Abstract
Electromagnetic (EM) tracking enables localization of surgical instruments within the magnetic field emitted by an EM field generator (FG). Usually, the larger a FG is, the larger its tracking volume is. However, the company NDI (Northern Digital Inc., Waterloo, ON, Canada) recently introduced the Planar 10-11 FG, which combines a compact construction (97mm x 112mm x 31mm) with a relatively large, cylindrical tracking volume (diameter: 340mm, height: 340mm). Using the standardized assessment protocol of Hummel et al., the FG was tested with regard to its tracking accuracy and to its robustness with respect to external sources of disturbance. The mean positional error was 0.59mm, with a mean jitter of 0.26mm in the standard setup. The mean orientational error was found to be 0.10°. The highest positional error (4.82mm) due to metallic sources of disturbance was caused by the steel SST 303. In contrast, steel SST 416 caused the lowest positional error (0.10mm). Overall, the Planar 10-11 FG tends to achieve better tracking accuracy results compared to other NDI FGs. Due to its compact construction and portability, the FG could contribute to increased clinical use of EM tracking systems.
Introduction
In the field of surgical navigation, precise localization of instruments relative to patient anatomy is a fundamental requirement. Intraoperative Tracking (IOT) systems are commonly employed for this purpose. While optical tracking systems are prevalent, they are limited by the need for a continuous line-of-sight between the camera and the tracked tools. Electromagnetic (EM) tracking overcomes this limitation by functioning through tissue and surgical drapes. However, EM systems have historically faced a trade-off between the physical size of the field generator (FG) and the usable tracking volume. Large volumes typically required bulky generators that are difficult to integrate into the constrained space of an operating room.
The NDI Planar 10-11 FG represents a significant advancement, offering a large, cylindrical tracking volume (340mm x 340mm) within a compact device roughly the size of a thick paperback book. This study provides a standardized evaluation of this new hardware to determine its suitability for clinical use, particularly in delicate head and neck interventions.
Methods
The researchers evaluated the Planar 10-11 using the Hummel Protocol, a gold-standard assessment for EM tracking systems. The evaluation focused on two primary configurations:
- Standard-Setup: The FG is mounted to the side of a measurement plate, mimicking a typical fixed installation in a clinical setting.
- Mobile-Setup: The FG is positioned centrally over the measurement plate, simulating a "mobile" use case where the generator might be integrated into a headrest or vacuum pillow directly beneath the patient's head.
The study utilized a 6DOF (six degrees of freedom) Cable Tool sensor to measure three critical performance metrics: jitter (signal stability), position accuracy (relative to a 5cm reference grid), and orientation error. Furthermore, the robustness of the system was tested by introducing four different metallic materials (Steel SST 303, Steel SST 416, Bronze, and Aluminum) at varying heights within the magnetic field to quantify the resulting data distortion.
Results and Discussion
The Planar 10-11 demonstrated exceptional accuracy, particularly when used in the centered "Mobile-Setup." In the Standard-Setup, the mean positional error was 0.59 mm, with a mean jitter of 0.26 mm and an orientation error of 0.10°. In the Mobile-Setup, performance improved significantly: the mean positional error dropped to just 0.16 mm, and jitter was reduced to 0.03 mm. These results indicate that for maximum precision, clinicians should aim to place the generator as close as possible to the target anatomy.
The robustness tests revealed that the choice of surgical materials is critical when using EM navigation. While Steel SST 416 caused minimal interference (0.10 mm error), Steel SST 303 induced a substantial error of 4.82 mm. This finding highlights the importance of material compatibility in the operating room.
Compared to older NDI models, such as the "Standard FG" and "Compact FG," the Planar 10-11 showed superior performance, with positional errors in the mobile setup being approximately 3.13 times lower. However, the study noted that accuracy degrades toward the edges of the tracking volume, and the use of "micro" sensors (0.8mm diameter) required for certain needle-based interventions resulted in higher orientation errors.
Conclusion
The NDI Planar 10-11 FG successfully combines a compact form factor with a large, high-accuracy tracking volume. Its sub-millimeter performance in standardized tests suggests it could significantly lower the barrier to routine clinical use of EM tracking in head and neck surgeries. Future research will involve clinical integration studies to validate these findings in real-world operating room environments, accounting for electronic noise and the presence of diverse metallic surgical equipment.
Summary updated