Mobility Analysis of Screw-Based Locomotion and Propulsion in Various Media

Jason Lim, Calvin Joyce, Elizabeth Peiros, Mingwei Yeoh, Peter V. Gavrilov, Sara G. Wickenhiser, Dimitri A. Schreiber, Florian Richter, Michael C. YiparXiv 2023 · OpenReview

Abstract

Robots "in-the-wild" encounter and must traverse widely varying terrain, ranging from solid ground to granular materials like sand to full liquids. Numerous approaches exist, including wheeled and legged robots, each excelling in specific domains. Screw-based locomotion is a promising approach for multi-domain mobility, leveraged in exploratory robotic designs, including amphibious vehicles and snake robotics. However, unlike other forms of locomotion, there is a limited exploration of the models, parameter effects, and efficiency for multi-terrain Archimedes screw locomotion. In this work, we present work towards this missing component in understanding screw-based locomotion: comprehensive experimental results and performance analysis across different media. We designed a mobile test bed for indoor and outdoor experimentation to collect this data. Beyond quantitatively showing the multi-domain mobility of screw-based locomotion, we envision future researchers and engineers using the presented results to design effective screw-based locomotion systems.

Introduction

Mobile robots frequently encounter challenging "in-the-wild" terrains where traditional locomotion methods falter. While wheels excel on prepared surfaces, they often become bogged down in soft granular media like sand. Conversely, legged systems offer high agility but at the cost of significant mechanical and control complexity. Screw-based locomotion, which utilizes rotating helical threads to generate thrust against a medium, has emerged as a robust "go-anywhere" alternative for amphibious and multi-terrain applications.

Despite its historical use and potential, standardized data characterizing how screw parameters—such as torque and speed—translate into thrust and efficiency across diverse materials has been lacking. This research addresses this gap by providing a systematic experimental analysis of Archimedes screw physics across a spectrum of media, including grass, dirt, gravel, and sand.

Experimental Methodology

To rigorously quantify performance, the researchers developed a custom mobile test bed designed for both indoor and outdoor environments. This system allows for the isolation and measurement of key locomotion metrics.

The custom mobile test bed showing the linear rail system, motors, and sensor suite.

The test bed features:

  • Linear Isolation: A rail system constrains the screw's motion to a single axis, ensuring that measurements reflect pure locomotive performance.
  • Axial Loading: A secondary motor applies a controlled "towing" load, simulating the weight of a robot body or cargo.
  • Comprehensive Sensing: A 6-degree-of-freedom (6-DoF) Force Torque Sensor (FTS) and high-resolution encoders capture real-time thrust, torque, and velocity data.

Experiments were conducted using a 3D-printed ABS screw across seven distinct media: small gravel, big gravel, grass, sand, wood chips, dirt, and concrete.

Performance Analysis and Key Insights

The study evaluated both static performance (mechanical advantage when stationary) and motion performance (slip, efficiency, and Cost of Transport).

Linearity and Media Effects

A primary finding is the remarkably linear relationship between input angular velocity and output traveling velocity across most media. However, the performance varies significantly depending on the material's properties.

Traveling linear velocity vs. angular velocity across different media, highlighting the failure on rigid surfaces like concrete.

As shown in the data, screws are fundamentally unsuitable for rigid surfaces like concrete. Without the ability to deform or penetrate the medium, the screw simply slips, resulting in near-zero traveling velocity. In contrast, granular media like gravel and wood chips—characterized by high shearing force—yielded the highest locomotive efficiency.

The "Dig-In" Effect

One of the most significant insights is the "dig-in" effect. Counter-intuitively, applying an axial load often increased locomotive efficiency in granular media. The added weight forces the screw to embed deeper, increasing the surface area of the threads in contact with the medium and thereby generating more effective thrust. However, this effect has limits; in sand, excessive loading can cause the screw to churn the material in place, leading to a sharp decline in performance.

Efficiency and Cost of Transport (COT)

  • Efficiency: Wood chips and gravel demonstrated the highest locomotive efficiency under load (up to 0.20).
  • COT: The Cost of Transport—a dimensionless measure of energy efficiency—was lowest for big gravel (~1.91) and highest for grass (~4.03) under no-load conditions.
  • Thrust Generation: In dirt and gravel, the screw generated significant thrust (up to ~18N) when loaded, confirming its potential for heavy-duty towing in loose terrain.

Conclusion and Future Work

This work provides a foundational dataset for understanding screw-based locomotion in diverse terrains. While the current study focused on a single screw geometry, it establishes a standardized methodology for future optimization.

Future research will expand this analysis to include fluidic media (liquids and mud) and explore the unique physics of regelation on ice. Additionally, the test bed will be used to investigate how varying screw geometry—such as pitch and thread profile—can be optimized for specific environmental conditions, ultimately leading to more capable multi-domain robotic systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Robots "in-the-wild" encounter and must traverse widely varying terrain, ranging from solid ground to granular materials like sand to full liquids. Numerous approaches exist, including wheeled and legged robots, each excelling in specific domains. Screw-based locomotion is a promising approach for multi-domain mobility, leveraged in exploratory robotic designs, including amphibious vehicles and snake robotics. However, unlike other forms of locomotion, there is a limited exploration of the models, parameter effects, and efficiency for multi-terrain Archimedes screw locomotion. In this work, we present work towards this missing component in understanding screw-based locomotion: comprehensive experimental results and performance analysis across different media. We designed a mobile test bed for indoor and outdoor experimentation to collect this data. Beyond quantitatively showing the multi-domain mobility of screw-based locomotion, we envision future researchers and engineers using the presented results to design effective screw-based locomotion systems.
BibTeX
@misc{lim2023mobility,
  author = {Jason Lim and Calvin Joyce and Elizabeth Peiros and Mingwei Yeoh and Peter V. Gavrilov and Sara G. Wickenhiser and Dimitri A. Schreiber and Florian Richter and Michael C. Yip},
  title = {{Mobility Analysis of Screw-Based Locomotion and Propulsion in Various Media}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2301.10878},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2301.10878},
}
Figure