Study on the work-family role dilemma and intervention mechanism of rural female grassroots managers

Man Tang, Guiqing LiAdvances 2024 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

With the rapid development of China's economy, the country pays more and more attention to the development of rural talents, and has achieved great success in China's rural areas. As rural grassroots female managers, multiple roles and responsibilities conflict and contain each other. It is necessary to make clear the expectations and responsibilities of various roles. In addition to the dual pressure of work and family, rural female managers also suffer from the public opinion of "budding" of local human feelings. This paper mainly analyzes the plight of rural female grassroots managers, and puts forward reasonable solutions to the existing contradictions, in order to form a strong support for women's social status and role dilemma.

Introduction

As China’s rural economy undergoes rapid transformation, women are increasingly assuming leadership positions within grassroots management. However, these professional advancements often collide with deeply entrenched traditional patriarchal values, such as the "three obediences and four virtues." Rural female managers face a unique "double burden": they must be decisive leaders in the workplace while remaining submissive or primary domestic caregivers at home. This role conflict frequently results in psychological exhaustion, community pressure, and strained interpersonal relationships. This study identifies the roots of these tensions and proposes a systemic framework to alleviate the role dilemma.

Methodology

The researchers employed a qualitative approach centered on semi-structured interviews to capture a comprehensive view of the dilemma. The study involved 10 participants:

  • Five female grassroots managers from township enterprises, who provided insights into their lived experiences balancing family and professional duties.
  • Five male managers, who offered a male perspective on the systemic challenges women face in these roles.

The qualitative data gathered from these interviews served as the foundation for synthesizing common "pressure points" and developing a multi-dimensional intervention strategy.

The Nature of the Role Dilemma

The study highlights several cultural stressors specific to the rural Chinese context:

  • Intergenerational Conflict: The relationship between a daughter-in-law and her mother-in-law is a significant source of friction. Professional independence often clashes with traditional domestic authority, leading to isolation.
  • Domestic Inequality: Many husbands adopt a "shopkeeper" role, remaining present but contributing little to household labor, leaving the female manager to handle the entirety of the "second shift."
  • Social Capital and Public Opinion: Rural managers are subject to local gossip. Success at work is often misinterpreted as neglect of family duties, which can damage a woman's social standing within the community.
  • Institutional Discrimination: Recruitment processes often include discriminatory inquiries regarding child-bearing plans, leading some firms to avoid hiring women to minimize perceived costs.

Proposed Intervention Mechanism

To address these challenges, the authors propose a four-tiered intervention framework designed to move from the initial dilemma toward a sustainable solution that improves social happiness and women's sense of gain.

Figure 1: Conceptual framework for the multi-level intervention mechanism addressing the work-family role dilemma.

As illustrated in the framework above, the intervention spans four critical levels:

  1. Social Level: Focuses on strengthening legal aid for domestic issues, providing targeted health screenings to reduce economic stress, and increasing government oversight of gender discrimination in hiring.
  2. Work Level: Encourages "flexible management" styles and professional boundary-setting to help women maintain competitiveness.
  3. Family Level: Advocates for breaking the "rigid division of labor" by encouraging husbands to share domestic responsibilities.
  4. Individual Level: Promotes continuous education in management and the development of a "professional brand" to enhance authority and self-efficacy.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While this study provides a valuable theoretical framework, it is limited by its small sample size (n=10), which may not represent the full diversity of rural China. Future research should focus on empirical testing of these interventions and the creation of specialized government agencies dedicated to cohesive family policy. Increasing female participation in policy drafting is essential to ensure that support systems are effectively tailored to the realities of rural grassroots management.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the rapid development of China's economy, the country pays more and more attention to the development of rural talents, and has achieved great success in China's rural areas.As rural grassroots female managers, multiple roles and responsibilities conflict and contain each other.It is necessary to make clear the expectations and responsibilities of various roles.In addition to the dual pressure of work and family, rural female managers also suffer from the public opinion of "budding" of local human feelings.This paper mainly analyzes the plight of rural female grassroots managers, and puts forward reasonable solutions to the existing contradictions, in order to form a strong support for women's social status and role dilemma.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tang2024study,
  author = {Man Tang and Guiqing Li},
  title = {{Study on the work-family role dilemma and intervention mechanism of rural female grassroots managers}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2991/978-2-38476-277-4\_153},
}
Figure