Navigierte Interventionen im Kopf- und Halsbereich - Standardisiertes Assessment eines neuen, handlichen Feldgenerators

Benjamin Johannes Mittmann, Alexander Seitel, Lena Maier-Hein, Alfred M. Franz

Introduction

Electromagnetic (EM) tracking has become a cornerstone of surgical navigation, particularly for interventions where a direct line-of-sight is impossible, such as endoscopies or catheter-based procedures. Unlike optical systems, which are prone to occlusion, EM tracking utilizes magnetic fields to localize sensors within the patient's body. However, existing EM field generators (FGs) often force a compromise between portability and tracking volume. Large generators offer expansive workspaces but are cumbersome, while smaller units frequently suffer from restricted volumes or reduced accuracy.

Schematic representation of the clinical application for the mobile setup, integrating the field generator into a vacuum pillow for head and neck surgery.

This study evaluates the NDI Planar 10-11 FG, a compact device designed to bridge this gap. By offering a large tracking volume within a small physical footprint, it aims to provide clinical-grade precision (sub-millimeter accuracy) in space-constrained environments like head and neck surgery.

Methodology

The performance of the NDI Planar 10-11 was assessed using the standardized "Hummel protocol." The evaluation focused on two primary configurations:

  1. Standard-Setup: The FG is mounted laterally to a measurement plate, simulating a conventional fixed clinical installation.
  2. Mobile-Setup: The FG is positioned centrally beneath the measurement area, representing integration into a patient headrest or vacuum pillow.
Comparison of the experimental configurations: (a) Mobile-Setup with height adapters and (b) Standard-Setup with lateral FG mounting.

The researchers measured Jitter (signal stability), Position Accuracy, and Orientation Error. Additionally, the system's robustness against metallic interference was tested by introducing four materials (Steel SST 303, Steel SST 416, bronze, and aluminum) at varying distances. The study also compared a standard 6DOF Cable Tool sensor against a specialized 0.8 mm "Micro" sensor. Raw data from these benchmarks is publicly available via the Open Science Framework.

Results and Discussion

The Planar 10-11 demonstrated significant improvements over previous generations. In the Mobile-Setup, the system achieved a mean positional accuracy of 0.16 mm with a jitter of only 0.03 mm. Even in the more expansive Standard-Setup, accuracy remained high at 0.59 mm. Orientation errors were consistently low, averaging 0.10°.

Key Insights

  • Workspace Optimization: Despite its small size (112mm x 97mm x 31mm), the device maintains a substantial cylindrical tracking volume (340mm x 340mm), allowing for full coverage of the head when placed under the neck.
  • Spatial Accuracy Variance: Accuracy is highest at the center of the field but degrades toward the periphery, with errors reaching up to 7.16 mm at the extreme edges.
  • Material Sensitivity: The type of metal significantly impacts interference. While Steel SST 303 caused errors of 4.82 mm, Steel SST 416 was nearly "invisible" (0.10 mm error), suggesting that careful material selection for surgical instruments can mitigate EM tracking issues.
  • Sensor Limitations: The "Micro" sensor exhibited higher rotation errors (up to 8°) and lower overall accuracy compared to standard sensors, indicating a current physical limit for ultra-miniaturized tracking components.

Conclusion

The NDI Planar 10-11 FG represents a major advancement in EM tracking hardware, offering roughly twice the stability and over three times the accuracy of its predecessors in mobile configurations. While the device is ready for high-precision clinical tasks, users must remain mindful of the accuracy drop-off at the tracking volume's edges and the limitations of miniaturized sensors. Future work will focus on clinical trials within vacuum pillows and software-based compensation for peripheral field distortions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Electromagnetic (EM) tracking enables localization of surgical instruments within the magnetic field emitted by an EM field generator (FG). Usually, the larger a FG is, the larger its tracking volume is. However, the company NDI (Northern Digital Inc., Waterloo, ON, Canada) recently introduced the Planar 10-11 FG, which combines a compact construction (97mm x 112mm x 31mm) with a relatively large, cylindrical tracking volume (diameter: 340mm, height: 340mm). Using the standardized assessment protocol of Hummel et al., the FG was tested with regard to its tracking accuracy and to its robustness with respect to external sources of disturbance. The mean positional error (5cm distance metric according to Hummel protocol) was 0.59mm, with a mean jitter of 0.26mm in the standard setup. The mean orientational error was found to be 0.10°. The highest positional error (4.82mm) due to metallic sources of disturbance was caused by the steel SST 303. In contrast, steel SST 416 caused the lowest positional error (0.10mm). Overall, the Planar 10-11 FG tends to achieve better tracking accuracy results compared to other NDI FGs. Due to its compact construction and portability, the FG could contribute to increased clinical use of EM tracking systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mittmann2019navigierte,
  author = {Benjamin Johannes Mittmann and Alexander Seitel and Lena Maier-Hein and Alfred M. Franz},
  title = {{Navigierte Interventionen im Kopf- und Halsbereich - Standardisiertes Assessment eines neuen, handlichen Feldgenerators}},
  booktitle = {Bildverarbeitung für die Medizin},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/978-3-658-25326-4\_53},
}
Figure