Abstract
Closing the gender gap or achieving gender equality is a common goal in many fields. Achieving gender equality has positive impacts, such as increased diversity and specialized knowledge. A gender gap has been observed across various medical specialties, although recent trends suggest a gradual improvement in gender balance. Understanding the gender ratio in academic publications within this field can be considered essential for developing strategies to address gender disparities in dental anesthesiology academia. However, to date, no investigations have examined trends in authorship by gender in dental anesthesiology. We hypothesized that the gender gap in dental anesthesiology academic publications would also narrow. To test this hypothesis, we investigated the gender of the first author in Anesthesia Progress, the longest-running and most prolific journal in dental anesthesiology, over two periods. A total of 209 articles published between 2000 and 2003 and between 2020 and 2023 were collected from the Scopus database. For all collected articles, data including "first author," "affiliation (country)," and "article type" were extracted. The first author was classified as female or male; the affiliation (country) as US, Japan, or other countries; and the type of article as "Review," "Scientific report," or "Case report." Statistical analyses were performed using numerical data on the number of articles by gender and time period. Pearson's chi-square test or Yates' continuity-corrected chi-square test was applied with a significance level of 5%. The percentage of articles with female first authors increased significantly, from 19.2% (10/52) in the 2000s to 34.0% (49/144) in the 2020s (P = 0.046). By country, the percentage of female first authors decreased in the US but increased in Japan and other countries. Notably, in Japan, the proportion of female first authors rose significantly from 1.9% (1/52) in the 2000s to 22.2% (32/144) in the 2020s (P = 0.002). Regarding the types of articles submitted by female first authors, the number of "Scientific report" articles markedly decreased in the US, whereas the number of "Case report" articles significantly increased in Japan. The investigation revealed that the gender gap in dental anesthesiology has narrowed in terms of total representation; however, the extent of this gap differs from country to country. Regular statistical bibliometric analyses could provide more insights into closing the gender gap.
Introduction
Gender equality is a recognized goal across scientific and medical disciplines, as diverse teams drive better research, innovation, and patient care. While many medical specialties have tracked and actively addressed the "leaky pipeline" of female researchers in academia, dental anesthesiology has lacked comprehensive data on this issue.
In academic medicine, publication—specifically first authorship—is a primary metric for career advancement, funding, and academic productivity. Without baseline data on how gender representation in dental anesthesiology literature has evolved, it is impossible to know if the field is progressing toward equity or to design effective, targeted interventions. This study presents the first bibliometric analysis of gender disparities in dental anesthesiology research by examining first authorship trends in the field's leading journal, Anesthesia Progress.
Methods and Materials
The researchers conducted a retrospective bibliometric analysis focusing on Anesthesia Progress, the longest-running and most prolific journal dedicated to dental anesthesiology. The study compared two distinct four-year periods to measure longitudinal change: the early 2000s (2000–2003) and the early 2020s (2020–2023).
Data was extracted from the Scopus database. For each article, the researchers identified the first author's name, affiliation country, and the article type (Review, Scientific Report, or Case Report). Because the database does not explicitly list gender, the authors manually inferred the gender of the first authors by cross-referencing names with official institutional profiles, the Japanese Ministry of Health's physician directory, and contextual clues from public photos.
After excluding non-research items like editorials, comments, and errata, the final dataset consisted of 196 peer-reviewed articles: 52 from the 2000s and 144 from the 2020s. Statistical significance was evaluated using Pearson’s chi-square test and Yates’ continuity-corrected chi-square test.
Results
The analysis revealed that while overall progress is happening, it is not universal across regions.
Global Trends
Female first authorship across all regions increased significantly from 19.2% (10/52 articles) in the 2000s to 34.0% (49/144 articles) in the 2020s (P = 0.046). This jump suggests that global initiatives to support women in STEM and medicine are having a tangible impact.
Regional Divergence
The aggregate data masks stark, highly localized contrasts:
- United States: Surprisingly, the US saw a decrease in female first authors, with the proportion dropping from 15.4% to 9.0%. Notably, US female-authored "Scientific reports"—which typically require heavy funding and institutional support—fell from 15.4% to just 4.2%.
- Japan: Japan experienced a massive increase in female first authorship, skyrocketing from 1.9% to 22.2% (P = 0.002). This was heavily supported by an increase in "Case reports," which jumped from 1.9% to 18.0%.
- Other Countries: This group showed a negligible increase from 1.9% to 2.8%.
Discussion
The findings suggest that institutional structures play a significant role in authorship trends. In Japan, the dramatic surge is likely linked to a specific mandate: the Japanese Dental Society of Anesthesiology requires publication in Anesthesia Progress as a prerequisite for board certification. This institutional push is successfully bringing more female clinical practitioners into academic publishing, albeit primarily through case reports.
Conversely, the decline in the US may be due to systemic issues prevalent in Western academia, such as lack of research funding, prejudice regarding research reliability, childcare burdens, and a "leaky pipeline" where female researchers drop off before advancing to senior academic or mentorship roles. The sharp drop in scientific reports by female authors in the US is particularly concerning, as these publications are often critical for high-level academic tenure.
Conclusion
This investigation reveals that the gender gap in dental anesthesiology has narrowed in terms of total representation, but the extent of this progress varies significantly by country. While institutional mandates in Japan have successfully increased female participation, the decline in the US highlights ongoing barriers to equity.
The study is limited by its reliance on a single journal and the manual inference of gender. Future research should expand to include other specialized journals and analyze the gender of last authors to better understand disparities in mentorship and senior research leadership. Regular statistical bibliometric analyses remain essential for tracking progress and closing the gender gap in dental anesthesiology.
Summary updated