Well-being of Academy Fellows and specialty trainees: what is the problem?

W. P. Leung, Rosalie Lo, Jeremy Yuen-Chun Teoh, Aaron Cheng, Martin C. S. Wong, Gkk LeungHong 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Medical professionals in Hong Kong are facing a critical burnout crisis, with recent data indicating that nearly three-quarters of young doctors suffer from personal and work-related exhaustion. Historically, physician well-being has been treated as a matter of individual resilience. However, the Hong Kong Academy of Medicine (HKAM) has recently shifted this paradigm, introducing a "Well-being Charter" and the "ASAP" strategic framework. This paper outlines the scale of the mental health challenge among Hong Kong’s medical trainees and early-career specialists and details the institutional shift toward a shared-responsibility model for physician wellness.

Introduction

The medical profession is grappling with a global burnout crisis, characterized by emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and a diminished sense of personal accomplishment. In Hong Kong, this issue is particularly acute among "young doctors"—a demographic encompassing residents in training and specialists within their first decade of registration. This editorial addresses the alarming prevalence of mental health struggles in this cohort and argues that physician well-being is not merely a personal attribute but a systemic prerequisite for high-quality patient care and a sustainable healthcare workforce.

The Magnitude of the Problem

The urgency of this intervention is underscored by findings from a territory-wide survey (Kwan et al., 2021) involving Hong Kong’s medical community. Utilizing the Copenhagen Burnout Inventory (CBI) and the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9), the study revealed staggering levels of distress among young practitioners:

  • Personal Burnout: 73% of respondents reported significant personal burnout.
  • Work-related Burnout: 71% identified their professional environment as a primary source of exhaustion.
  • Client-related Burnout: 55% experienced burnout stemming from patient interactions.
  • Depression: 21% of surveyed doctors met the clinical criteria for depression via the PHQ-9.

These figures suggest that the current working environment is unsustainable. When more than two-thirds of the workforce reports burnout, the issue can no longer be framed as a lack of individual "grit." Instead, it indicates a systemic failure that requires institutional and policy-level interventions.

A Shift to Shared Responsibility

A core tenet of the HKAM’s new approach is the rejection of the "individual burden" model. The Academy’s Well-being Charter explicitly defines wellness as a shared responsibility between the individual doctor, the employing institution, and government policymakers. By framing well-being as a fundamental requirement for professional duty, the Charter elevates mental health from a "perk" to a core institutional value.

The ASAP Framework

To operationalize this commitment, the HKAM introduced the ASAP framework, an incremental strategy designed to provide a roadmap for mental health support:

  1. Awareness: Enhancing the ability of clinicians and supervisors to recognize early signs and symptoms of stress and vicarious trauma.
  2. Self-care: Providing practical resources and time-management tools to help doctors prioritize their own health.
  3. Ask for help: Reducing the stigma associated with seeking assistance by facilitating peer support networks and professional counseling services.
  4. Promotion of well-being: Cultivating a supportive organizational culture and advocating for structural changes in workload and resource allocation.

This framework is supported by a centralized web portal and a dedicated Task Force on Well-being, ensuring that doctors have immediate access to self-care tools and peer support mechanisms.

Future Directions and Policy Advocacy

While the introduction of the Well-being Charter and the ASAP framework represents a significant step forward, their long-term success depends on effective implementation across the 15 constituent Colleges of the Academy. Future efforts will focus on three primary areas:

  • Implementation Science: Monitoring how different medical specialties adapt these guidelines to their unique clinical environments.
  • Impact Assessment: Conducting longitudinal follow-up surveys to determine if these institutional changes lead to a statistically significant reduction in CBI and PHQ-9 scores.
  • Systemic Reform: Advocating for government-level policy changes regarding physician workload, shift patterns, and the professional environment.

Conclusion

The high rates of burnout among Hong Kong’s young doctors are a clear signal that the healthcare system must evolve. By moving toward a model of shared responsibility and institutional support, the HKAM aims to ensure that the next generation of medical professionals can flourish, thereby safeguarding the quality of care for the entire community.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{leung2021well,
  author = {W. P. Leung and Rosalie Lo and Jeremy Yuen-Chun Teoh and Aaron Cheng and Martin C. S. Wong and Gkk Leung},
  title = {{Well-being of Academy Fellows and specialty trainees: what is the problem?}},
  booktitle = {Hong},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.12809/hkmj215123},
}
Figure