Les Pays-Bas aux XVIIe et XVIIIesiècles. Nouveaux regards, C. Secretan et D. Antoine-Mahut (éds.)

Péter BalázsStudi 2017 · DOI

Introduction

The 17th and 18th centuries in the Netherlands, often heralded as the "Golden Age," are frequently shrouded in hagiographic myths and simplified historical narratives. In a review published in the journal Studi Francesi, Peter Balazs evaluates a significant collective volume edited by Catherine Secretan and Delphine Antoine-Mahut: Les Pays-Bas aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Nouveaux regards. This multidisciplinary work seeks to dismantle these myths by exploring the complex intersections of philosophy, art, and politics.

The review was published in the journal Studi Francesi.

Challenging Historiographical Presentism

A central theme of the volume, introduced by Willem Frijhoff, is the danger of "presentism"—the tendency to interpret historical events solely through the lens of modern concerns. Frijhoff argues that this approach often leads to the neglect of historical causality. By deconstructing how the "Golden Age" narrative was originally constructed, the contributors aim to restore a more nuanced understanding of Dutch identity and its evolution, moving beyond nationalistic models.

The Cartesian Network and Minor Media

One of the most persistent intellectual myths is that René Descartes lived in relative isolation during his time in the Netherlands. Theo Verbeek’s research within the volume challenges this, demonstrating that Descartes was deeply integrated into Dutch intellectual life. Rather than being a solitary figure, he was "adopted" by local thinkers, and his ideas were disseminated through various channels.

Interestingly, Erik-Jan Bos highlights the role of "minor" media in this dissemination. Instead of relying solely on dense philosophical treatises, Cartesianism spread through mnemonic formulas and simplified supports created by figures like Henricus Regius. This suggests that the mass reception of complex ideas often depends on accessible, non-traditional formats rather than just major academic works.

Art as Philosophical Evidence

The volume excels in its interdisciplinary approach, particularly in bridging the gap between philosophy and art history. Laurent Bove, for instance, analyzes the concept of "the multitude" by comparing the visual representations in Pieter Bruegel the Elder’s paintings with the philosophical frameworks of Baruch Spinoza. This synthesis allows for a deeper understanding of how social and political concepts were visualized and debated during the period.

Furthermore, the study of "visual studies" frameworks from the 19th century is applied to 17th-century religious propaganda. This reveals how "spiritual testaments" were used for both Catholic and Protestant indoctrination, highlighting the sophisticated use of visual media in religious discourse and how subversive ideas were often broadcast or hidden through "Tacitism" (the influence of the Roman historian Tacitus).

The Socio-Political Foundations of Competence

Catherine Secretan provides a historical genealogy of the modern concept of "competence," tracing it back to the specific economic, bureaucratic, and political requirements of the emerging Dutch state. This suggests that professional standards were not abstract ideals but practical responses to the needs of a growing maritime and commercial power.

The volume also explores the paradox of religious pluralism in cities like Utrecht. While the Netherlands is often praised for its "tolerance," the contributors show that this was a messy reality. Confessional borders often "hardened" institutionally even as they were practically "transcended" in daily interactions, driven by competing philosophical and theological doubts.

Conclusion

By moving beyond siloed research, Les Pays-Bas aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Nouveaux regards provides a vital update to Dutch historiography. It demonstrates that the intellectual and cultural landscape of the Netherlands was a laboratory for modern ideas—not through isolated genius, but through a complex web of interaction, media, and practical necessity. As Balazs notes, the volume successfully encourages scholars to look past the "Golden Age" veneer to find the intricate causalities beneath.

Summary updated

Abstract

L’Introduction des rédacteurs, suivie de l’étude de Willem Frijhoff (La perception identitaire et son influence sur l’historiographie. Réflexions sur les Pays-Bas et leur Siècle d’Or, pp. 21-48), nous introduit dans le débat historiographique contemporain et ses répercussions sur l’actualité néerlandaise. L’auteur regrette surtout les conquêtes récentes du présentisme et l’oubli de la notion de la causalité historique. Dans la suite, Theo Verbeek (Étudier l’histoire du cartésianisme néerlanda...
BibTeX
@inproceedings{balazs2017les,
  author = {Péter Balázs},
  title = {{Les Pays-Bas aux XVIIe et XVIIIesiècles. Nouveaux regards, C. Secretan et D. Antoine-Mahut (éds.)}},
  booktitle = {Studi},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.4000/studifrancesi.9950},
}
Figure