Mobility as a Resource (MaaR) for resilient human-centric automation: a vision paper

S. Travis Waller, Amalia Polydoropoulou, Leandros Tassiulas, Athanasios K. Ziliaskopoulos, Sisi Jian, Susann Wagenknecht, Georg Hirte, Tomasz Bednarz

Abstract

With technological advances, mobility has been moving from a product (i.e., traditional modes and vehicles), to a service (i.e., Mobility as a Service, MaaS). However, as observed in other fields (e.g. cloud computing resource management) we argue that mobility will evolve from a service to a resource (i.e., Mobility as a Resource, MaaR). Further, due to increasing scarcity of shared mobility spaces across traditional and emerging modes, the transition must be viewed within the critical need for ethical and equitable solutions for the traveling public. The evolution of mobility into a resource requires novel conceptual frameworks, technologies, processes and perspectives of analysis. A key component of the future MaaR system is the technological capacity to observe, allocate and manage (in real-time) the smallest envisionable units of mobility (i.e., atomic units of mobility capacity) while providing prioritized attention to human movement and ethical metrics related to access, consumption and impact.

Introduction: The Scarcity Wall

As urban environments become increasingly congested and transportation modes diversify—ranging from e-scooters and bicycles to autonomous delivery pods—cities are hitting a "scarcity wall." While Mobility as a Service (MaaS) has improved access by shifting the focus from ownership to usage, it does not fundamentally solve the underlying problem of how to allocate limited physical space and time efficiently.

Current "smart city" solutions often lean toward purely market-driven outcomes, which risk creating "hyper-market" scenarios that ignore social welfare. There is a critical gap in managing the microscopic interactions between automated systems and human-centric movements like walking or cycling. This vision paper proposes Mobility as a Resource (MaaR): a framework designed to manage mobility capacity in real-time, ensuring efficiency without sacrificing equity.

The Evolution to Mobility as a Resource (MaaR)

The shift to MaaR mirrors the evolution of computing. Just as computing moved from owning hardware (product) to renting servers (service) and finally to serverless cloud functions (resource), mobility is undergoing a similar "resourcification." In a MaaR system, a specific patch of road at a specific millisecond is treated as a tradable, "atomic" unit of mobility capacity.

Hard capacity as Physical Infrastructure illustrates how spatial and trajectory capacities are reserved and shared across a grid-based network.

This discretization allows for much higher fidelity than current lane-based or signal-based management. The system distinguishes between "hard capacity" (physical infrastructure) and "soft capacity" (trajectories). Hard capacity can be reserved, shared, or prioritized for specific users, such as Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs).

Research Pillars for a MaaR System

The transition to MaaR requires a synthesis of research across five key pillars:

  1. Dynamic Reservation Frameworks: Developing systems where atomic units of road pavement can be reserved via auctions, first-come-first-served protocols, or blockchain platforms.
  2. Automated and Mixed Traffic Control: Utilizing techniques like max-pressure stochastic control and multi-objective Pareto optimization to manage the flow of both autonomous vehicles (AVs) and human-driven vehicles (HVs).
  3. Adaptive Mixed Equilibrium: Creating models that account for both hard capacity and "soft capacity"—where a traveler might use their vehicle's unused space to provide a secondary service, like parcel delivery.
  4. Behavioral Modeling: Predicting how travelers adapt to dynamic bidding or reservation systems using hybrid choice models and machine learning.
  5. Strategic Quantification: Integrating formal equity metrics (e.g., Gini or Atkinson indices) directly into optimization goals to ensure fair distribution of mobility benefits.

Balancing Automation and Human-Centricity

A core tenet of MaaR is the distinction between automated mobility and human-centric movement. While automated systems can operate within strict reservation protocols, human movement is inherently less predictable.

Traveller classes in the MaaR framework, distinguishing between automated mobility with reservation and human-centric mobility without hard capacity reservation.

The system must accommodate "Human-centric mobility" (pedestrians, cyclists) that operates without hard capacity reservations. MaaR must be resilient enough to handle "human-centric failures"—such as a child unexpectedly entering a reserved trajectory—by instantly reallocating resources to prevent cascading system failures.

Challenges and Future Directions

The path to MaaR faces significant hurdles. It is highly dependent on the evolution of high-speed communication and fine-grained sensing; without precise discretization, the system cannot function. Furthermore, the regulatory and legal complexity of auction-based road management varies significantly by region.

The transition period will likely span decades, requiring a long-term mix of automated and non-automated actors. Perhaps most importantly, social acceptance remains a major research need: will the public accept a system where their "right to the road" is managed by dynamic, market-based algorithms?

Conclusion

MaaR represents a paradigm shift toward a hyper-efficient, resilient, and equitable transportation future. By treating mobility as a resource and managing it at the atomic level, we can balance the optimization of automated systems with the essential, unpredictable nature of human movement.

Summary updated

Abstract

With technological advances, mobility has been moving from a product (i.e., traditional modes and vehicles), to a service (i.e., Mobility as a Service, MaaS). However, as observed in other fields (e.g. cloud computing resource management) we argue that mobility will evolve from a service to a resource (i.e., Mobility as a Resource, MaaR). Further, due to increasing scarcity of shared mobility spaces across traditional and emerging modes, the transition must be viewed within the critical need for ethical and equitable solutions for the traveling public (i.e., research is needed to avoid hyper-market driven outcomes for society). The evolution of mobility into a resource requires novel conceptual frameworks, technologies, processes and perspectives of analysis. A key component of the future MaaR system is the technological capacity to observe, allocate and manage (in real-time) the smallest envisionable units of mobility (i.e., atomic units of mobility capacity) while providing prioritized attention to human movement and ethical metrics related to access, consumption and impact. To facilitate research into the envisioned future system, this paper proposes initial frameworks which synthesize and advance methodologies relating to highly dynamic capacity reservation systems. Future research requires synthesis across transport network management, demand behavior, mixed-mode usage, and equitable mobility.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{waller2024mobility,
  author = {S. Travis Waller and Amalia Polydoropoulou and Leandros Tassiulas and Athanasios K. Ziliaskopoulos and Sisi Jian and Susann Wagenknecht and Georg Hirte and Tomasz Bednarz},
  title = {{Mobility as a Resource (MaaR) for resilient human-centric automation: a vision paper}},
  booktitle = {Data},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s42421-024-00115-z},
}
Figure