Combined Modality for Ultrasound Imaging and Electromagnetic Tracking

Alfred M. Franz, Keno März, Alexander Seitel, Hannes Kenngott, Martin Wagner, Anas Amin Preukschas, H.-p. Meinzer, Ivo Wolf, Lena Maier‐HeinBiomedizinische 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Computer-assisted interventions (CAI) typically require localization (tracking) of surgical instruments and the patient. For ultrasound (US)-guided interventions, a new compact electromagnetic (EM) field generator enables construction of a combined modality which allows for both, EM tracking and US imaging with one handheld device. In this study, we present a research prototype of such a device and conduct accuracy assessments in a clinical US suite. The results show robust US imaging and EM tracking of the combined device, which emerges as a promising component for US-guided CAI systems.

Introduction

In Computer-Assisted Interventions (CAI), precise tracking of surgical instruments and patient anatomy is critical for procedural success. Ultrasound (US) is a preferred imaging modality in these settings because it is real-time, cost-effective, and radiation-free. However, to track the US probe within a 3D coordinate system, external tracking hardware is required.

Electromagnetic (EM) tracking is often favored over optical systems because it does not require a direct line of sight. However, traditional EM tracking relies on bulky Field Generators (FG) that must be placed near the patient, cluttering the surgical workspace. This paper presents a solution: integrating a miniaturized FG directly onto the ultrasound probe, creating a single handheld device that eliminates the need for external tracking hardware around the patient bed.

System Design and Methods

The research prototype combines a standard Telemed C4.5/50/128Z ultrasound probe with a lightweight (100g) NDI Compact Field Generator. This integrated setup projects a dome-shaped tracking volume with an 18.5 cm radius directly around the ultrasound imaging plane, ensuring the tracking region always aligns with the physician's region of interest.

Figure 2: Overview of the combined modality system, including the US probe with attached EM field generator, tracking system, and processing unit.

To ensure the two technologies do not interfere, the team conducted evaluations in a clinical US suite:

  1. EM Tracking Assessment: Using the standardized Hummel protocol, 36 positional and 32 rotational measurements were taken in a physical grid to determine if the probe's materials or the clinical environment distorted the EM field.
  2. US Imaging Assessment: The team scanned a gelatine phantom containing artificial targets, comparing baseline images (FG detached) against images taken with the active combined modality to measure pixel-level intensity errors.

Key Results

The experimental results demonstrate that the integrated device maintains high performance across both modalities with negligible interference.

Tracking Accuracy and Precision

The EM tracking system maintained a mean positional accuracy of less than 1.0 mm and a precision of less than 0.1 mm. While the presence of the probe caused a slight decrease in accuracy (~24%) compared to a sterile lab baseline, the results remain highly suitable for clinical use. Rotational errors were also minimal, ranging between 0.4° and 1.6°.

Figure 5: Quantitative evaluation of precision and accuracy (at 5cm distances) for the combined modality compared to a reference baseline.

Imaging Robustness

Ultrasound imaging remained highly stable. The mean pixel intensity error introduced by the active EM field was only 0.65 (on a 0-255 grayscale range), which is a minor increase over baseline noise. Qualitatively, no visual artifacts or field distortions were observed in the resulting scans.

Discussion and Future Work

This study proves that modern compact FGs can be successfully integrated with ultrasound probes. By keeping the FG close to the sensors, the system appears more robust against environmental metal interference common in operating rooms.

One limitation of the current prototype is ergonomics; the side-mounted FG makes the probe somewhat lopsided. Future iterations will focus on a custom joint housing that centrally mounts the FG to the probe to improve handling. This combined modality represents a promising step toward more streamlined, less cluttered US-guided computer-assisted interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Computer-assisted interventions (CAI) typically require localization (tracking) of surgical instruments and the patient. For ultrasound (US)-guided interventions, a new compact electromagnetic (EM) field generator enables construction of a combined modality which allows for both, EM tracking and US imaging with one handheld device. In this study, we present a research prototype of such a device and conduct accuracy assessments in a clinical US suite. The results show robust US imaging and EM tracking of the combined device, which emerges as a promising component for US-guided CAI systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{franz2013combined,
  author = {Alfred M. Franz and Keno März and Alexander Seitel and Hannes Kenngott and Martin Wagner and Anas Amin Preukschas and H.-P. Meinzer and Ivo Wolf and Lena Maier‐Hein},
  title = {{Combined Modality for Ultrasound Imaging and Electromagnetic Tracking}},
  booktitle = {Biomedizinische},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1515/bmt-2013-4291},
}
Figure