Introduction
The history of science is frequently presented as a series of clean, revolutionary breaks—paradigm shifts where one worldview is instantly discarded in favor of a superior successor. One of the most enduring of these narratives is the transition from Cartesian mechanism to Newtonian physics in the early 18th century. In the popular imagination, René Descartes’ universe of vortices and contact mechanics was swept away almost overnight by the mathematical elegance of Isaac Newton’s universal gravitation. However, in his work Les cartésiens face à Newton, Carlo Borghero challenges this oversimplification, revealing a complex period of intellectual "trench warfare" and hybrid theories.
The Myth of Sudden Obsolescence
Borghero, through a series of lectures at the École Pratique des Hautes Études, argues that the narrative of Cartesianism’s sudden death around 1730 is largely a myth. This myth was popularized by figures like Voltaire, who sought to frame the adoption of Newtonianism as a triumph of Enlightenment reason over outdated dogma. In reality, Cartesianism remained a vigorous and influential framework for decades after Newton’s Principia began to circulate in France.
The "problem" facing 18th-century intellectuals was not a simple choice between two competing sets of equations. Rather, it was a struggle to reconcile Newton’s undeniable mathematical accuracy with the philosophical and theological foundations of the time. While Newton could describe how gravity worked with unprecedented precision, he famously declined to provide a mechanical cause for it (hypotheses non fingo). To many Cartesians, "attraction at a distance" felt like a return to the "occult qualities" of Scholasticism—a mysterious force acting through a vacuum without physical contact.
The Rise of "Newtonized" Cartesianism
Instead of immediate surrender, many French and Italian thinkers attempted to "Newtonize" Cartesianism. Borghero highlights the work of transitionary figures like Privat de Molières and Joseph-Adrien Lelarge de Lignac. These scholars sought to create a "reformed" Cartesianism that could accommodate Newtonian experimental data while preserving the mechanical "plenum"—the idea that space is full of matter and that all motion occurs through direct contact.
In these hybrid models, the famous Cartesian "tourbillons" (vortices) were not discarded. Instead, they were mathematically refined. Thinkers like Molières tried to explain gravity as a result of mechanical pressure within these vortices, essentially attempting to derive Newtonian results from Cartesian premises. This period of "hybridity" shows that the scientific revolution was less a sudden coup and more a slow, messy evolution of ideas.
Metaphysical and Theological Stakes
The resistance to Newton was not merely a matter of physics; it was deeply rooted in the defense of religious and philosophical traditions. Borghero emphasizes that for thinkers like Hyacinthe Sigismond Gerdil, the stakes were nothing less than the nature of the soul.
The Cartesian divide between res extensa (matter) and res cogitans (mind/soul) provided a clear safeguard for religious doctrine. If matter was purely passive and moved only by contact, then "thought" and "will" must belong to a separate, spiritual substance. However, if matter possessed an inherent power of "attraction" (as Newton’s theory seemed to suggest to some), it opened a dangerous door. If matter could act at a distance, could it not also, perhaps, think? This fear linked the critique of Newton to a critique of John Locke’s empiricism. For the Cartesians, defending the mechanical plenum was a way of defending the spiritual nature of the soul against the perceived threat of materialism and atheism.
The Materialist Irony
One of the most fascinating insights in Borghero’s analysis is the historical irony of the Cartesian position. While the Cartesians fought to preserve a spiritual worldview through mechanism, their insistence on a purely mechanical universe eventually provided the foundation for the very materialism they feared. Later in the century, radical thinkers like Julien Offray de La Mettrie would take the Cartesian "animal-machine" to its logical conclusion, arguing that humans themselves were entirely material mechanisms, thereby discarding the soul that the original Cartesians had worked so hard to protect.
Conclusion
Carlo Borghero’s Les cartésiens face à Newton provides a necessary correction to the history of the Enlightenment. By mapping the intellectual multi-polarity of the era—including the influence of Leibnizians and Jesuits like Father Castel—Borghero shows that the 18th century was a time of profound synthesis and struggle. Cartesianism did not vanish; it evolved, fought, and eventually merged into a new scientific consensus. This work serves as a reminder that science does not exist in a vacuum; it is always inextricably linked to the broader philosophical and theological debates of its time.
Summary updated