Mobility as a Resource (MaaR) for Resilient Human-Centric Automation – A Vision Paper

S. Travis Waller, Amalia Polydoropoulou, Leandros Tassiulas, Athanasios Ziliaskopoulos, Sisi Jian, Susann Wagenknecht, Georg Hirte, Satish V. Ukkusuri, Gitakrishnan Ramadurai, Tomasz Bednarz

Abstract

With technological advances, mobility has been moving from a product (i.e., traditional modes and vehicles), to a service (i.e., Mobility as a Service, MaaS). However, as observed in other fields (e.g., cloud computing resource management) we argue that mobility will evolve from a service to a resource (i.e., “Mobility as a Resource”, MaaR). Further, due to increasing scarcity of shared-mobility spaces across traditional and emerging modes, the transition must be viewed within the critical need for ethical and equitable solutions for the traveling public (i.e., research is needed to avoid hyper-market driven outcomes for society). The evolution of mobility into a resource requires novel conceptual frameworks, technologies, processes and perspectives of analysis. A key component of the future MaaR system is the technological capacity to observe, allocate and manage (in real-time) the smallest envisionable units of mobility (i.e., atomic units of mobility capacity) while providing prioritized attention to human movement and ethical metrics related to access, consumption and impact. To facilitate research into the envisioned future system, this paper proposes initial frameworks which synthesize and advance methodologies relating to highly dynamic capacity reservation systems. Future research requires synthesis across transport network management, demand behavior, mixed-mode usage, and equitable mobility.

Introduction: The Shift from Service to Resource

The transportation landscape is undergoing a fundamental shift. We have transitioned from viewing mobility as a product (vehicle ownership) to a service (Uber, shared shuttles, MaaS apps). However, as urban space becomes a "complex scarcity" contested by autonomous vehicles, delivery robots, and human travelers, the "service" model may no longer suffice.

This vision paper proposes a transition to Mobility as a Resource (MaaR). Drawing an analogy from cloud computing, where hardware is abstracted into on-demand resources, MaaR treats road space and time as "atomic units" that can be reserved, managed, and traded in real-time. Without this structured "resourcification," the authors warn of "hyper-market driven outcomes" that could prioritize high-paying automated fleets over vulnerable human road users, potentially worsening social inequality and system instability.

The MaaR Conceptual Framework

The core of the MaaR vision is a multi-disciplinary framework that manages the interaction between different traveler classes and infrastructure types.

The MaaR conceptual framework integrates soft capacity (trajectories) and hard capacity (physical infrastructure) across automated and human-centric traveler classes.

The framework distinguishes between two primary types of capacity:

  • Hard Capacity: The physical infrastructure, such as lanes and intersections, which must be allocated with high granularity.
  • Soft Capacity: The "empty space" within a traveler's planned trajectory. For instance, an automated vehicle might "share" its trajectory capacity to allow a small delivery robot to follow closely or utilize unused space.

This system requires a "technological operating system" capable of handling decentralized reservations, potentially leveraging blockchain or advanced traffic control policies like "max-pressure" stochastic control to manage intersections in real-time.

Human-Centric Automation and Equity

A critical tenet of MaaR is its responsiveness to human movement. Unlike rigid automated systems, a resilient MaaR system must prioritize Vulnerable Road Users (VRUs) like pedestrians and cyclists. If a human enters a reserved space, the system must dynamically reallocate resources to ensure safety without causing systemic cascading failures.

Furthermore, the paper emphasizes that "resourcification" is not inherently equitable. To prevent the creation of "transit deserts," the authors propose integrating rigorous equity metrics into the system's core logic. These include:

  • Rawl’s Egalitarian (RE): Maximizing the welfare of the least well-off.
  • Gini Index: Measuring the statistical dispersion of accessibility across the population.
  • Atkinson Index: Assessing social welfare with a specific parameter for "inequity aversion."

Challenges and Future Research

The transition to MaaR faces significant hurdles. It relies on ubiquitous high-fidelity sensing and V2X (Vehicle-to-Everything) communication. Moreover, the behavioral response of humans to a high-fidelity reservation system—where paths are reserved in meters and seconds—remains an open question.

Future research must focus on synthesizing transport network management with demand behavior and ethical metrics to ensure the transition from MaaS to MaaR is both efficient and just.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract With technological advances, mobility has been moving from a product (i.e., traditional modes and vehicles), to a service (i.e., Mobility as a Service, MaaS). However, as observed in other fields (e.g., cloud computing resource management) we argue that mobility will evolve from a service to a resource (i.e., “Mobility as a Resource”, MaaR). Further, due to increasing scarcity of shared-mobility spaces across traditional and emerging modes, the transition must be viewed within the critical need for ethical and equitable solutions for the traveling public (i.e., research is needed to avoid hyper-market driven outcomes for society). The evolution of mobility into a resource requires novel conceptual frameworks, technologies, processes and perspectives of analysis. A key component of the future MaaR system is the technological capacity to observe, allocate and manage (in real-time) the smallest envisionable units of mobility (i.e., atomic units of mobility capacity) while providing prioritized attention to human movement and ethical metrics related to access, consumption and impact. To facilitate research into the envisioned future system, this paper proposes initial frameworks which synthesize and advance methodologies relating to highly dynamic capacity reservation systems. Future research requires synthesis across transport network management, demand behavior, mixed-mode usage, and equitable mobility.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{waller2024mobility,
  author = {S. Travis Waller and Amalia Polydoropoulou and Leandros Tassiulas and Athanasios Ziliaskopoulos and Sisi Jian and Susann Wagenknecht and Georg Hirte and Satish V. Ukkusuri and Gitakrishnan Ramadurai and Tomasz Bednarz},
  title = {{Mobility as a Resource (MaaR) for Resilient Human-Centric Automation – A Vision Paper}},
  booktitle = {Data},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s42421-024-00115-z},
}
Figure