Making the 2007-2010 Action Plan work for women in family medicine in the Asia Pacific

Jan Coles, Amanda S. Barnard, Amanda Howe, Jo Wainer, Zorayda Leopando, Sarah StrasserAsia 2010 · DOI

Abstract

The Wonca Working Party for Women and Family Medicine (WWPWFM), established in 2001, aims to address gender equity, promote networking, and enhance women's participation in global health initiatives. In October 2008, fifty women physicians gathered at the Asia Pacific Regional conference in Melbourne to translate the global "2007-2010 Action Plan" into regional priorities. This report outlines the identified barriers—ranging from professional invisibility to rigid training models—and the resulting 16-point roadmap designed to improve career pathways and clinical outcomes across the Asia-Pacific.

Introduction

The Asia Pacific Family Medicine initiative focuses on regional equity and professional development. Making the 2007-2010 Action Plan work for women in family medicine in the Asia Pacific, page 1

The Asia Pacific Family Medicine initiative focuses on regional equity and professional development.

Despite the growing presence of women in the family medicine workforce, structural and cultural barriers persist. In the Asia-Pacific region, female doctors frequently face a "glass ceiling" in leadership and academic roles, often earning less than their male counterparts. The WWPWFM workshop held in Melbourne (2008) sought to address these inequities by applying a participatory action research framework to the regional context.

The Dual Challenge: Professional and Clinical

The workshop identified two primary dimensions of gender inequity:

  1. Professional Inequity: Medical systems often devalue the "emotional work" inherent in family medicine. Female practitioners frequently provide longer, psychosocially-focused consultations—sometimes dismissively labeled "tears and smears" by colleagues. This systemic devaluation impacts both compensation and career advancement.
  2. Clinical Competency: A lack of gender equity in leadership leads to "gender-blind" medicine. For instance, myocardial ischemia often presents differently in women than in men. Without diverse leadership and research, medical education may fail to train doctors to recognize these critical differences, compromising patient care.

Methodology

The findings are based on a structured, full-day pre-conference workshop involving 50 women family physicians from diverse nations, including Australia, New Zealand, the Philippines, Vietnam, Thailand, Indonesia, Pakistan, and India. Using the "2007-2010 Action Plan" formulated in Singapore as a baseline, participants engaged in collaborative workshopping to categorize regional issues and develop consensus-based solutions.

Key Insights: Redefining Value and Visibility

  • Combating Invisibility: Women have historically been underrepresented in plenary positions and leadership roles. The report advocates for explicit policy changes, such as Gender Equity Bylaw Amendments, to ensure structural representation.
  • Valuing Psychosocial Care: There is a pressing need to redefine "quality" in medicine to include the complex, time-intensive consultations often preferred by women, rather than prioritizing high-volume, procedure-oriented metrics.
  • Flexible Training Models: Current "gender-blind" training models often lack the flexibility required for maternity leave or geographic stability, disproportionately affecting women's career trajectories.

Results: A 16-Point Roadmap

The workshop culminated in a refined 16-point Action Plan for the Asia-Pacific region. Key outcomes include:

  • Targeted Projects: Launching a regional survey of trainee needs and developing an internet-based leadership module for mentorship.
  • Policy Integration: Mandating gender equity in core publications and ensuring linguistic diversity in regional communications.
  • Structural Advocacy: Utilizing Wonca as a platform to influence national legislation regarding the working conditions of female practitioners.

Conclusion and Future Work

While many barriers are deeply culturally embedded, the 16-point plan provides a concrete framework for progress. Future efforts will focus on monitoring this roadmap at global congresses, expanding mentorship networks for early-career physicians, and integrating "gender-competent" knowledge into standard medical curricula to improve outcomes for all patients.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Wonca Working Party for Women and Family Medicine (WWPWFM) was organized in 2001 with the following objectives: to identify the key issues for women doctors; to review Wonca policies and procedures for equity and transparency; to provide opportunities to network at meetings and through the group's listserve and website; and to promote women doctors' participation in Wonca initiatives.In October 2008, at the Asia Pacific Regional conference, the Wonca Working Party on Women in Family Medicine (WWPWFM) held a preconference day and conference workshops, building on the success and commitment to initiatives which enhance women's participation in Wonca developed in Ontario, Canada (2006) and at the Singapore World Congress (2007). At this meeting fifty women workshopped issues for women in Family Medicine in the Asia Pacific. Using the Action Plan formulated in Singapore (2007) the participants identified key regional issues and worked towards a solution.Key issues identified were professional issues, training in family medicine and women's health. Solutions were to extend the understanding of women's contributions to family medicine, improved career pathways for women in family medicine and improving women's participation in practices, family medicine organizations and academic meetings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{coles2010making,
  author = {Jan Coles and Amanda S. Barnard and Amanda Howe and Jo Wainer and Zorayda Leopando and Sarah Strasser},
  title = {{Making the 2007-2010 Action Plan work for women in family medicine in the Asia Pacific}},
  booktitle = {Asia},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1186/1447-056x-9-1},
}
Figure