Persistence of the steady planar normal shock structure in 3-D unsteady potential flows

Beixiang Fang, Feimin Huang, Wei Xiang, Feng XiaoarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper concerns the dynamic stability of the steady 3-D wave structure of a planar normal shock front intersecting perpendicularly to a planar solid wall for unsteady potential flows. The stability problem is formulated as a free boundary problem of a quasi-linear hyperbolic equation of second order in a dihedral-space domain. The key challenge is the edge singularity at the intersection curve between the shock front and the solid wall. By introducing a modified partial hodograph transformation and an improved extension technique, the authors establish a well-posed theory for the linearized problem without loss of regularity. This allows for a classical nonlinear iteration scheme to prove the existence of the solution, demonstrating the dynamic stability of the steady planar normal shock without requiring the Nash-Moser iteration method.

Introduction

In fluid dynamics, shocks represent abrupt discontinuities in pressure, density, and velocity. A fundamental question for engineers and physicists is the stability of these structures: if a steady shock is slightly perturbed by flow fluctuations or wall irregularities, will it maintain its basic structure or collapse? While the stability of shocks in 2-D domains—where the shock meets a wall at a single point—is well-understood, the 3-D case presents significant mathematical hurdles.

Steady planar normal shock structure in a 3-D domain.

In a 3-D scenario, when a planar shock hits a wall, the intersection is a curve rather than a point. This creates a "dihedral" (wedge-like) domain. Mathematically, this intersection curve acts as an edge singularity where standard smooth equations break down. Previous methods used for 2-D cases could not be directly applied due to the added complexity of this singular curve in three dimensions.

The Stability Problem as a Free Boundary Problem

The authors treat the stability of the 3-D planar normal shock as a free boundary problem for a quasi-linear hyperbolic equation of second order. Because the shock's position changes over time in response to perturbations, the boundary itself is an unknown that must be determined as part of the solution.

Perturbed shock front and solid wall in the 3-D unsteady flow model.

As shown in the figures, the goal is to prove that if the incoming supersonic flow or the solid wall is slightly perturbed, the resulting shock front (the red surface in Figure 2) remains a well-defined, smooth structure close to the original steady state (the blue plane).

Methodology and Technical Innovations

The paper introduces several key innovations to overcome the difficulties of the 3-D dihedral domain:

  1. Modified Partial Hodograph Transformation: The authors developed a sophisticated coordinate transformation that "fixes" the moving shock front and "flattens" the potentially curved solid wall into a rectangular coordinate system. This transforms a complex, moving geometry into a static, manageable one.
  2. Improved Extension Technique: To handle the edge singularity, the authors "extend" the flow equations from the wedge-shaped domain into a simpler half-space. Crucially, they improved this technique to ensure that no loss of regularity occurs during the process.
  3. Classical Nonlinear Iteration: In many similar problems, researchers must use the "Nash-Moser" iteration—a powerful but complex tool used when equations lose smoothness at each step. Because the authors' extension technique preserves regularity, they were able to prove existence using a more standard, classical iteration scheme.

Key Results and Insights

The main result (Theorem 2.1) proves the existence and uniqueness of a local-in-time smooth solution to the nonlinear stability problem. This confirms that the steady 3-D wave structure is dynamically stable under a specific physical condition: $q_-\rho_+ - q_+\rho_- - \rho_+ > 0$ (where $q$ is velocity and $\rho$ is density).

The transition from 2-D to 3-D is not merely the addition of a variable; it changes the topological nature of the problem's difficulty. By maintaining the "smoothness" of the solution throughout the iteration, the authors demonstrated that the stability of these 3-D shocks is more mathematically robust than previously thought. The paper provides detailed a priori estimates in weighted Sobolev spaces ($H^s_\eta$), showing that the solution remains controlled near the edge singularity.

Limitations and Future Work

While significant, the study has several limitations:

  • Local in Time: The proof guarantees stability only for a short duration ($T_0$), not necessarily indefinitely (global stability).
  • Potential Flow Assumption: The model uses potential flow equations, which assume isentropic and irrotational flow. This does not capture the full complexity of the unsteady Euler equations, where entropy changes across the shock can create vorticity.
  • Small Perturbations: The results apply only to small disturbances; large-scale changes could still lead to radical transitions like Mach reflection.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper concerns the dynamic stability of the steady 3-D wave structure of a planar normal shock front intersecting perpendicularly to a planar solid wall for unsteady potential flows. The stability problem can be formulated as a free boundary problem of a quasi-linear hyperbolic equation of second order in a dihedral-space domain between the shock front and the solid wall. The key difficulty is brought by the edge singularity of the space domain, the intersection curve between the shock front and the solid wall. Different from the 2-D case, for which the singular part of the boundary is only a point, it is a curve for the 3-D case in this paper. This difference brings new difficulties to the mathematical analysis of the stability problem. A modified partial hodograph transformation is introduced such that the extension technique developed for the 2-D case can be employed to establish the well-posed theory for the initial-boundary value problem of the linearized hyperbolic equation of second order in a dihedral-space domain. Moreover, the extension technique is improved in this paper such that loss of regularity in the a priori estimates on the shock front does not occur. Thus the classical nonlinear iteration scheme can be constructed to prove the existence of the solution to the stability problem, which shows the dynamic stability of the steady planar normal shock without applying the Nash-Moser iteration method.
BibTeX
@misc{fang2021persistence,
  author = {Beixiang Fang and Feimin Huang and Wei Xiang and Feng Xiao},
  title = {{Persistence of the steady planar normal shock structure in 3-D unsteady potential flows}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2108.09207},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2108.09207},
}
Figure