Introduction
Navigating transitional environments—such as muddy marshlands or volcanic lava tubes—presents a significant challenge for traditional robotic locomotion. Archimedes screw-based propulsion offers a versatile solution, theoretically capable of "swimming" through fluids and "crawling" through granular solids. However, a design optimized for one medium often fails in another; for instance, a screw designed for water may simply dig a hole in dry sand. This study investigates how design parameters like blade height and pitch angle influence performance across a spectrum of media, from fluids to non-Newtonian saturated sands.
Theoretical Framework and Methodology
The researchers adopted a "principles-first" approach by drawing an analogy between screw propulsion and heat sink design. Just as an optimal fin spacing maximizes airflow in a heat sink, an optimal "crowdedness" of screw threads maximizes mass transport for propulsion.
To quantify this, a new parameter called the Aspect Ratio ($\psi$) was introduced. This metric integrates pitch angle ($\alpha$), the number of starts ($N$), and blade height ($B_H$) into a single metric to describe the geometric density of the screw threads.
The experimental setup involved a custom linear test rig evaluating seven 3D-printed screw shells with varying blade heights (10mm and 30mm) and pitch angles (8.4° to 36.2°). Performance was measured across four distinct environments: water (fluid), dry sand (granular), wet sand (cohesive granular), and saturated sand (non-Newtonian fluid).
Results and Discussion
The study revealed that the dominant design parameters shift significantly depending on the medium:
- Granular Media (Sand): Blade height is the critical factor. Taller blades increase normal stress on the sand, creating more effective "grooves" for propulsion. High-pitch screws performed poorly here because sand does not "reflow" (fill back in) quickly enough, leading to "tunneling" or digging a hole.
- Aquatic Media (Water): Pitch angle is the primary driver. Higher pitches move larger volumes of water, acting more like a propeller. Interestingly, low blade heights were 8.9% faster than high blade heights for the same pitch, likely due to reduced drag and vortex interference.
- Transitional Media (Wet/Saturated Sand): Cohesion in wet sand actually improved performance, with the best shell seeing a 48% velocity increase over dry sand. However, saturated sand acted as a shear-thinning non-Newtonian fluid, often stalling motors during traditional "screwing" due to high torque demands.
The "Rolling" Breakthrough
In saturated sand where screwing almost completely failed, the researchers tested a "rolling" mode—treating the screw as a cylinder or wheel. This achieved a velocity of 0.137 m/s, representing a 27-fold increase over the best screwing attempt in the same medium.
Conclusion
This research provides a ranking framework for screw designs across diverse media, demonstrating that a "one-size-fits-all" design is insufficient for amphibious transitions. Future robotic systems could utilize motor current sensing to detect environmental transitions (e.g., hitting saturated sand) and automatically switch from screwing to rolling modes to optimize efficiency and prevent stalling.
Summary updated