they utilize a radially symmetric test function $F(y)$ that satisfies specific decay properties.
  3. Integral Quantities: By integrating the equations against these multipliers and applying Rankine-Hugoniot conditions (which describe how physical quantities jump across a shock), they derive a system of ordinary differential equations (ODEs) for the total "energy" or mass of the perturbation.
  4. Blow-up Analysis: They prove that these ODEs inevitably lead to a singularity (a "blow-up") in finite time, meaning the piecewise smooth solution cannot exist globally.

Datasets

Not applicable. This is a theoretical mathematical study based on analytical proofs and does not utilize empirical datasets or benchmarks.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dimensionality Matters: The most striking insight is the contrast between 1D and multi-D. In 1D, plane shocks are stable; in 2D and 3D, the geometry of the space allows perturbations to grow and eventually destroy the wave structure.
  • The Wave Equation Connection: The authors found that the "lifespan" of these fluid solutions (how long they last before blowing up) is mathematically identical to the lifespan of solutions to nonlinear wave equations. This suggests a deep, underlying structural similarity between fluid shocks and general wave propagation in higher dimensions.
  • Isothermal Constraints: The study specifically looks at isothermal flow (where pressure $p$ is equal to density $\rho$). This simplification allows for a clearer look at the instability mechanism without the added complexity of varying temperatures or complex equations of state.

Key Results

The paper establishes two primary quantitative results regarding the lifespan ($T$) of the solution relative to the size of the perturbation ($\epsilon$):

  • Two-Dimensional Case: The lifespan is bounded by $T(\epsilon) \leq C\epsilon^{-2}$. This means as the perturbation gets smaller, the solution lasts longer, but only quadratically so.
  • Three-Dimensional Case: The lifespan is bounded by $T(\epsilon) \leq \exp(C\epsilon^{-1})$. In 3D, the solution is much more resilient than in 2D, lasting for an exponentially long time, but it still eventually fails.
  • Non-Existence: The core result is a "negative" one: global piecewise smooth solutions consisting of two shocks and a contact discontinuity simply do not exist for this system in higher dimensions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Local vs. Global: While the paper proves these solutions cannot last forever, it doesn't solve the "local existence" problem for all cases. For instance, in 3D, it is still not fully proven that these solutions can even be started (local existence) due to the complexity of 3D vortex sheets, though this paper shows that if they start, they must end.
  • Equation of State: The results are specific to isothermal flow ($p = \rho$). Future research could investigate whether these instabilities hold for more general polytropic gases (where $p = \rho^\gamma$).
  • Weak Solutions: Since smooth solutions blow up, the next logical step is to study the problem in a "weak sense"—allowing for more rugged, less smooth mathematical descriptions to see if a different type of global stability can be found.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we are concerned with the long time behavior of the piecewise smooth solutions to the generalized Riemann problem governed by the compressible isothermal Euler equations in two and three dimensions. Non-existence result is established for the fan-shaped wave structure solution, including two shocks and one contact discontinuity and which is a perturbation of plane waves. Therefore, unlike the one-dimensional case, the multi-dimensional plane shocks are not stable globally. What is more, the sharp lifespan estimate is established which is the same as the lifespan estimate for the nonlinear wave equations in both two and three space dimensions.
BibTeX
@misc{lai2018global,
  author = {N. Lai and Wei Xiang and Yi Zhou},
  title = {{Global Instability of the Multi-dimensional Plane Shocks for the isothermal flow}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1807.07386},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.07386},
}
Figure